Test Match Special - Huge Ashes injury blow for Australia

Episode Date: November 15, 2025

Jonathan Agnew and Stephan Shemilt round up all the Ashes tour news including details of England’s win against the Lions with Ollie Pope again in the runs, and we get an Australian view from ABC Rad...io reporter Mitch Turner plus England fast bowler Brydon Carse joins the podcast.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Bring more gear, carry more passengers, face greater challenges. Welcome to the world of Defender, with seating up to eight, ample cargo space, and legendary off-road capability. It's built to make the most of every adventure. Learn more at landrover.ca. You're listening to the TMS podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live. Hello, I'm Stefan Shemmelt and welcome to the Test Match Special podcast on England's Ashes Tour. Today there's been a significant blow for Australia ahead of the first test with Josh Hazelwood ruled out, but better news for England with the result of Mark Wood's scan.
Starting point is 00:00:46 We'll have all the news of that, plus round up the action from England's win against the Lions with Ollie Pope again in the runs. We'll be joined by Jonathan Agnew and get the Australian news. view from ABC reporter Mitch Turner plus England fast bowler, Bride and Kass. You're listening to the TMS podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live. Well, welcome back to Perth. Night has fallen. We're in the city centre. It's the end of what's been a busy day. We've had two significant pieces of news off the field, as well as England beating the England Lions in their warm-up game on the field. Before, play we had confirmation from England that Mark Wood's scan had shown no issues around the left
Starting point is 00:01:34 hamstring which caused him some concerns on the first day 90 minutes later we had more news this time from cricket Australia telling us that Josh Hazelwood will miss the first test with a muscle strain in his own hamstring remember a couple of days ago he walked off the field in New South Wales a Sheffield Shield game against Victoria we thought he was was okay, he had a scan. Now another scan has revealed the injury. Michael Nisa has come into Australia's squad. On the field, less eventful. England chased down 202 to beat the Lions. Olly Pope made 90 to add to the century he scored yesterday. Jacob Bethel made 70 playing for the Lions and probably a little bit too late his return to form to push a case for a place in the first test.
Starting point is 00:02:27 There are also half centuries for Ben McKinney and Jordan Cox, England hopefuls of the future. On the bowling front, Mark Wood didn't take the field, but Bradencast did. It's his first bowl of the tour. He missed the first day of the tour game with illness. He took three wickets, and I spoke to him after play. You know, the last couple of days, good to be back out here, and today to bowl a couple of spells and, you know, get some miles in my legs again. It's a good feeling. You obviously missed the first day.
Starting point is 00:02:53 Do you feel like you're back up to speed? Yeah, 100%. I just had a bit of a 24-hour bug. But, yeah, obviously yesterday, done a bit of training and then today to be able to bowl 12 overs out there today, I feel good again. Three days here at Lila Kill for the team. Do you feel like the whole squad has got what they needed out of this game?
Starting point is 00:03:13 Definitely, I think you look across, you know, now the group of seamers have all got a decent amount of overs in and some of the batters have spent some time at the crease. So, you know, we've got a couple of days off now and then three or four days of prep. leading into that first test. We heard this morning that Mark Wood has been cleared of any concerns over that hamstring.
Starting point is 00:03:33 How much of a relief is that for him and for the rest of the squad? Yeah, that's great news, you know, when Woody found out last night that it's nothing serious. So, you know, he's going to, again, have a couple of days off and then have a good bit of training up,
Starting point is 00:03:47 leading up to that first test. How concerning had that been over the past couple of days waiting to hear about that? Oh, you know, I think for any player, You know, when you're waiting on a result of a scan, it can be a little bit niggly, but, you know, he was fairly confident that it was going to be nothing serious, and he's obviously received that positive news, so, you know, he's all up and about and full of energy at the moment. Everything that he's gone through to get his body on the park, it's tough bowling fast. I mean, as a character, I mean, he's incredibly tough, isn't he to want to keep doing that and keep coming back?
Starting point is 00:04:19 Yeah, he's got a, you know, a huge amount of resilience. You know, you look back at some of the setbacks that he's had over his career. to keep coming out and keep going through the processes to get back out on the field it's very exciting and it shows the sort of character that he has we've heard today that Josh Hazelwood
Starting point is 00:04:36 has been ruled out of the first test what's your reaction to that? Has he? He has? Right, you're the first person telling me look he's obviously a massive bowler for Australia and I'm sure now we'll certainly see some part of him throughout the series and yeah
Starting point is 00:04:54 Is he a bowler that you've ever looked at or looked up to with the skills that he's got? He's certainly a bowler that I've admired throughout my career and the performances and his importance to Australian cricket has been someone to look up to. So yeah, he's a phenomenal bowler. Here we are talking about injuries to fast bowlers. Mark Wood has come through one, Josh Hazelwood has suffered one. What is it like as a bowler to put yourself, to put yourself, through that to try and hurt the ball down 22 yards as fast as you can.
Starting point is 00:05:28 That's hard work at times, but you know that's part and parcel of the job. You know, we've got a great, you know, support staff that help us get out on that field and, you know, get us 100% match ready. You've done all you can now to prepare for the first test, certainly on the field. The next time we'll be on there is playing in it. Have you allowed yourself to think about what it's going to be like? It's going to be amazing. You know, the opportunity comes.
Starting point is 00:05:50 It's something that I'm looking forward to taking. You know, the guys have all had a good three days out here, and some guys have been out here a bit longer, and some guys have been in New Zealand. So, you know, the group of players have had a lot of cricket over the last couple of months and obviously the back end of the English summer. So, yeah, everyone's wearing to go. We're told that Optus pitch can be a little bit spicy. You're excited to have a go on that? Yeah, of course. You know, it might be a little bit different to this week's preparation, but, you know, this week was all about bowlers getting, you know, miles in their legs.
Starting point is 00:06:20 So, yeah, look, it's exciting. I think we've got a group of six bowlers who, whatever dynamic we go with, were relish in those conditions. Well, that was Bright and Cars, and from one big, nasty England fast bowler to another, and with Jonathan Agnew. It's been a long day, Steph. I've flown from Sydney, which as everyone knows, about a five and a half hour flight, three-hour time change, and it feels like it's the middle of the night. When was the last time you were called a nasty fast bowler? Very long time ago. A very long time ago. But no, it's just great to be.
Starting point is 00:06:52 back on the tour again, you know, I've been having to have a couple of weeks in Sydney, and there's a huge anticipation there. I mean, there really is. And actually, funnily enough, I went to watch New South Wales against Victoria the day, the SCG, and they were amazed by how many people were there, you know, the spectators. And that's because cricket is being talked about. I mean, they really was, the pavilion and the ladies' pavilion there was, it was full. Not the SCG, but that area in which you're allowed in. And there was a real anticipation about it. Yes, because a lot of the Australian, players were playing as well of course including Hazelwood who I watched Bowl on the first day and he's his usual rhythmic pounding away at a length self and then of course comes the news that a has gone off but he's okay and then today up in the air comes the news that he's out of the game so that's that's you know clearly a huge talking point as far as as as
Starting point is 00:07:48 far as England are concerned they they've got a great chance you know and you don't to profit on injury you know you want to play the best team and you don't want at the end of Sydney when England win the ashes of yeah mate but Cummins and Hazelwood didn't play and you don't want to hear that you want to beat the best team however that's the team they're up against you go out there and beat them and it's they've got a much better chance now than they did a couple days ago I wanted to call this podcast hamstrung and hamstrung but producer Adam he wasn't happy with it well it is it does feel like a sort of a hamstringy
Starting point is 00:08:20 sort of a debate doesn't it because Mark Wood, of course. What are they going to do with Mark Wood? I mean, you just can't help but feel that he is fragile now. That's his first runout since February. And it just shows you can do all the training, you can do all the weight training, and do all the sprinting around, running about.
Starting point is 00:08:41 And I mean, I saw him at the end of the summer at the Oval running in and bowling. And I said, how's he coming on? Oh, I'm doing really nicely. First runout properly in the game, and, you know, you have an issue. Now, okay, he hasn't done. any damage so we think but you know the fact he's had to go off it had to go for a scan
Starting point is 00:08:58 it's because it gets in your head after a while as well how am i ever going to play at this level again that that's the sort of stuff that goes around in in a fast bowler's head inevitably because of the thing as Mark Wood every ball is a hundred percent effort there's no subtlety you know he doesn't run in and bold this and that he just tears in he's not a big bloke he's actually quite a slight fellow he's physically strong but he's not your typical sort of big strong
Starting point is 00:09:28 he's not a hazelwood every ball is a hundred percent effort and if after one run out he's already feeling a bit creaky in a handstring you do have to wonder what sort of party can play in this well I've got a theory though on this and
Starting point is 00:09:45 I think England showed their hand in the warm up game against the Lions by the England 11 in inverted commas it was five seamers four specialists plus Ben Stokes
Starting point is 00:09:58 showed Bashir in the Lions to me that is a big hint that they want to play five seamers at the Optus for reasons that we know why the Optus is spicy it's bouncy and in general actually
Starting point is 00:10:09 spin has played quite a diminished role in test cricket in Australia over the past decade so if the plan is to play five seamers and remains to play five seamers, is that not the time when you can actually look after Mark Wood
Starting point is 00:10:25 a little bit more, because he's got that protection around him, and if England only need him to bowl 8, 12 overs a day, 3, 4 over spells, won a session, is that the risk that they will now have to weigh up between now and Friday? I think it's a good point, and it's certainly manageable, isn't it? They're not going to play a spinner. They might play Will Jacks, I think we talked about it earlier, and I agree, I think he looks a more likely bet to play as a spinner with Root as well than Bashir does, I'm afraid.
Starting point is 00:10:56 I think he's struggling at the moment. But anyway, that's a different point. Five seamers, I mean, it's not often done. It's not often done. And you often say don't do it because the fifth seamer isn't bowl enough. Well, exactly. But actually, you're right. If you don't want your fifth seamer to bowl too much.
Starting point is 00:11:11 And there's still that question of Stokes, isn't there? Do you really want Ben Stokes to be bowling 20 overs a day? Actually, probably not. you've actually got two to look after. I can see Atkinson and Carr's doing a lot of bowling on this tour and he got Joffar Archer as well. Again, you know, you're just slightly being careful of, aren't you? So that might be a way of managing their attack.
Starting point is 00:11:31 Daynighter in Brisbane coming up. You know, the pink ball there could be interesting. With a big gap between the two. Yeah, absolutely. So you could give someone a bit of a rest. No, I suspect they've got most of their plans formulated by now. but I suspect that was very definitely one of their options because there are people listening to this
Starting point is 00:11:51 who are saying what are you talking about it is far too big a risk to play Mark Wood after no cricket since February on the first day he goes on to the field he pulls up with some hamstring tightness but I think I would argue it would be a bigger risk to bringing him later in the series when England have to play a spinner
Starting point is 00:12:12 and he's one as four Yeah, no, I can absolutely see your argument, I can. And if he blows up in this test, well, you know, they're still forcing bowlers and wood blows up and that's that. So, no, I do get that. And there is, there's him, there's Archer and there's Stokes, who you just have to be a little bit careful of. And, yeah, that could well be. I just really hope that England make the most of this opportunity. You know, because it is, I mean, cricky, no Cummins or Hazelwood.
Starting point is 00:12:43 They are the steady eddy bowlers for Australia and a lot more than that besides. They are quality bowlers. They give control to Steve Smith, the captain. Now they are such good bowlers to be missing both of them. It was a massive blow. I did watch Doggett bowling though. I saw him bowling for South Australia against Tasmania. He picked up wickets and actually he looked.
Starting point is 00:13:05 I mean he's 31, he's been around a while. But he bowled at a decent pace but he bowled a good length, a foolish length for Australia and he swung the balled. He bowled genuine out-swingers and was getting batswain caught in the slip cordon era. So, you know, he looked decent, but, you know, it would be his first game. Well, Brendan Dogg, it's 31. He won't be over-rored. You think not, because he's got that experience in Sheffield Shield cricket. I've heard former bowlers like Ryan Harris and Jason Gillespie talk him up.
Starting point is 00:13:35 Ryan Harris is his coach at South Australia. In terms of the opportunity, I totally agree with you in that, you know, Cummins and Hazelwood to be missing, but we're in this situation four years ago. Hazelwood only played one of the five tests, and Cummins missed the second one with a COVID scare. Australia still won the series four nil. The thing I find interesting about Cummins and Hazelwood missing out is that if England were going to basball anyone, the seamers that Australia are left with are Mitchell Stark, who can be wayward, and Scott Boland, who England got after,
Starting point is 00:14:12 two years ago the other thing I'm going to throw into the mix is there seems to be a little bit of debate over where the Nathan Lion plays in that test I'll go back to this game I watched the other day and Smith used him brilliantly he bowed one over
Starting point is 00:14:28 got a wicket, the first wicket actually took him off and then he came back again and got the Centura now I mean he's a good bowler he'd be delighted if he doesn't play wouldn't they yeah I just think that Smith now he's going to have to He's going to have to have his experience.
Starting point is 00:14:43 I just think he's going to have to play Lion. You know, if you have got Nisa or Dogger or these guys playing alongside Bowling and Stark, he's going to want some control. And Lion does bowl well against England. They do respect him. So you're talking about England's opportunity, and I think everyone can agree now this is a golden opportunity.
Starting point is 00:15:05 And we need them to start well because there is no way back, is there? from realistic, from going behind in the way I think it's a first test it's very, very difficult to get back. But what about this idea of preparation then
Starting point is 00:15:19 and this is the golden opportunity where there or not and we'll judge England on the result weren't we? Their preparation we will judge it on the result now my personal theory is the quality that they could have
Starting point is 00:15:34 had without some outside assistance from cricket Australia the quality of the opposition they had this week was about the best they could have done. That was what was in their control. The conditions were totally different to what they'll face at the optus. Slow low pitch at Lila Kill, not much of a crowd, not much abuse. I don't know what more they could have done in the circumstances. It's whether or not the circumstances can ever be changed, isn't it? Yeah, but it's a totally valid conversation. I mean for Stokes to get angry with Botham and Vaughn for it's a
Starting point is 00:16:06 totally valid conversation. A three-day match amongst yourselves. A up for an ashes series. I mean, that's totally unprecedented. But it is, it's their decision. And all you hope at the end of this series is that they will all look in the mirror, that Duncan Fletroy has talked about, and really believe that they give themselves the best chance. You know, this is, this is their opportunity of a lifetime to go to Australia and to win the ashes. People talk about that for years. Ben Stokes as captain, yeah, you know, to win the ashes. People still talk about Ray Lingworth doing it in the early 70s. You know, it happens so infrequently.
Starting point is 00:16:43 And they've made this choice. It might suit them, you're right? I mean, what worries me a little, well, there are two things. I'd like them to have had a bit of experience of Australians, batting, particularly, because Australians batte differently to English bats. They're back-foot players, they cut, they pull, you know, it's just different.
Starting point is 00:17:00 The language is different. Everything's different when you're playing against the Australians. And the crowd, you know, that's another thing that, If they've played here at the Wacker against Western Australia, Australia A, and again, I would just urge ICC to make a test series. However long the test is, there must always be, for my money, included a match against the hosts A team. I just think that suits everybody. It helps the hosts, it helps the tourists, and it helps test cricket, because everyone's better prepared. But anyway, that's the thing for me, that, yeah, I get your argument that there was no guarantee of the cost.
Starting point is 00:17:36 quality that they would have faced. And they've made this decision, well, that's their decision. But to question it is entirely valid, entirely valid, and it's up to Stokes, isn't it? It's up to him and his team to make the most of it. How many Ashes Tours is this for you? I don't know. 10 is it?
Starting point is 00:17:55 Thank you, Adam. Yeah, I don't know, I mean, that seems, yeah, it seems extraordinary. 10 series here, I think it's about, I think, is it 20 overall, something like that, 19 or 20? And what are we? six days out from the first test now, still get that tingle? Oh yeah, absolutely.
Starting point is 00:18:11 I mean, I've been in Sydney for two weeks doing other things and, you know, to get on the plane and come here today, I'm really looking forward to it. I can't wait to get, you know, see the practice, just catch up with everybody. That's the lowest thing about the Ashes and the Ashes tours, you know, meeting up with your old mates in the commentary boxes and, you know, life goes on after cricket when you've been doing this for a while. Just to catch up with Mark Taylor and Mark Boar and, you know, Adam Gilchrist, people like that, you know, who have become good mates through doing this job.
Starting point is 00:18:40 And, you know, Jim Maxwell, of course, who I saw the other day on very good form in Sydney. You know, he'll be part of our team again, and I'll be going on the ABC. And that amazing connection that ABC radio has with the whole of Australia. You know, there's no other radio station that gets blanket coverage of this vast country. And there they all are, and they're combines, tractors, or whatever they're doing, listening to the cricket. It's the connection. And of those tours that you've done to this country, has it ever been like this, the build up,
Starting point is 00:19:13 the frenzy, the hype? Is it a different level this time? Well, in the 90s, it was a bit more hostile because Australia was sure they were gonna win. They just, they had Warren McGraw and the rest, and they just knew they were gonna win. So there's a lot of, oh, geez, why are we playing bothering with five tests?
Starting point is 00:19:32 You know, oh, just make it competitive this time. You'd hear that sort of whiny, whingey stuff. You'd think, oh, shut up. 2010-11, when they should have won at the Gabba and didn't. You know, Cook, Trot, batting brilliantly, saving that game to then go on and win from there. But this feels definitely the best opportunity that England have had since then. I mean, I'm a bit with Stuart Broad about the last tour, the COVID tour.
Starting point is 00:20:00 Very difficult, really, to judge on that. It was a horrible tour. No one could go out, no one could practice. No, it was a, it was a tick the box tour to get it done. This is different. This is different. And to have this opportunity that England have now at the start of it is very exciting. You're listening to the TMS podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live.
Starting point is 00:20:23 So that was Jonathan Agnew and I'm alongside Mitch Turner from the ABC to react to what we've heard today. Mitch, I think like when we turned up at Lila Kill, I was expecting bad news and we got some just not for the team I was expecting to receive bad news absolutely Stefan we arrived here today
Starting point is 00:20:46 thinking what's going to happen with Mark Wood will we see him bowl we knew that he'd had some precautionary scans and were wondering to await the outcome the one we weren't worried about was Josh Hazelwood who we were told was given the all clear within hours
Starting point is 00:21:00 of learning that he had an issue with his hamstring and unfortunately for the Australian camp in that sense. The news came through today that he will not be part of that first test in Perth and it seems to be more positive on the Mark Wood front, not bowling today
Starting point is 00:21:15 at Lila Akeel in this interest squad match if you like but certainly seems like a more positive long-term outlook for Mark Wood and not great for the Australians. So I'm going to ask about you sort of where you think this leaves Australia with not having Josh Hazelwood
Starting point is 00:21:31 as well as Pat Cummins already been ruled out the test. But first, what's gone on there? Because we sort of did a dance on Wednesday when he first went off the field for New South Wales and then Steve Smith spoke to say, I think he's okay, and then we got told he's okay. Now a few days later we're told he's not and he's out of the test. It seems like this is not the first time we've been through something like this with Josh Hazelwood who has struggled to stay on the park for consecutive periods of time. And For long periods of time, he's, for quite a while, he barely managed to play through an entire test series. Certainly in the Australian summers in the hard pitches and the tough conditions on your body.
Starting point is 00:22:13 But the word from cricket Australia was that initial scans sometimes don't pick up these minor strains in the muscle body. So that's what they've told us now. Subsequent scans have picked up that there is an issue with the hamstring and there is a strain there. We were a bit, I guess, taken back by how quickly the news came out the other day when we first heard it. It was remarkable, wasn't it? because Josh Hazelwood had a scan the same day. Mark would have to wait 24 hours to get himself into wherever these things happen. And I'm not sure if it was gamesmanship saying,
Starting point is 00:22:42 look, Mark, you'll have to wait 24 hours. We're not going to sneak you into a scans clinic. I'm sure it wasn't that. And there didn't seem to be a huge amount of concern when Mark Wood left the field here at Lilac Hill the other day. And also with Josh Hazelwood, but we've learnt now that it was more serious than first thought. And they haven't played a lot of cricket without Josh Hazard or Pat Cummins. And this swings things in favour of England, I think, for the first test,
Starting point is 00:23:04 and the English camp would certainly like their chances. There's one point I want to make, before we get into what this means for both teams. We were in a similar situation four years ago. Josh Hazelwood played one test in Brisbane. Pat Cummings was ruled out of the second test because of a COVID scare. And Josh Hazelwood, at that point, suffered a side injury, which meant he missed. the entire series. So, last time around, there was a time when Pat Cummins and Josh Hazelwood weren't in the Australia team for an Ashes test. Australia won that match in Adelaide
Starting point is 00:23:43 and they won the series 4-0. So that's my English pessimism, realism, call it what you will. Is it different this time around? I think it is different given the ageing profile of this bowling attack already. Mitchell Stark and even Scott Boland, who a lot of people might not realize, Scott Boland's in his mid-30s. He's quite far along in his cricketing journey, even though he's early in his test journey. Michael Nisa, the money's been called up, is 35.
Starting point is 00:24:11 Exactly. So Michael Nisa are into the squad. Very experienced, but they're not the youthful bowling lineup that we've had for Australia for the last 10 to 15 years. They are right at the back end of their careers. That includes Josh Hazelwood. Pat Cummins might have a bit longer, but they're not this
Starting point is 00:24:27 sprightly youthful attack that we used to Even Nathan Lyon, who there's whispers going around, he may not even play in Perth given they could go with an all-out pace attack on what will be a fast and bouncy wicket. I just think five years ago they'd be less of a concern covering it. Right now, given that they aren't the young spring chickens that they once were in test cricket, there's a bit more of a concern there.
Starting point is 00:24:48 And their ability to take 20 wickets now, I think, has taken a really big hit and a lot is going to fall on, not just Scott Pond. But Mitch Stark has got to take early wickets for Australia now and we'll get a pretty good indication in the first ovary bowls in Perth whether that's looking likely or not. One thing I thought was interesting when we got that news as well
Starting point is 00:25:05 from Cricket Australia today that Josh Hazelwood is going to miss the first test match is we've had a lot of noises around Pat Cummins to say we think he's on track to play in the second and maybe even actually there's a bit of a school of thought
Starting point is 00:25:17 that Australia might have been a bit too key to rule him out of the first test because we're hearing that actually he's doing okay on the recovery from that back injury but lots of stuff it's going to be fine for the second test and he'll take the captaincy on and all those sorts of things.
Starting point is 00:25:30 There's no suggestion in that statement is there from Cricket Australia today of how long Josh Hazelwood's going to be out for. No, and what we've seen with Josh Hazelwood in the past is that lack of date from Cricket Australia and getting the initial news through that he's had a side strain or he's had a hamstring issue or some of the injuries he's battled through in the past and it's been an open end of date that just kind of gets pushed back and he misses one test Josh Hazard, then he misses a second,
Starting point is 00:25:55 and then all of a sudden it gets midway through the series and the news comes out, he won't take further part in the series. So I think there is concern with Josh Hazel because small niggles and small injuries have gone on to become bigger problems for him. And it almost felt too good to be true with his form with the white ball this summer in Australia. It's been so good that I think there was a few of us around
Starting point is 00:26:15 in the Australian public, certainly that we're thinking this sounds too good to be true. He's bowling as well as he ever has in the short form of the game. and are we waiting for the other shoe to drop and waiting to see if there's something bad's going to happen and it has happened a week out from the first test which is not catastrophic for Australia but I really do think it swings things much further towards England
Starting point is 00:26:39 for that first test which is going to be so big for the summer. I think where the two teams land at the moment is that I think England have got 10 names for the team in the first test inked in and the 11th name would be would if they think he's fit
Starting point is 00:27:00 if it's not would and they want that fifth seamer then Josh Tong would take his place or maybe they may look to tinker the balance of the attack and think about a spin option Australia how many players do they know that are going to
Starting point is 00:27:16 play in the first test because it seems like there could be all sorts of different options and knock-ons to Hazelwood not being available. Does Jake Wetherald open the batting and Cameron Green and both Boewebser players all round options? Does now Weatherald miss out? And Monas Labe Sheen has to open.
Starting point is 00:27:34 Does Nathan Lyon miss out? It just seems like there's, I don't know, such an amount of uncertainty that we're not used to from the Australia cricket team. And it's been like this for probably the last six to eight weeks leading in that every day it feels like that the 11 in everyone's mind is shifted. One day, Manus Lavashane is going to open.
Starting point is 00:27:54 One day, he's going to about three. Boe Webster's ahead of Cam Green, and the next day, Cam Green, is ahead of Bo Webster. Now we're without Pat Cummins in Australia, without Josh Hazelwood as well. So, as you mentioned, it throws things around because at the end of the day, test cricket, you need to take 20 wickets.
Starting point is 00:28:10 And do the Australian selectors feel comfortable that without Pat Cummins and Josh Hazelwood that the rest of their bowling line-up can take 20 wickets? Bo Webster in Red Bull Cricket in first-class cricket this summer has bowed really well in recent times and took wickets in the Sheppard Shield game just the other day. So does
Starting point is 00:28:28 that swing him in front of Cameron Green, who bowled well but only took one wicket from his 16 overs across the match? So does that change the line-up? And do you try and push Marnas-Labashane back to the opening spot to get Cam Green at 3 and Boewebster at 6? I can't remember being this close to
Starting point is 00:28:44 a first test of a summer with this many questions around an Australian 11. There's always been a couple in recent summers who's going to open, but we've kind of known if they land on this decision then this will be the rest of the 11. Right now there is option 1, 2, 3, 4, A, B, C, D. There is every option and we are no closer to knowing what it's going to be and today has just made that even more complicated. I think I'm also right in saying that one of the trepidations that the Australian cricket
Starting point is 00:29:13 fans have around this England team is what they can do with the bat if it goes right. And there were examples of that in the last home ashes in 22. 2003. What about now as well the seamers that are left standing? I mean they feel to me like the ones who could most be bas-balled. England got after Scott Boland a couple of years ago. Of course you got a brilliant record in Australia but it was different in England and sometimes a Mitchell Stark you don't know what you're going to get. You're exactly right. Mitchell Stark you know a sense here in Australia you know within an over or two, maybe even three balls sometimes what you're going to get for Mitchell Stark. If he's swinging the ball early in his innings with the ball, then he's a chance to take wickets. If the swing and the movement sideways isn't there for Mitchell Stark, don't worry about the bounce
Starting point is 00:30:04 and the pace. He relies on that swing and that ball coming back in and challenging the stumps here in Australia and all around the world. So Mitchell Stark, as you said, if he's not moving the ball, then these England batting line up, they could get right on top of it. And Scott Bollins are the same. He, a very good record in Australia and not so good when He went overseas with the ball at the test level, but he needs something in the pitch. He needs a bowling friendly pitch to get something out of it, I feel. You're right, that's probably the concern is the two bowlers that were most susceptible to, I guess, being basbald and being dominated by this English line-up, are the two that are left.
Starting point is 00:30:41 You felt more comfortable with Josh Hazel with the form he'd been in, the extra bounce he gets, he gets the most bounce of the Australian bowlers, and Pat Cummins, who's got so many tricks and it's such a smart bowler. They are left with, if you had to take two out, you probably took Hazelwood out, oh you probably took Boland out and you probably took Mitchell Stark out because Hazelwood and Cummins feel like the two leaders of that attack. And for that reason, to me it would seem crazy for Australia to think about leaving Nathan Lion out for the reasons that he has got a good record against him. I know that the Optus Stadium is you know traditionally favours scene bowlers and Australia
Starting point is 00:31:20 in general actually has favoured scene bowling over the past ten years but if you were to work on the theory of the bowlers that the opposition would least like to face I think Nathan Lyon would be right up there from an England point of view and they would be delighted to see him not in the Australia 11 come next Friday I think as a final thought Mitch I am an Englishman who is I was bought up in the 90s so my Ashes optimism is rarely high from an Australian's point of view are we now both in the same boat that we're both I don't know pessimistic I don't know I mean we're trying to I guess because that is not the Aussie way is it no we are generally a confident
Starting point is 00:32:03 positive nation when it comes to sport when it comes to cricket however we are also much like England but we're ruthless and we can chop people down and we can pick holes in our own lineup just as quickly as we can go after other nations. I feel like there is a lot of concern around the Australian public. Worryed about the batting line up, even the players that we know will be picked in Osmond Kowager, Manas Abashane, haven't made a lot of runs at test level in the last 12 months. So there's concern around that. Now the bowling lineups got massive holes in it. We're both being pessimistic. I was going to say someone has to win. Not necessarily.
Starting point is 00:32:38 We can have a drawn series. However, I do think with the news today around Josh Gaisal, given the Pat Cummins situation, given what we already know with a fragile batting line up and an uncertainty around that, I think the first test really does swing closer to England and that first test will be pivotal to winning throughout this summer and regaining the ashes. Mitch Turner, the ABC. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Starting point is 00:32:59 You're listening to the TMS podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live. So thanks very much to Mitch Turner from ABC Radio. That's it from the Test Match Special. podcast for today. We'll have podcasts every day of this Ashes tour. We're only a few days away from that first test on Friday at Optus Stadium. There'll be live coverage on BBC Sounds with video clips on the BBC Sport website and app and highlights on the IPlayer. That's it for now. We'll speak to you next time.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.