Test Match Special - The Ashes: Wounded Stokes says no place for weak men.
Episode Date: December 7, 2025England finally show some fight, but Australia take two nil Ashes lead.There’s an astonishing interview with England captain Ben Stokes, we hear from coach Brendon McCullum and there’s reaction fr...om Australia captain Steve Smith and player of the match Mitchell Starc. And there’s analysis by Jonathan Agnew, Glenn McGrath, Michael Vaughan, Phi Tufnell, Simon Mann and Andy Zaltzman,
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
This month in football, everything is up for grabs.
The Premier League battles intensify.
The Champions League reaches its crucial turning point
and the World Cup draw sets the stage for the biggest tournament on earth.
Football Daily from the BBC brings you sharp analysis,
instant reaction, expert insight,
and the stories driving the game on and off the pitch.
Your Essential Football Podcast
Delivered every day.
Listen to Football Daily on Spotify
to Football Daily on BBC.com
or wherever you get your podcasts.
You're listening to the TMS podcast
from BBC Radio 5 Live.
Smith, two to win, faces Atkinson,
Atkinson balls to him.
Smith launches it.
It's going out towards Deep Midwicket.
He's finished it off with a six.
emphatic win for Australia they've done it again by eight wickets resistance from
England today but ultimately they have been outplayed by Australia who are two
nil up with three to play and they're not far away from retaining the ashes
Adelaide is next and Australia can do it then well it's a great finish from the
Australian skipper he's becoming a really good interim captain he doesn't lose too many
don't think he's lost yet one six and drawn one he's seven games as interim and that's
another eight-wicket victory pure dominance from Australia just play stronger cricket even
today when England hung in there they fought really hard with the ball and ball with great
consistency so Australia are two-nill-up in this test series they have dominated
for the first three days of the game.
There was some fight from England today.
Ben Stokes making 50 share a partnership of 96 in 36.4 overs with Will Jacks.
To delay the inevitable England, 241 all out.
Atkinson picked up a couple of wickets.
Travis Head, bold for 22, and lavish and got a snortone was caught behind by Jamie Smith for three.
But Steve Smith finished it off, 23 not out, and hitting the last ball for six to give us
Australia there emphatic victory. Michael Vaughn, sum up today from England. What did you see from
England today? Well, I saw more discipline with the bat in hand. Ben Stokes is an incredible leader,
an incredible fight, but Will Jack's played a really strong hand as well. You know, they were
always so far behind the game. The game's been lost in many different areas. You know, day one,
you look at the score of 325 for 9. You think, well, that's quite decent. Realistically,
there were probably 100 light in terms of par.
shot that Harry Brooke played to Mitchell Stark, when England were really dominating the game.
You know, in Australia, you need players to get big hundreds.
And if you keep getting 30s and 40s and fancy 50s, well, that's not going to get you to those really big totals.
With the ball on day two, just got it all wrong in the initial start.
Then they kind of grabbed it back in the middle session.
Then they created chances in the back end of the day.
And the catching just wasn't good enough.
And Australia, they just know how to capitalize.
Australia's skill sets on day three were exceptional.
England made too many mistakes last night.
They needed to arrive here on day four, probably three down.
So that needed a different approach last night.
From the way that I saw, it was like the bas-ball way.
This is the way that we play.
Today wasn't the bas-ball way.
It was attritional.
It was like Stark and bowling yesterday.
But you have to look at Australia's bowling today when the pitch didn't do a great deal,
but they were just so consistent, so consistent, on a length, on a length.
They never kind of went away from the plan.
Every now and again, they bought a few short balls,
but it was hit the off-stump, hit the off-stump.
Michael Nisa and it's quite ironic
Simon that you look at the England side
and they've come down here with a lot of pace
and I'm looking at Australia bowling Nisa Dogget
they're all English style scene bowlers
and I've been here for many many years
and I've seen in the last three or four years
a completely different change to the pitches
and the ball here in Australia
I know the pink ball has been used this week
but the top of off stunt ballers
like an Anson Broad Wokes
they're the type of bowlers that you need here in Australia
of course to have a bit of pace and have a little bit
of change up fantastic but
what I've seen in the last few years
it's top of off that natural pitch up
bowler that can challenge the forward
press challenge that
forward defence you bring your keeper up
that's been a genius move
Alex Carey I think's had as good a game
behind the stumps that I can remember
we've seen Ben folks in
India against the spinning ball
magnificent but Kerry's just given a master
class of how to stand up to
the bouncing ball at times so
brilliant tactics from Australia
England have just got to be honest not enough
players are turning up. You know, you can't win against
Australia in Australia with just three or
four of your players rocking up and performing
to a level and beyond. You need
six, seven, eight players playing
to par at least with three or four playing
exceptional kind of innings or
bowling performances.
Yeah, all facets of England's game.
This week have not quite been good enough.
What did you make of Ben Stokes' approach
today? Liked it.
I think he did what he had to do. He had to try
and take the game deep.
He was just hoping that he could be there for that
second new pink ball. I know that sounds mad under the lights, but it was probably the one
chance England had of scoring quickly. With the old pink ball, it's so hard to score quicker
because it goes so soft. And Steve Smith is a brilliant captain. He does read the game great,
and he kind of plays the in-out field game. It brings them in at the right time to try and force
a shot. Once you get one or two away, he just spreads it. England tried the best, but it was all
too late, you know, and then Geoffrey's spell there and Gus, you look at them and go,
oh, they bowled nicely, but, you know, I want to see my bowler bowling 150,
kilometers an hour on the first morning in Adelaide.
You know, the sun's shining.
I want to see that contest again, Joffre Archer versus Steve Smith.
It was almost too late.
But again, you see that, you know, he's got so much talent.
And he is the one ball that I look at.
I think, if he can just get it right, he could have a Mitchell Stark type of week for England.
And it looks to me like they're going to have to have that kind of week from someone like
Joffre Archer.
They'll have to make change.
You know, you can't keep with the side that have gone too and all down.
There will be changes going into Adelaide.
to what sort of changes can they make?
Jacob Bethel made some runs today for the Lions, 71.
Bowling changes, batting changes.
They haven't made many batting changes, have they?
For a long time now, it's been a very settled batting line up in top seven.
I think they have to seriously consider Ollie Pope's position.
You know, he's just looking like he's played plenty of games against Australia with out of 50.
So I think there's a little bit of a mental scar against Australia for Ollie Pope.
you're bringing
Jacob Bethel
I've said it a long while ago
could Ben Stokes bat at number three
could he just say I'll bat at number three
then Will Jack's bat at number six
I think it's such a big risk
to bring in someone like Jacob Bethel
into this kind of series
when the team's 2-0 down
he's never got a first class 100
and you're expecting him to go
and deliver against an Australian team
with the likes of Pat Cummins
and Nathan Lyme back into their team
so the bowling unit for me needs to change
I think Matthew Pots
an English style pitch-up bowler
is probably something that could be required.
Adelaide might not be that style of bowling week,
but they have to rotate the bowl as Josh Tongue.
We've got 18 wickets in the summer.
Five against Australia in 2020, 23.
In that one test match,
he hasn't played a game yet.
He does get wickets.
And England just need to find a way of not only,
obviously, getting 20 wickets,
but Australia is scoring too quickly.
They're scoring so quickly against this England side
from the second innings in Perth to the first innings here.
The only reason they've kind of scorned,
Goring weight went down is because bowling and start thought,
nah, we'll just bat for a bit of time.
Up until that point, they were scoring at well over five.
So there's huge problems for the England team.
Glenn McGrath is here as well.
We'll get some reaction.
We'll hear from Ben Stokes and anyone else that the England camp put up.
Glenn, what's your assessment of what you've seen over the last?
Oh, four days.
We thought it was going to be three and a bit, but it ended up being four days.
Yeah, so you'd just like to look at see what.
England learnt from the first test and whether they put them in play here.
And you'd probably look at that first innings.
You know, it's a great innings by Joe Root.
You know, you can't take anything away from him.
And that's a one little mark against his name.
Never had a hundred against Australia.
He came out and did that here.
You take that out.
It's completely different.
And again, it's just, to me, it also showed that England haven't played much day-night cricket.
You know, I reckon they still should have declared in that, you know,
had half an hour at Australia.
Who knows, they could have picked up two or three
like we saw here tonight.
And then yesterday,
when Australia's batsmen in firstly Kerry and Nisa,
and then especially with Stark and bowl in the way,
they went about it to drag it as long as possible
to get that newer ball under lights
and you saw the damage they did.
England should have realised that
and just thrown everything at them.
We have to get these last four wickets well before
night so that
that pink ball's a lot softer, a lot
older going into that night session.
So, yeah, there's a lot of things there
where England needed to pick up.
You know, the way Stokes fought
today with Jacks, you know,
you expect that from Stokes. He's
a quality play, he's a great player.
And, yeah,
the way it finished off,
that's why it goes.
The way England played today,
I bring toughers in at the moment, but the way
in them play today, Glenn, do you think
there's a sort of pointer to the
future actually that it is better to just play within yourself a bit and not
not play in an over-aggressive way yes and no you know I you've got to pick the
the situation and how the game's going and that and they assess the conditions and
adjust and adapt accordingly you know in Pakistan the way they played they took it on
and it was conditions for that the first two tests have not been conditions for you know
hitting balls off short of the length bouncing.
So, yeah, yeah, there was a little, few little improvements,
especially in the sort of last, probably more so today.
But even the way they finished off, you know,
Joffre Archer came in, had a bit of fight in him.
You know, he was having a chat, he was bowling sharp,
he was bowling, getting aggressive, but the game's gone.
Where was that on day one?
Let's go down to Jonathan Agnew.
He's down there on the band,
edge and Brendan McCullum
the England head coach
is walking towards him
we'll hear from Brendan in just a moment
okay
thank you Simon
yes Brendan McCollum is with me
how do you reflect on
that bad
obviously disappointing
to go 2-0 down in a five-match series
makes things pretty tough but
you know we've been here before and we're going to have to
make sure we stay tight as a group and
iron out a couple of the chinks that we've shown over
last two test matches because when you come to Australia you can't be below your best and you
need to make sure you seize every opportunity. I think I look at a few moments in this test
match and I think there was times where we had a tendency with the bat and we probably let that
slip. There was times where we didn't execute with the ball as well as we should have and didn't
adapt to the conditions that we were presented with as quick as we could have and clearly our catcher
was an issue as well and it's very hard to beat Australia at home if you're going to be deficient
in all three of those areas. So we got some work to do. We've got some time. We've got some time.
but we've been here before and you know there's no point feeling sorry for yourself you pick
yourself up and you go again yeah and you pointed the finger at basically all three disciplines
of the game they're batting bowling and fielding as being issues well we weren't at our best
right and i think to beat australia in australia you need to be at your best across all three
disciplines and and we weren't that's the brutal honest brutal honesty of it and we'll wear that
and you know from our point of view we know that we need to get better we need to be a lot
a lot quicker to adapt to the conditions that we're going to get in Adelaide
because I thought we were a bit slow to adapt to the conditions here
and I think we were showed by Australia when they bowled in that second innings
the lengths that they hit, the adjustments they made and they put us under a lot of pressure
and we weren't quite able to do that when we had our opportunity.
There was some positives in it as well but obviously when you lose
is you try and grasp on some of those positives and you try and iron out some of the negatives.
But we have time and we've got to make sure that we don't lose half.
We've still got an opportunity to bounce back
and we've got a chance in nine days' time
to be able to put our hands up
and be better than what we were in this one.
I mean, ironically, a lot of what we saw today actually
is what I don't know, England fans have been calling out for.
Yeah, look, I think we scrapped hard today, you know?
I think on a pitch like this and conditions that you're confronted with,
it's not a natural free-flying type of surface today
and the situation needed us to try and bat as long as we could
and try and get as many as we could.
whether that was 140, 150, it would have given us a chance on a pitch,
which even right at the end there, we saw still had some tricks in it.
We just weren't able to capitalize on it.
We didn't get enough runs in our second innings,
and we gave away too many runs in our first innings,
and ultimately, hence why we ended up only having 60 to defend in the last innings.
Is there anything you'd have done differently?
Looking back now, there was a bit of a break these last two tests.
Would you have done anything differently coming into these games?
Not from a preparation point of view.
If anything, we probably trained too much, to be honest.
we had five intense training sessions leading into this game
and that's something as a coach you've got to make sure you're aware of
I think sometimes there's a tendency to want to overdo things to try and to make up for it
but as we all know in this game it's played in the top two inches majority of it
and you've got to find a way to be able to we all have to find a way to be able to ensure
that we feel prepared physically we're prepared technically
prepared for the battle we adjust to the conditions as quickly as we can
but also make sure we're fresh and we're ready and we're able to make those
succinct decisions in the heat of the battle which can win and lose games.
So you're an ad load. Thank you, Beth.
Thank you.
Right, this is Brendan McCullum.
Talking to me, we'll get Ben Stokes in just a few moments, I think.
So if you listen out, he's actually talking on the television at the moment,
and then he'll be talking to me.
Tough as this here.
Train too much.
That's an interesting comment, wasn't it?
But I can sort of understand that to some extent because they hadn't had any pink ball practice
at all. You had to suddenly
go fast forward and train quite a bit
for the pink board. Well, yeah, perhaps there
a little bit. I mean, but what sort of struck
me was that they just
didn't grasp the situation,
you know, kept playing these shots.
Glenn mentioned it earlier on, you know,
very quickly you find, and they got
away with that. I can remember, what was it, Pope and
I'm not quite sure, Corley or something like that.
You know, they went through this period where they'd got
on top and they'd wrestled a little bit of
initiative away from Australia, and
then they had this period where then Ollie Pope started skimming them over the slips and Crawley skimmed a few over the slips.
Surely then you go, you walk down, you do a bit of gardening, you have a chat with your mate and say, listen, you know, we've had a little bit of luck there.
Let's just tuck up here a little bit.
It's coming into the pink, you know, it's coming into the darkness and what have you.
You've just got to be a little bit more circumspect.
You've got to learn, you know, you've got to do your learning and your practice and everything before the game.
But, you know, a lot like life.
You know what I mean?
you've got to then adapt through you've got to go through the gears you've got to sometimes pull back on the gears
sometimes put a shot away that you think you can do but then as the lights come down you can't do it like those big hacks outside of stum to to start but yeah right
ben stokes is approaching jonathan now so let's go back to jonathan yeah just mimicking the captain up well ben how do you how do you feel after that
Yeah, obviously disappointing.
You know, again, I think looking back on this game
and something that I sort of can take a little bit of sort of,
I don't know, stuff happening over and over again.
And it's the moments in games where the game is in a moment of it's neither here or there.
And Australia have managed to get through those periods,
whether they've got the bat in the hand or the ball.
the hand and outdo us and that seems to be you know the constant theme not only these first two
games but over a long while so i can stand here and say i know it's not down to a skill thing
because of the players we've got on that dressing room they're all incredibly talented players
they've shown that in numerous occasions but if you can't put it down to a skill thing then you start
to wonder what is it are we do we need to start thinking about what mentality we're taking into
to those pressure moments.
Because when we're on top, we're great.
When we're behind the game, we're also very good.
But when that moment of the game is neck and neck,
we're not coming out on top on enough occasions
to be able to challenge a team like Australia.
So, yeah, there'll be, look,
there's going to be some conversations going on in the dressing room
that I'll keep to the dressing room.
I'll fully back my players that we're able to bounce back from this
and deliver what we need to deliver over the next three games.
Because what else are we supposed to do?
We're two-nil down, we've got three games left.
And we know we've got to win them.
And, yeah.
Can you learn from watching how Australia,
I mean, Australia did play a pretty decent game here tactically as well, didn't they?
Oh, God.
I mean, look, we...
It's probably a blur now.
No, it's not necessarily blur.
I think, as I said to you there,
it's the moments in the games where it's on the line.
You know, is it fight, is it characters,
is the mentality that were taken out there as a group?
That's what I've got to find out.
That's what I've got to ask.
You know, it's a saying that we said a lot here in the distress room,
Australia isn't for weak men, but a dressing room that I'm captain of
isn't a place of weak men either.
So, yeah, look, we need to dig deep.
I need to dig deep, and I need to get this team in a place
where we do go out there in Melbourne,
and we are seriously switched on and understand where we are right now.
And does that involve conversations with individual players
and points in this match that you will bring up as conversation points?
Our individuals, individual chats, I think they happen constantly, Jaggers.
You know, I think it's, you know, we are one team, but we're made up of 11 players.
So, you know, when it's a team thing.
And as I say, if I feel like it's something that's constantly happening, then I need to address it.
But yeah, I've got no doubt about the guys in there are capable of winning the sashes.
I'm capable of within myself as a leader and as a captain and my skill set.
as a player.
But yeah, look, we can't speak about the things that I think has, you know,
potentially, you know, gone wrong over these last two games.
Ironically, there were parts of today that actually went really well,
showing the sort of spirit, I think, and the character.
And, you know, that's down to you as well.
But the way Joffar Archer ran in at the end there, a couple of wickets taken.
I mean, that actually looked good from the sidelines.
Yeah, and look, that's it.
as a captain you're trying to put a little bit of your own influence within the team
as your own personal character and all I asked for last night and this morning was from
everyone who still had a responsible thing to do in this game you know especially with the bat
was just show fight take the you know we talk about taking a scoreboard out of the equation
and I asked the group to take the scoreboard out of the equation and just fight I think me
and jacksy did an unbelievable job at doing that but look you know the guys lower down the
order yes they have an unbelievable ability to be able to score us some runs
but you know they're batting down the order for reasons so yeah it's it's tough to expect
more and more from them down the order if that makes sense you know we've got to take some
responsibility there as a batting group you know especially that top seven yeah and and hopefully
to rein in some of the the looser shots that have been played is that a fair comment
I think when you there's some of the stuff there I think it's a it's a mentality thing and
again we seem to see those kind of things in that pressure situation where
it's neither here or there. We've managed to wrestle the first two games and moments back
towards us and then Australia have got the momentum back. So yeah, I see that as it's a common
theme when the game is on the line. When the pressure is on, where are we at? What are we thinking
about? Are we clear? To go out there and do what we need to do to get us back in the game.
So, you know, that's something that, as I said, I'll be addressing all this kind of stuff
in the dressing room. I ain't going to sit here and spurt it all out. But, you know,
Yeah, yeah.
Okay.
Last thought, there's still three games left, Ben.
You're confident you can win?
Incredibly confident.
I always am confident of the guys who get to put the shirt on.
Confident within myself that I can lead this team to a pretty impressive bounceback.
What else can I do?
Where else can I be with my mind?
I'll be doing everything I possibly can to do that.
Thanks, just talking to us.
Okay, cheers.
There we are.
we go. I think Ben
Stokes in an extraordinary
reflective mode there.
Simon, he's going off to have his
conversations and
looking into his eyes
different to the other
week. That's someone who's
really got a lot on his mind and
I think he's got a lot to say
and he knows he's got big challenges ahead
but he is going to dig deep
into the mentality
of that dressing room and find out
what the problems
are and when those moments come in which there is that that situation change that it's not
Australia that grabbed the initiative every time yeah I mean obviously didn't name names you
would never name names in a situation like that but what what do you think or who do you
think he was referring to top seven the top seven batsman that's that's that's who's
talking about isn't he that's it's quite clear I think you know the way that the way that
they've been getting out and
the way that they've been allowing Australia to get back
into the game.
Yeah, I mean, I couldn't agree more.
I mean, it was a really interesting
interview, that wasn't.
It's an interview, I'd like that to have gone on for the other 15 minutes.
Yeah.
You're not allowed to do it, but he was in a talking,
get some stuff out there, sort of mood there.
Yeah, that's the first time I've heard
the Baz Stokes, you know,
partnership sort of say these things keep happening and if they keep happening we have to then
address them so how will we then go to address it and john i don't necessarily think it's just
the batting as well it's the bowling as well look at nisa john look at nisa just comes up
there professional top of off stump you know and he keeps saying that australia uh then
wrestled the initiative back they wrestled the initiative back just by sometimes pulling back
when we try to wrestle initiative we kind of go harder and then that gives the initiatives sometimes
if it doesn't come off to the opposition.
So, you know, sometimes just by ploughing on forward
isn't getting the initiative.
Like anise, the wicket went flat,
and he just top of off-stum,
good professional bowling,
went about his craft,
and that's the way of getting it back.
Yeah, I was interested,
particularly in the way he looked,
as he was saying those words,
there are going off for a bit of a break now.
There is, you know, at some time until the next test match,
he's going to be dealing with,
stuff. I think that was absolutely the message. He recognises
that there is an issue. He wants to find out why
certain players are not responding in the right way. I think
he's talked about individual conversations to go through it all. And he said,
I'm going to find out what the problem is. So I think
this break for him
probably comes at a good time, actually. The way he
was speaking there, he knows that there's a lot to be done.
I don't think, you know, I interview Ben Stokes a lot.
That was an entirely different look.
People can say words, but it's how you look into the eyes as well.
And that was a very, very determined looking Ben Stokes.
Yeah, I mean, my dressing room is not a place for weak men, though.
I mean, you can draw your inference on that, can you?
I mean, that's quite a strong comment to make.
But weak doesn't necessarily mean playing more shorts.
week sometimes was what Ben Stokes
did there with the bat. Well I wonder
I mean just listening to him there I wonder
whether the innings he played today
was kind of like a bloody minded
innings to say look this is what
you've got to do everybody. Absolutely yes
it wasn't we're going to save
this game we're not going to win this game but look
this is what you can do if you
apply yourself whether you're trying to lead by
example out in the field
we're not going to give an inch that's basically what he was
saying we might have lost this game which they clearly
had but we are not going to
give an inch and I think it'll be very interesting to see how they come out and the way
the Joffar Archer ran in this evening for instance above like lightning in a losing
cause you know maybe there have been a few rockets fired already in that dressing room
you know and well we'll see again we've talked a lot about all sorts of things
preparation and all of that we'll see how they how they turn up in Adelaide next week
does it mean do you think John it's difficult we're trying to read something into
words that to some extent
we're in code because you don't name names
do you in a situation like that?
Do you think that means
potentially changes in the top seven?
I think he's going to be listening
very carefully to what each
player has to say
he'll have those in his mind
who I suspect who he will
feel have not given their best so far
and I suspect Olly Pope might be on that list
and as we talked
last night
there's just no copy
competition for places. This is the problem. There's no player under threat in that team
apart from Olly Pope. And that's been the case from the very start because of Jacob Bethel.
But Jacob Bethel can't open the batting. Jacob Bethel can't keep wicket.
Jacob Bethel's not going to bat anywhere else. I mean, you know, it is a very strange setup in which
there is just no competition. So these players are going to have to respond. But unfortunately,
there isn't the bottom line that is usually the case in these teams.
in which it's made pretty clear
if you don't sort yourself out, you're out
you're gone. You know, Harry Brooke, you play
another shot like that, I don't care if your second
best in the world or whatever, the rankings
say, if you do that again
then I'm very sorry but that's unacceptable.
But that can't happen in this team
because there's no one else.
As I said, it could be a little bit
of a change attack. It could be a change attack.
So change of approach do you think?
Well, change of approach, absolutely.
Well, it has to be a change of approach
because this approach clearly has not worked.
It's not working, too.
No, absolutely.
But like you said there, I mean, Harry Brooke absolutely filled to the rafters with talent.
But I think what he was saying there, you might be,
but you play a couple of more shots like that.
It doesn't matter how much talent you've got.
You've got to prove it on the field with a big hundred.
And that means graft, knuckle down, application, and play the situation.
And that was a great interview.
And I think that there will be a few rockets fired.
in this dressing room for Ben Stokes.
Sorry, and McCollum.
I wouldn't like to be, I wouldn't like to be in that room.
I mean, he wasn't looking aggressively at me at all.
This was steely determined.
Ice cold.
Yeah.
Very reflective.
Choosing his words very carefully and saying what he said absolutely deliberately.
I mean, Ben Stokes is not a stupid individual.
He said that on here.
for the public consumption absolutely deliberately.
Yeah, and I don't think that dressing room now
might be saying, coming back in like that
and take your gloves off and saying,
well, that's just the way I play.
That's what I sort of felt from that.
You know, if that's the way you're playing,
I don't care how good you are,
don't care how much we've invested in you,
you're not playing.
I think that's a change of tack right there.
Yeah, well, we'll see.
What did you make a bit of Glenn listening on?
No, it's interesting, trying to listen to what he's saying,
but also what he doesn't want to say.
Yeah.
There's a few things there.
I guess it's got to the point now.
There's been a lot of talk about basball for a couple of years now.
This is make or break.
This is, there's no, you know, if we lose the next few games,
I will continue on with it.
It's all or nothing now.
And just listening to him, to me, it's about they've got the talent.
There's no doubt about it.
But then it's applying yourself for adapting to the conditions.
Okay, I can go hard now, or it's a bit tough.
okay, get through this tough period, then assert myself again.
And that's where they haven't made the right decision.
So it's more mental side of the game.
And when he said, oh, we're great front runners.
When we're behind, we're great, it's that middle period
when neck and neck and Australia gets the assurgency.
But you look at Perth, they were miles in front.
And they threw it away with shot selection.
And after lunch on day two, they were, you know, 100 in front.
one wicket. All of a sudden, Australia's chasing 200 and gets them. So they're on top,
didn't assess the situation, you know, keep batting out there. You can always sense the
opposition when they're vulnerable and that's when you can attack. When it's sort of level
pegging, you've got to work hard. So yeah. Exactly. About Perth, like you said, Glenn, a hundred
ahead. Now, they went hard and then that that's what their undoing was. I think now, you know,
When you're 100 ahead, if anything, buckle down the hatches a little bit and grind them and make sure you get there.
So I think it's going to be a completely different England side that we're going to see turning up in Adelaide.
But not different necessarily in personnel, but in...
I don't know how they all slot in.
Hopefully in attitude, in accountability from the team and from the individual sort of perspective.
Yeah, absolutely.
I mean, Jonathan, I mean, you just said it there.
I mean, it's very hard to overhaul this team, especially the batting order.
I mean, there is Jacob Bethel.
He did make some run to the Lions today against Australia A.
I mean, they do have Lions players here.
You don't think they would do something really radical and blood a couple of, not new players,
but players who haven't played in the series, perhaps from outside the squad.
I mean, not the Lions have done particularly well in their first things.
They've bought out for 160.
They don't have that much room for manoeuvre.
No, they haven't.
They've got none.
I mean, it wouldn't surprise me if they played Bethel, actually.
just because in this the way tours are now
and I know they've got a few days off now
and they will reconvene in Adelaide
but there's no escape
you know if the same bowlers getting out all the time
and there he is running in at you again the following week
we saw it in the COVID series isn't before years ago
you know there's no escape for the batsman in particular
but also the bowlers who run in and you know Steve Smith again
has made his mark here again isn't against Jopher Archer
there's no means of getting away
So sometimes just freshening something up
but might be a good idea.
I think Olly Pope was disappointing in this game.
They really rave about Jacob Bethel, don't they?
So that, but it's the only change they can make
apart from switching a bowler or two.
I think Will Jacks is,
Will Jacks, who has done himself a lot of good in this game.
Yeah.
You know, first innings he played pretty well.
Seconds played really well.
It showed the right temperament.
And that I think is what, you know,
I think temperament is probably what Stokes was taught.
talking about there, you know, where they're going at stuff.
And Glenn was right.
You have that opportunity.
You've got to grab it.
You've got to take it and not let Australia wrestle it back again, which is what's
happened so far.
They've had opportunities in these two games, but they've just not taken them.
And that's, that's, it must be so frustrating to be the captain in that, in that situation.
You can just, you can see the opportunity is there.
But it, but it hasn't been taken.
So it wouldn't surprise me if that was the case.
but they tend to be very loyal
and they tend to keep
you know we heard
Brendan McCallum say to me there
you keep it tight
that's the way they like to do it
and that's what they've done
they've come here more or less with their
well with 12 or 13
already inked in
they can change a quick bowler or two
but maybe that
that might be a change that we look out for
Agas
it's a familiar theme
2 nil down in Australia
but actually it was 2 nil last time
in the Asher
in England. There were two tight test
matches. England lost them by
two wickets and by
40 odd runs. Ben Stokes, I remember
him saying, I think it's Brendan McCullum saying
at Lords, we can come back and win
this series. Is there any
way back realistically for England
from here? Well, it doesn't feel
like it when you're standing out here in the gab
and there's a four-day defeat
on the back of a two-day
defeat and, you know,
you've got Australians celebrating all over
the place. I've got hundreds of people
just behind me here, pinned up against the railings.
We've got Mitch Stark signing.
You know, he's having a selfie.
You know, it's an all-in Australian celebration.
But anybody who's watched these six days
will see that Australia is vulnerable.
Now, they're going to be stronger in Adelaide.
They'll have Nathan Lyon back.
I think Pat Cummins will almost certainly be back.
Although, he hasn't played a game for months.
And that's, you know, we talk about England's preparation
and match preparation and match practice.
Well, you know, he hasn't played for a very long time.
and so he'll be fairly careful, I would have thought, how he comes back.
Can they win the three out of three?
Well, as I said to you, I think semi-joking the other day,
at least now they've had some preparations,
at least now they've had some match practice in these two games.
They've lost them both.
They had opportunities to win them both.
And I think after all the inquests have taken place
and these conversations with players are taking place in the dressing rooms
and they've all got their heads straight
and Ben Stokes has got his head straight
and he's delivered his message
then we'll see
how they come out at Adelaide
because the way the series is so far
there'll be opportunities there for England
because this is not a great Australian side
they are vulnerable
there'll be opportunities
and this time
well England will have to take them
I think also
what it comes down to a little bit
is it's like the minerals
you've got some minerals
he was all very well and good to see
Joffar Archer with a three or four overspell
didn't see too much of that
when the game was happening
you know I mean
and the guy's run in and everything
but I think it's sort of like
he came steaming in there
he was steaming he was in Steve Smith's face
where was that John
where was that John in the Thursday
well exactly exactly
so maybe some rockets
have already been fired
yeah perhaps that's what he bent
absolutely about weak men
Jonathan, from here to Adelaide, it's over a week now.
People listening to this might not know,
but England have a mini-break where they go to Nusirp.
What do you think about that?
A mini-break and then off to Adelaide at the weekend
for preparation for the test match, which starts next Wednesday.
Yeah, well, I mean, the optics will be bad.
And people at home listening are prepared to see lots of photographs
of England's cricketers playing golf.
And, you know, that is not going to look good.
Now, do you do things for optics?
And what else could they do?
Well, the only thing they could do, alternatively,
is to go to Adelaide, to Bin Nusa,
which is up on the Sunshine Coast.
It's a very nice place indeed.
But you bin that, you go to Adelaide.
You don't practice every day.
You can't practice every day.
You can't net every day.
But you can at least be there
and preparing yourselves mentally.
you go to the Adelaide Oval
you do a bit of work every day
just a little bit before building it up
but then you can go and play your golf in the afternoon
I mean as I've said so many times
you can't train all day
and you can't sit in your hotel room
all afternoon and evening when you finish your training
you've got to do something
so you know playing golf is not the problem
it's just it's built
the narrative has kind of built up
which suggests that actually all they're interested in
is playing golf well that's not true
we watch some training you watch them work
it's unfortunate i think for england that it's entirely of their own doing that this narrative has been allowed to grow while they're losing games and and rather than playing like for instance the game in cambra that i think people are still a bit split on but i mean i i think that some of them should have gone and played that just to have got used to a pink ball there were a number of playing in this game who never played with a pink bull before that that to me would be it would mean a more sensible approach and i think the people listening at home would would agree with that and
And had they done all that and still lost, well, okay, you have your break.
But that's the only thing I can think of.
But I must say, I just think that the sight of them are on their golf buggies over the next few days in Nusa.
They're going to be drones up.
They've had it already with cameras.
I mean, the people at home have no idea really about the scrutiny that the England cricket team is under.
There they were on those scooters in Brisbane.
You know, all that stuff.
They are followed all of the time.
Every airport lounge they go into, it's everywhere.
And they're going to have to prepare themselves
for some pretty tricky headlines and photographs
over these next few days.
But I say, what else could they do?
Yes, you can go and do some practice,
but that match is, what, nine days away.
It's a long time just be spending,
having fielding practice and in the nets.
Okay, I suppose in the old days,
they'd all had a match, right?
Yes, they would.
Yes, they would.
They would have played a practice match.
That's exactly.
And what they would have done,
they'd have had players in the squad
who would have played in that practice match,
along with people who actually needed the practice out of the main team,
and then you'd sit down at the end of that practice match
and before the next test, say, right, who's in form?
Who's playing well?
Who's going to play in this next test match?
Well, I think you could virtually name 1 to 11,
and we've talked a bit about Bethel,
but that doesn't happen.
That is not happening anymore.
I don't think that's old school
and do you know what it was
it was also rather fun going round
and going up into up country places
and just playing against
the country 11 whoever it was
you saw a bit of the country
you got away from all the main
players you could clear ahead
opportunity for bats particularly to get some runs
it was a useful
exercise but yeah that's
unfortunately not on the agenda
this time
thanks very much
I guess, Glenn, you wanted to say something.
Yeah, no, sort of the fact they don't have a game on now,
I actually don't mind them having a break.
You know, listening to Ben Stokes and to, you know,
Brennan McCollum, it was a different,
I got a different sense from it because they've always been very positive
and no negativity at all and very strong
that this is the way we're going to go.
And end of story.
But now I'm hearing, yes, we do have issues.
Yes, not playing as well as we like.
they've now identified their issues.
They've accepted it.
I think going away now, having a break,
go up, Nuset, play some golf, whatever you want to do,
and really come back, okay, now this is our mindset.
We've changed.
This is what we have to do to do things differently.
They've been so strong,
and they put a wall up around everyone else saying,
this is the way we're going to do it.
They've finally identified.
This doesn't work.
So now they've got to have a different approach.
So from here on in,
their approach, once they get to Adelaide,
is going to set the standard for them for the rest of the series
and see if they're good enough to bounce back from here.
So I'm glad they've finally identified it.
Maybe it's a test or two too late, but better late than never.
No, absolutely.
I think it's a change attack.
You know, I mean, the batters are getting a little bit of stick here,
but also the bowlers, you know, if you're not, you know,
wickets are flat in Australia.
They go flat.
It's long, it's hot and everything.
So what do we do?
Bang it in halfway down.
That hasn't worked.
You know, take a leaf out of Nisa's book.
Just bowl some top of off stump, you know, set some fields back, you know,
and let the opposition come to you a little bit.
I think it's going to be a change attack with the ball,
and I think it's going to be a slight change attack with the bat.
Still looking to be positive and aggressive, but Ben Stokes,
he led the way with the basball charge,
and I think he's perhaps just shown there.
He's going to lead the way with a little bit more defiance.
There are always two sides to a story.
We've heard the England side.
There's a happy side for Australia.
Victors by eight wickets in this second test match.
We can get some reaction now from the Australia camp.
Captain Steve Smith has been speaking to Issa Goua.
Now I'd like to welcome up, Steve Smith.
He's just calmed down from his knock.
Feeling a bit more relaxed now?
Yeah, pretty chilled now.
It was good fun there for a little bit.
So, no, great day of cricket.
The guys toiled really hard early on.
and obviously a really good partnership with Stokesy and Jackson there.
And, you know, once we broke that, we're able to go through
and get them out and chase 60.
So, yeah, great day.
Let's go back to the start.
You lost the toss.
So how pleasing must that be, given it's such a crucial thing and a pink ball test?
Yeah, I think the first two days were pretty even in terms of conditions that we both faced.
No one got a new ball at the night in that first little bit.
And then I think the game turned for us when we were able to, you know, extend everyone,
one get into double digits.
Unfortunately, no one go on to make a big one,
but particularly the tail to bat for 50 overs
and extend that time so we could get the new ball under lights
and obviously do some damage last night was crucial for us.
And yeah, it was just a really good performance.
You had 650 run partnerships there.
How crucial was that?
Especially, you know, when England are coming hard at you
and the lights are changing and the conditions are changing.
Yeah, I mean, it can be tricky with the pink ball.
You're almost never in at times
Sometimes it feels a little bit easy
When the ball gets a bit soft
And then you get a ball change
Or something
You know the lights come on
It speeds up a bit
It just changes really quickly
And you've got to adapt
And yeah
It's a tricky game at times
But yeah
I thought the guys
Being able to extend those partnerships
And have a lot of 50 run partnerships
Really helped us in the game obviously
With the ball obviously
Michael Nisa was a talking point
Coming into the side for Nathan Lyon
He delivered
He did
Yeah he obviously made out
batting a little bit longer as well at number eight
and yeah, what he did today
and in the first innings was exceptional.
I think, you know, he offers something different
to the other guys. We can bring the keeper up to the
Stumps and change the game that way. And
the way he bowled today and last night
was exceptional and yeah,
really pleased for him to get
his first fifer. He's been on a lot
of tours. He's worked really hard and
yeah, really pleased for him.
Wicketkeepers don't often get a good rap, but how good
was Alex Carey? He's a freak.
Honestly, up to the stunts. The ball
just seems to end up in his hands. It hits the batter's pad or something and it still ends up in
his hands. He's got no fear up there. He moves so well and his gloves are just sensational and
yeah, he's, that was one of the best keeping performances I think I've ever seen. And yours top three?
Your cat? I don't know. It's got to be up there, I reckon. They're pretty tough when, you know,
you've got a pink ball, the lights are on. Yeah, I'm blindsided by Alex. I'm standing quite wide
because Alex covers so much room
and then, yeah, just fortunately
saw it late and got down to it
and at Stark. It was obviously
at a crucial time to break that partnership
so, yeah, I'll remember that one.
Just last one for you, Steve.
Pat Cummings obviously comes back for the next test match
but you're going pretty well with the captaincy.
Are you happy to hand it back?
Yeah, all his.
No, it's been fun.
The last couple of games
and the boys have put on some terrific performances
and, yeah, done everything I've said,
so give it back to Paddy and let him take it.
done. Congratulations. Thank you.
Steve Smith with Isha Guett. So is it obvious, Glenn, what Australia do for Adelaide?
They just bring back Lyon and they bring back Cummins and that's it?
Well, by the looks of things, that's probably what will happen.
You know, Pat Cummins hasn't played for a while and I think back to last year when India
came out, that first test match where India won in Perth, the bowling looked underdone a bit.
And it wasn't until the second test that they really fired and that includes Pat Cummins.
So hopefully he's ready to go.
hits the ground running
and Nathan Lyon
I think he could have played an impact out here
but then you look at what Boland
and Nisa did at different times
so yeah
who did they leave out
unfortunately I think it's
it will be Doggett and Nisa
that will be left out
Nisa has played three day night
test matches in his career
and they like their
you know that horses for courses things
so yeah if Lyon and Cummins
come back in it will be
Doggett and Nisa that unfortunately miss out.
Nisa with 5 for 42 today.
Mitchell Stark taking 2 for 64 to go with his 6th for 75 and his innings of 77.
He was player at the match and he has been speaking to Isha as well.
Two wins, yeah.
Yeah, can't ask for much more.
Yeah, well, I mean, it went a bit longer than the first test but hard for one I think for both teams and yeah, glad to be on the right side of it.
How's that body holding up because you keep putting in and keep bowling at 100
140 plus kilometres an hour.
Yeah, it takes a little bit longer in the mornings at this age,
but no, still going okay.
Yeah, hanging in there.
And that pink ball, not swinging necessarily too much for you,
but you were still able to extract the wickets.
What was the key for you?
Yeah, I mean, we've sort of seen on this ground before,
and the wickets this hard,
it's sort of see that pink ball go soft pretty early.
So, yeah, I think we, as a bowling unit,
it bowled really well across both innings.
Obviously, the batting in the first innings was key to get
get a lead there and nest today was phenomenal so
really really pleased for him at his home ground front of family
he was phenomenal today you're so often the tone setter just how difficult is it to
get yourself ready for that first ball because you make it look very easy
yeah I still try and do the same things on I so
no it doesn't take much to get ready to go
still trying to bowl as quick as I can and hit the stumps every time so
yeah just keep running in and see it
Yeah, we go.
Well, you've contributed so much in terms of the wickets,
but what about with the bat?
How much did you enjoy that?
There's no better incentive for bowlers than to bat as long as you can,
to not bowl anymore.
So, yeah, it was nice to put a bit of a partnership there.
I think that's, you know, you speak a little bit of the tactical side of pink ball test cricket,
and we knew it was going to be better to bowl with the pink ball
or hard new pink ball later in the day.
So to get through as long as we did with the bat,
to put a partnership together with Scotty and then obviously doggy for a little bit there at the end,
was really key for us to push that bowling innings as far back as we could.
And we saw late in the day we got those rewards.
So, yeah, fantastic to contribute as a lower order.
Got a taste of what it's like to be a proper all-rounder.
I'm too old for that.
Yeah, I'm not sure how Stokesy and then the guys do it as long as they do.
So, yeah, I'll enjoy an extra day to put my feet up and get ready for Adelaide.
Well, I don't once again, Mitch.
Thanks, each.
So that's Mitchell Stark, one of Australia's match winners.
There were a few and a fine.
round performance from Australia
they win this second test match
by eight wickets as indeed they won the
first test match Andy Zaltzman
alongside me what so what about
the some of the individual
stats from this game well let's start
with Stark back-to-back
player of the match performances as
Isha said there 18 wickets
in the first two tests that's the most
any bowlers had after two tests of an Ashes series
since Shane Warn had 20
after two matches in the 1990
94-95 series and his
an achievement of having a six-wicket
hall and a score of 75 or more
in the first innings
of the test. Only two other
players have done that in Ash's history to
great Australian all round us. Jack Gregory
in the first series after the First World War
and Keith Miller in the first series after the
second World War. So extraordinary performance
from him with both
ball and Bat and Michael Nisa
became the oldest seamer
to take his first five-wicket hall
for Australia since
a medium pace called Harry Boyle
in the 1880s
and Australia just the fifth team
slightly niched at this
but the fifth team in test history
to have two pace bowlers age 35 or more
both take five wickets
five wicket innings in a series
and two of those were Walsh and Ambrose
for the West Indies in the late
1990s so yeah
some excellent performances
from Australia's bowlers
and the nature of that team batting
performance it was a slight
mixture of ruthlessness and care
There are a number of shots of this will let England slightly back into it.
But every single player scored double figures.
The first test innings in history in which all 11 players made 13 or more
and a very rare instance of a team reaching 500
without a single century stand.
Only the third time that has happened in test history.
Now, Australia are 2-0 up.
Yes.
They are closing in seemingly on winning the ashes.
Now, they are 2-0 up after six days of cricket.
Is there a potential record for winning the ashes in double-twick quick time?
In terms of days of cricket, I'll dig around between now and Adelaide.
In terms of overs taken, England have batted for 219 overs and one ball in their four innings here.
We had 36.4 overs in that one partnership by Stokes and Jacks today.
either side of that they've lost 39 wickets in 182 overs,
a wicket every 28 balls faced in the series.
It's the fastest, in terms of balls-faced batting,
England have never gone 2-0 down against Australia more rapidly
and by quite a significant margin.
To put it in context, in the 2013-14 series
when they were destroyed by Mitchell Johnson,
when they were 2-0-down, they'd faced 303 overs.
So, basically, 85 was a whole, well, over a whole day's batting at modern over-o-rate's more.
across the first two tests to go 2-0 down to the Johnson-inspired Australians then.
So this has been extremely rapid.
Obviously, Perth was off the charts, but even here,
a bowled and under 80 overs in both innings.
And England are used to being 2-0 down on Australia.
It's the eighth time in the last 10 series in Australia.
They've been 2-0 down after 2.
they're now 17 matches without a win in Australia since the last test of the 2010-11 series
when they won by an inning so take the series 3-1 their previous longest run of test without a win in
Australia was 12 either side of the Second World War even in the difficult times at the start
of Australia's dominance in the early 1990s the longest they went without an ashes win was 9 tests
So 17 tests. Joe Root, Ben Stokes, first played on the 2013-14 series here.
Neither of them has ever won a test in this country.
So it's a pretty desperate statistical situation.
And just picking up on one particular aspect, and again, it involves Mitchell Stark.
He had a 27.2 over partnership with Scott Boland that was crucial in shaping the game early yesterday.
England's eighth, ninth and tenth wickets across all four innings of the series have lasted a total of 27.
0.5 overs in losing their 12 wickets.
They've lost the wicket every 14 balls for the 8th, 9th and 10th wickets.
On paper, this is a strong England tale on the field.
It has capitulated rapidly.
And you look at the comparison of the players, Atkinson, with a test 100,
and a number of other scores in the 30s and 40s, Bryden Kass,
as a test 50, a couple of first class hundreds.
And just comparing them with Boland and Doggett,
who've managed about considerably longer than England's, on paper, far stronger tail enders.
So that's been a significant factor in this series, the rapidity with which England's tail subsided.
We saw it again today when Stokes and Jacks had given them a glimmer of hope of at least challenging Australia
and then the tail once again disintegrated into the Brisbane air.
And most of them caught from short balls on the leg side as well.
But anyway, that is another story.
unless you've got something more?
Just one final.
Niche stat.
Well, the Jack Stokes' partnership, 59 in 24 overs in the first session of the day,
the lowest scoring full session of the Basball era.
It was Stokes' second's lowest 50 of his career.
But his opposing number, as Captain Steve Smith, 23 off 9 in the second inning.
He scored two sixes in each innings the first time in his long and illustrious chest career
that he's hit four sixes in a match, which, given the nature of a nature of,
of basketball is, I don't know, like an anti-cherry on the top of a disappointing cake.
Yeah, kind of rubbing it in. There we go. Thanks very much, Saltz. Now, you can watch highlights
on the BBC Sport website and app and on BBC IPlayer. You'll also be able to watch
the TMS Ashes debrief with Alex Hartley on IPlay and the BBC Sport YouTube channel.
Check out BBC Sounds for our full range of podcast. Just Search Ashes. And we're back on air Tuesday
the 16th of December at 1055 p.m ahead of the first ball at 11.30 for the third test in Adelaide.
The TMS podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live.
This month in football, everything is up for grabs.
The Premier League battles intensify.
The Champions League reaches its crucial turning point,
and the World Cup draw sets the stage for the biggest tournament on earth.
Football Daily from the BBC brings you sharp analysis, instant reaction, expert insight,
and the stories driving the game on and off the pitch.
Your essential football podcast delivered every day.
Listen to Football Daily on Spotify, to Football Daily on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.
