The Creep Off - Episode 152: Whop-de-doo!
Episode Date: February 13, 2023In observance of Valentine's Day Karl & Vinnie have decided to celebrate true love by making their nominations for creepiest couple: This week's WATC segment proves that Candian true-crim...e podcasts suck too!: In the Scum parade we meet a girls basketball coach who can't do or teach, an Egyptian goddess and a British man who does not mind sloppy seconds.Check out this weeks stories: A Virginia assistant HS basketball coach impersonated a 13-year-old player, leads to multiple firings (yahoo.com)Pa. woman who claims to be 'Egyptian goddess' accused of setting home and chicken coop on fire, killing 1 | Truecrimedaily.comHomeless man accused of raping A-level student said 'she had the time of her life', court hears | Daily Mail OnlineMom’s ex-boyfriend killed 12-year-old girl, hid body in basement freezer: police - pennlive.com
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hey everyone, welcome to every fighter pilot's favorite podcast, bursting Beijing's balloons, or as we call it, The Creep Off.
In this podcast, each host does nearly half a dozen minutes worth of research and then stretches out to about 30 minutes of entertainment for you.
Then you head over to the subredin vote for whoever you thought brought in the creepiest creep, or which host you think can beat off five cops at the same time.
Yeah, that might be a recycled joke, but if you're not playing my bits every week, Vinnie, I don't know which ones get played on air.
Send him on time, asshole.
After five losses, the loser has to spin the dread wheel.
consequences, which includes funny consequences, such as losing your Patreon money for a month,
or having to buy the winner two dozen eggs.
Last week in a show that was somehow different than all the other ones, they took on meth heads.
And Carl's creep decided that her baby really needed a good cleaning, while Vinnie's creep
was helping the world by killing chihuahuas.
Anyways, that's all I got for this week.
Tucker, out.
Attention parents, what you're about to see is not suitable for kids.
It's not even suitable for some grown-ups.
You might want to walk away now if you ain't into these type of things.
I'm going to give the people what they want.
Sensation.
Horror shock.
I'm going to deliver the goods because I'm alive and I'm not backing down.
Goon, go, go, cool.
My love.
My love, my love, my endless love.
The disgusting, vomit-inducing thing.
Ola creepos.
Welcome to another edition of your favorite true cry podcast, the show about creeps.
creeps for you creeps i'm your host the tower of power too sweet to be sour the people's
champion phidipoledo given a big excelsior true believers and i'm gonna also welcome into the
studio my co-host today we all love to hate them it's hot c cacarla what people people like me
what do you mean they love to hate you love to hate me what do you mean by that what's
happened at vittipalino i'm great buddy hey it's valentine's day well tomorrow's valentine's day
Today is Super Chet Day.
It's Valentine's Day Eve.
No one's getting laid.
It's Super Chit Day here on the creep off.
And because it's Valentine's Day week, we are doing the creepiest couple this week.
Overdue category, bud.
For real.
I was surprised we didn't hit this one yet.
I kind of was, too, when I realized we had it available.
So there's a lot of ways to go with this.
But before we start the competition, let's review last week's score.
Certainly do, Carl.
do we?
Yeah, buddy.
1.04 to my 62.
I am so happy
because Carl,
it's just another
Winhousing for the winhousing.
And that means
that if we put up our
properly spelled scoreboard,
the one that was not brought to us
by the city of Syracuse,
that would put me on game point.
Oh, fuck me.
So I got to win today.
Well, yes, and you also have to drive to Gary and Deanna.
I know.
Oh, I know.
Plans are being made, Vinnie.
Are they?
Yes.
How?
We're making arrangements to make this happen.
How are you going to do it?
Did you decide it yet?
Don't worry about it, buddy.
Don't worry about it.
I'll take care of my consequence.
All right.
All right.
Fair enough.
Fair enough.
I mean, I'm not going to make a pickle pizza and call it a day like you.
That was the most disgusting thing that's ever happened.
Oh, stop it.
apart from sharing a microphone with you.
You probably still have wet dreams about that experience.
Nightmares.
I don't want to hear it.
Very wet nightmares.
I sweat.
And come.
Carl, here's what I need from you, buddy.
I need you to ring that goddamn bell and let's get after it because it's contest time.
Creepiest couple, folks, everybody knows a bunch of these stories.
A lot of the creepiest couple stories are told over.
and over and over again.
I get it.
Paul Bernardo was a douchebag,
and Carlin Hamoko was a psycho.
They're just all the same stuff over and over again.
So I'm going to go after a couple that I really didn't know that much about.
And when I found out the details of this story,
it has a little bit of everything.
Oh, good.
So my creeps today are Phil and Nancy Garito.
Are you familiar with Phil and Nancy, Carl?
I'm familiar with Doritos.
I see what you did there
I am not familiar with this couple
what's up they suck they suck
1972 I'm just going to start
with a little bit of info about Phil before we get
going he's arrested in charge with sexually
assaulting a 14 year old girl
the case did not go to trial
after the girl declined to testify
in 73 he got married to a girl named
Christine Murphy who he used to
beat up and then she
alleged that he kidnapped her when she tried
to leave him okay he's divorced
by 1976, he kidnaps a 25-year-old girl named Catherine Calloway in South Lake Tahoe, California,
takes her to Reno, Nevada, Carl, takes her to some empty warehouse where he raped her for
five and a half hours.
When a cop noticed a car parked outside the unit and that the broken lock was on the warehouse
door, he knocks on the door and finds Phil Garito in stages of undress going, hey, officer,
how could I help you?
There's a problem what's going on.
officer five and a half hours of rape and torture yeah Jesus Christ I mean is that that's like
sting style rape so he's able to last that long that's impressive he had a thermos full of coffee
he was ready to be hold up in there for a while wow so at that point this woman Kathleen
Calloway starts yelling for help he gets arrested quickly he's charged and convicted in federal
and state courts because he brought her across state lines now I just given you a quick
background. This guy's a psycho from the get. He was diagnosed as a sexual deviant and chronic
drug abuser, loved his meth. I'm going to find out a little bit more about that later.
The psychiatrist recommended that a neurological examination be conducted because they thought
that maybe it was his drug abuse that was making him do these things. Yeah. And they're like,
no, this dude's just a real sexual fucking criminal. Yeah, but the meth probably doesn't help.
You know, I can't imagine he does some meth. He's like, you know what, today I'm just going to take it easy.
agreed. He also in court admitted that he used to masturbate in his car by the side of elementary
schools while watching the girls. So fun facts about... Drugs are bad. You should do drugs.
Now, he gets convicted in 77 and begins serving a 50-year federal sentence. Okay.
Now, what couple's story would be complete without a meat queue? Oh, yeah.
At Leavenworth State Prison, Garido met Nancy.
Bacangara, who was visiting her uncle, another inmate.
And on October 5th, 1981, he and Bockega were married at Leavenworth Prison.
They got married, fell in love in the jail.
But I got to tell you, Carl, the reason why this worked for him is because he was dreamy.
And while he was in jail, he was allowed to use, like, you know how they did, like, a lot
of rehabilitation programs and stuff like that?
Sure.
He had a little prison band.
and he was recording music.
Would you like to hear some of Phil's music?
I would.
What does he play in the band?
He plays guitar.
That's what the ladies like.
Let me see here.
Lead vocals, bass, and effects.
A guy named Derek Smalls played the guitar, and Bo Snatch was on the drums.
This is from the recordings.
Oh, he's the bass player?
Yeah.
He's the bass player and singer.
Yeah.
So he thinks he's Gene Simmons, but he doesn't.
Listen to this, Carl.
Why they remind me of the good old things
He kind of reminds me like Jeremy or Jerry Only
Yeah, singing a love ballad.
Yeah, it's like if Jerry only sucked more.
This episode could be hard to listen to.
Yeah.
That's bad.
It's not good.
But let me tell you something.
Nancy, stars in her eyes.
Okay.
And would you like to see a picture of?
Thab, Carl?
Here we go.
Let's see.
We'll get rid of that one.
That's Thab.
Oh, they're lovely.
He is dreamy.
Wow.
She's not bad looking.
She's kind of cute.
Nice.
Yeah.
So a jailhouse wedding, every girl's dream.
Now, he gets out of prison somehow in 1988.
Whether it's overcrowding good behavior, he was raping a woman for five and a half hours.
now he's been married for seven years of his marriages behind bars.
I feel like you should know the reason why he got out in 88.
Aren't you all presenting this story?
You're like, for some reason, he's not out of jail.
Is that what Wikipedia says?
Or like, ah, we don't know.
This isn't a Wikipedia article.
Okay.
So they move into his mother's house, who's an elderly woman.
She suffered from dementia.
He's a parolee.
He's not allowed to leave the house.
He's got an ankle bracelet.
Okay.
And he was under very, very strict parole.
By the way, ankle bracelets always work.
Never fail.
Nope.
We'll fast forward to 1991, where shit starts to go really south, Carl.
Okay.
11-year-old girl named J.C. Duggard was walking to the school bus.
A car approaches.
The man in the car starts asking her for directions.
He rolls down the window and then uses a stun gun to knock the 11-year-old unconscious.
Then, according to the witnesses who were other school children, saw the
woman get out of the car, pick up the girl, put her in the car, and they drive away. A bunch of
kids tried to tail them on their bikes. Okay. Like they did it right by the school bus, dude.
Yeah. Like very brave. But that's what Methods do. They're very brave. They don't think things
through either. Well, he thought enough through that he took the license plate off the vehicle
and dumb kids don't know what car is what. Sure. So it was not good. They couldn't,
they didn't have a lot to go on. What's the making model? Blue. Yeah. They said it was a gray car.
Thanks, thanks, kids.
So they get to their house with this 11-year-old girl.
First thing they do is they strip her naked and he rapes her.
Then they take her into the house.
Yeah, raped her in the car.
Put a blanket over, Duggard's head, ushered her into an area in his backyard with some sheds were.
They put her inside of a tiny one that was soundproofed.
He rapes her again, and he left her naked in this thing, just handcuffed.
The doors were bolted shut, and he told her that he had attack dogs.
So he would come in there every day or so
And bring her like fast food and a milkshake or something
And try to like pal around with her
Yeah
It was really like mental fucking torture for this kid
Yeah actually it's even worse than you realize
It was always Arbys
Yeah
Poor kid I mean the torture never stopped
The only time she got a shower was for raping
Yeah
Yeah
They gave her a bucket to shit in
And eventually they gave her a TV out there
Which I thought was kind of nice
I mean
It's cheap to eat
Yeah
This is before
She's in there for a very very long time
And he would go on these meth binges
He used to call them runs
And he would come out and explain to her
How he was a prophet of God
And would hear the demon angels
And the demon angels
Are who told him to come get her
And save her and bring her there
And she's still handcuffed to jaded to this thing
And he's just raping her daily
Smoking meth
and she is terrified for months and months and months.
So this guy's coming in there.
He's all whacked out of his mind on meth.
Explaining all this stuff to her.
And this is her response to him.
Uh-huh.
Uh-huh.
Uh-huh.
Listen,
shut up for a second.
You know what she said?
He would dress up in weird costumes and spend time with her while cutting out figures from porno magazines.
Oh.
He would just take the scissors and be like, do, do, do, do.
Now, it's a fun project.
This dude has been raping people.
he's a singer he's got his band he thinks he's great sure um he made her listen to the voices that he
thinks he could hear in the walls and then he'd make her listen to his bullshit music can you
imagine this fucking torture sounds terrible i might pick this guy's music if you ever land on the
handcuff torture thing so you can put yourself in this poor little girl's position car all right
seven months into this captivity phil comes in and says
jacy i got good news for you i'd like to introduce you to my wife nancy uh-oh nancy comes in
gives her a stuffed animal and chocolate milk and it's like hey we're all going to be friends
and now from what i understand nancy would sit there and uh play with herself
while he would rape jacy okay yeah so now they got like a whole fucking she's getting
cucked by this psycho meth guy and just is going along for the ride now she worked
Nancy worked a regular job she was like a nurse's aide okay and she took care of the mom
and eventually they like trained this child into being a sex slave to him and living in the
house with the grandmother Nancy and Phil okay okay they made her introduce herself to
the grandmother as
Phil's daughter from another
relationship named
Alyssa.
So the mother, you know, she's really old
and she's confused. She's like, so why are you having
sex with your daughter all over the house?
And why is she hang?
Shut up, mom. You don't get my generation. You never
will. Yeah, they're just
like living there like this is supposed to be fucking
normal. Okay. Well, this Nancy's
working a normal job out in the world.
Phil is just being
a fucking psycho who's on parole.
Is Nancy into the meth as well?
I don't know.
Nobody has said that she was, but he ended up breaking his parole because he fails a drug test
and has to go back to jail for a month.
So guess where J.C. goes?
Back to the shed, bitch, because Nancy's in charge now.
Okay.
So they would do nice things for her too, Carl.
Like they gave her some kittens.
Aw.
And then the kittens mysteriously would vanish.
Oh. Yeah.
Now, during this captivity about,
34 months into it he goes away for a month and comes back within by 1994 they're giving her
cooked food for the first time that's not just like fast food shit like they're giving
her isn't she getting too old for this shit at this point are they getting she's 13
oh okay by the time she's uh almost 14 she is three and a half months pregnant oh boy
it's pull out game is a week yeah so she
We ended up having two babies, Carl, one in August of 1994 and another one in 1997, named Angel and Starlight. Guess who named him?
An idiot. Correct. Give yourself a bail. So this whole thing, now there's two babies in the house. The grandmother's there and she's like, what is going on here? And he's like, these are my other two daughters from previous relationships. And Alyssa is,
their sister, even though that's the
mother. And this poor girl
was left to take
care of these two. Nancy and Phil
didn't take care of these two kids.
This is a woman in captivity
who's just trying to fucking, who's not
allowed to leave to go out into public.
She's the one who's tending to all
the needs of these kids. And she's a child
who has no idea how to fucking
do it. Well, you know what else she doesn't know how to do? Escape.
She's got three fucking years
to escape and she hasn't yet. Everyone's looking
for her. What is she doing?
Well, Carl, he would sit there and go on rants, make them all listen to music,
and they all grew up in this house together, this house of fucking horror and rape.
Now, let's fast forward to 2009.
I'm almost done, Carl.
Mr. Garrido, this math does not do people any good, okay?
He visits, you ready for this?
He visits the San Francisco office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and leaves a four-page essay.
containing his ideas about sexuality, suggesting that he had discovered a solution to problem
behaviors like his past crimes.
Okay.
He figured out how to solve it.
You kidnap one and then you fuck babies and do it.
Oh, okay.
Yeah, I guess he proved it, right?
I don't know if that's what he wrote that.
Oh, okay.
But he also said that he has all the information that could assist and curate other sexual predators
by controlling human impulses that drives humans to commit dysfunctional acts.
Then he drove over to the University of California at Berkeley office to the police office with Duggard's two daughters who are basically leaving the house for what we know might be one of the very first times in their life.
Okay.
He's just taking these two with them and they're fucking what the fuck, like they're shifty-eyed fucking pale little tiny fucking like terrified things.
And this meth head goes into the California, state of California, Berkeley campus into the police office and starts explaining to them about God's desire for a program that he needs to put on at the college.
Okay.
And they're like, sir, we're really busy.
And he's like, yeah, yeah, yeah, but I'm so and so.
And he gives him his name, he gives him his name, everything like that.
And they said, can we make an appointment with you tomorrow?
And they were like, sure.
can you be here tomorrow at 2 o'clock and he goes great so the next day he shows up after hearing this
after the supervisor hears that this ludic was in the office she runs his name finds out he's on
parole he's technically not allowed to be within 25 miles of his house him going to that office
was a violation of his parole so they contact his parole officers okay and they show up at his house
Can I ask a dumb question?
Yeah.
I just want to make sure I'm following this.
He was released from prison in 88.
And now we're in 2009.
Yes.
And he's still on parole?
And this woman is still living in the house.
Yes.
Because he had a 50-year sentence, Carl.
Okay.
All right.
They're keeping track on this guy.
He's a sex offender.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So what I'm trying to explain to you is,
this guy's not making good decisions for someone who doesn't want to get caught.
Well, I mean, he got away with this for 18 years at this one.
I got away with it for a long time.
He's doing pretty well.
These kids are like 15 and 17.
And they also look and they go,
this guy's a sex offender and he brought two young girls into the office with them too.
So now the parole people are like,
get to our offices tomorrow.
And he shows up to the offices with his wife, Nancy,
the two girls and fucking J.C. Duggard,
who he introduces as Alyssa.
Sure.
He explains to the parole officers that he had permission to take those two girls with him
to go spread the good news of his gospel to all the world.
He sings songs.
He does this.
He's going to fix everybody on the planet.
And that's really all this was.
And this is Alyssa.
She'll tell you I'm their mother and that she's from Minnesota and she's running away
from the father of her kids.
So the investigators think this man is completely insane.
And they take Alyssa into another room.
And hi, my name's J.C. Duggard.
I haven't been allowed to say my own name in either.
18 years. That man raped those two girls into me. Please help me. He was sentenced to 431 years at prison
and Nancy received 36 years to life. Okay. And Carl, I have to say during this time, the only reason
they did not kidnap more kids, I want to show you something that's really chilling. Okay?
Yeah. These are, this is video. They took, they used to go to, well, they
had J.C. locked up in the basement.
They used to go to the park
with video cameras
and sit there. And that's how
starts to stop. Automatically focuses. And I'm just
going to show you a little bit. Sit yourself back to
right there. Maybe you can pop. He would play
his songs.
Well, they videotaped
little kids playing on the playground
together. I can see
you really good. I don't like any of this.
The soundtrack
To pedophilia, folks.
This guy, these two, are disgusting fucking creeps,
and I'm very happy that they're gone.
All right, well, I like how you said these two at the end
because that wasn't much of a couple's stories.
She helped him abduct the child.
She picked the kid up and put it in the car.
She took care of the kid.
She could have gone to the police when he went to prison
and turned them all in.
And she was there diddling herself
while he fucked children in front of her.
All right.
So I would say she's a creep.
All right, I brought a creepy couple for the show today as well, Vittie.
Who cares?
Go ahead.
I'll present my couple here.
We're going to go over the other side of the pond over there to England and look at people who are known as British Society's benchmark for evil, Myra Hindley and Ian Brady.
Now, Ian was working at this factory, and Myra got a job there.
and she was really into this guy
she was just mesmerized by him
even though he had a criminal record
she was just in love with the guy
so they started going out on dates together
and the typical date that they would go on was this
they'd take a trip to the cinema
usually to watch an X-rated film
then they go back to Hinley's house to drink
German wine
Brady would then give her reading material
and they would spend their work lunch breaks
reading aloud to one another
from accounts of Nazi atrocities
Hinley began to emulate an ideal Aryan perfection, bleaching your hair blonde and applying
thick crimson lipstick.
Well, this is the tale oldest time.
Of course, yes.
So Ian Brady's really into Mind Kampf.
He's learning German.
He's really into what the Nazis were up to.
This is the 60s, by the way, I should mention in Britain at the time.
So what this couple has fun doing is abducting children, raping them, and then murdering them,
and then burying them where they cannot be.
found.
And they did this to John Kilbride, and then later to a 10-year-old girl named Leslie
Anne Downey.
So they abducted Leslie Ann Downey.
What would happen is Myra Hinley would go, can you help me?
I'm missing one of my gloves.
Can you help me find my glove?
And kids would be like, oh, sure, yeah.
And then they throw them in the car and drive somewhere and these things would happen.
Well, it's interesting because we talk all the time on this show about the fact that with
social media and with
smartphones and having a video camera in your pocket
at all times, people can't help
themselves. They're constantly recording
themselves with these atrocities
and they're posting it all over
and it's really just a dumb thing to do
even in the 60s.
I almost think that the FBI
invented this just for this
effect just to make crime solving
easier. Right. Because
people can't help themselves. So even
before we had this
technology, people
People would love to record their crimes.
The horrifying final minutes of the girl's life were documented both in photographs and an audio recording
that had later been found in two suitcases left in Manchester Central train station by Brady and Hindley.
Photos reveal that Leslie Ann had been taken to their house where she was bound and gagged with a scarf.
Brady took pornographic photos of her and sexually assaulted her.
The heinous audio recording lasts and excruciating 16 minutes.
On it, Leslie Ann can be heard begging for her life, crying for her mother, and asking God for help.
Pretty brutal shit going on there that they found.
Yeah, and he labeled the tape, 16 minutes in heaven.
Yeah, exactly.
Holy shit.
So the reason why you don't want to do that, Vinnie, because this couple went on to also kill and rape Edward Evans.
all of their victims between the ages of 10 and 17.
Well, what happened was when they were arrested and they found these audio tapes, they played them in court.
The horrific 16-minute audio recording of Leslie Ann before her death was played in court.
Brady was found guilty on all murder counts while Hinley was acquitted in the case of John Kilbride.
But she was found guilty of being an accessory to John's murder.
as well as guilty for the murders of Leslie Ann and Edward.
Yeah, so it didn't help that they had this audio tape that they played for everyone in the courtroom,
so they just threw the book at them for these murders, yes.
So they had them for murders of three children, John Kilbride, Leslie Ann Downey, and Edward Evans.
They're in prison.
Fast forward 20 years to the mid-80s.
In the 1980s, news broke that Brady and Hinley were not responsible for the death of three children.
but rather five after they revealed two more victims.
The two additional children had been missing since the mid-60s.
Police immediately began searching them more for their bodies,
even taking Brady and Hinley out of prison to assist in the search.
So they got a field trip day.
That must have been fun.
Hey, guys, you want to go help us find those other dead kids we didn't know about?
Yeah, sure.
I probably remember where they are.
We'll get pizza after.
Yeah, you promise?
Pinky sweater.
Pizza.
So how fun is that?
They're both serving multiple wife sentences for the murders of these three children.
And then 20 years later, they're like, hey, it turns out I think they killed a couple more kids, too.
Yeah, look at this.
Go figure.
Jesus.
So Myra Hinley really wants to get out of prison.
Now, Brady, not so much.
He's like, you know what?
That's fine.
I'll spend the rest of my days in prison.
But he finds ways to still get around young boys.
He goes on these hunger strikes.
In jail?
In jail.
And so they have to send them to the hospital because obviously that causes issues.
Well, they don't have to send them to the children's hospital.
You would think that.
And prison would not stop Brady's predatory behavior.
In 2019, it was reported that Brady actually had contact with teenage boys who were being treated for mental health issues in the same prison hospital he was held in during one of his hunger strikes.
The hospital quickly noticed Brady's interest in the young boys and would move them off his floor.
Pretty sneaky shit, huh?
I'm not feeling hungry today.
Yeah, exactly.
Wow.
All right, so look, here we have a couple.
They would work together to abduct children,
to then rape them and murder them and bury them.
And that's all horrible in all reasons to vote for my couple as the creepiest couple.
But here, here is the real reason to vote for me.
Oh, I don't like a kicker.
In prison, Hinley became a born-again Christian.
and would spend years trying to obtain parole.
She became a bored again after all of us.
I'm so sorry for what I've done.
The Lord has redeemed me.
Yeah, just fucking give in to Satanism and have some fun with it
if you're going to live this type of lifestyle.
Nobody wants to hear about how you're a bored again now.
Fortunately, she'll take anyone.
Those Christians will take anyone, won't they?
Yeah, no shit.
Jesus Christ.
Mara Hindley died in 2002 at the age of 60,
and Brady died in 2017.
at the age of 79, and neither of them were free ever again for these heinous crimes.
They really were a problem.
They were a problem.
But were they still a couple at that point where they were in prison and everything?
Yeah, they were writing notes to each other and stuff.
Yeah, there was actually a lot of love there.
Aw.
She was really obsessed with this guy.
Yeah.
Yeah, well, there you go, kids.
You have your opportunity to vote this week at R slash the creep off.
That's right.
Go to our subreddit where you'll find the poll there and you can vote for who you thought brought the creepiest couple this week.
I need a victory to keep this thing going.
So please.
Or what we could do is have a really fun episode next week where Carl has to spin the wheel and maybe have to do something stupid on his way to Gary Hediana.
Who knows?
That's not fun.
It's up to you guys to vote and pick.
Nobody finds that fun.
But, you know, those two weren't fucking babies into people and to kids.
So I'm just going to say that.
Carl, I think...
That would mean they'd have to keep them alive, Vinny, in order to do that.
So that's the reason why.
Yeah, that's a good point.
All right, are you ready for another edition of Who Are These Creepos?
Am I?
I think it starts a little something like this.
Creepos.
That's right.
That's a segment on the creep-off where we like to prove that we are the best true crime show on the internet.
And the way that we do that, Vinny, is we find every other true crime podcast.
and we break them down one of the time to show you why ours is far superior in many ways, if not, every single way.
And today I want to present to you a show called Dark Poutine, a true crime and dark history podcast.
And let me read you the tagline here, a podcast about notorious Canadian crimes, dark history, and other creepy topics as told by real live Canadians.
So listen, I hate that they threw the and other creepy topics in there.
Yep. That's the shit that drives me crazy.
That's annoying. Can't you guys just do a true crime show about true crime?
Nope.
Because they are pigeonholed into only doing Canadian things and Canada's a boring place.
God, how many fucking Sasquatch episodes do they have?
So, yeah, there's only so much they can do.
All right, this is hosted by Mike Brown and Matthew Stockton.
Now, Mike Brown is really the one in charge here.
He's doing most of the talking.
He's telling the story.
I don't even know, like, what Canadian, like, famous crimes are.
I'm guessing, like, the maple syrup murders or something like that.
Well, we all know about that one, right?
Yes.
The Back Bacon Massacre.
I don't know.
Yeah.
I think there was an H.L game where somebody got to stick to the head.
Yeah.
Oh, no.
All right.
So let's start with the introductions.
And let's just see how excited these guys are to be doing a show.
Welcome to.
To Dark Putine. I am Mike Brown. And this is Matthew Stockton. Hello. Hello, Matthew. How are
that? I am great. Good. I don't know how to answer in the, uh, ye oldy worldy. In the old world,
but anyway. I took my blood pressure medication and I'm happy. Oh, because this is a Mr. Big
episode. Exactly. Ah. Gets my blood boiling. Yeah, me too. Wow. What the fuck is this?
That's some chemistry, huh? I mean, if that doesn't hook you right away, that's how the show starts. You're
like, why? I can't wait. Dear, these two have a conversation with each other.
This is going to be amazing. Yeah. The fucking ye old douchebag in his blood pressure pills.
Yes. And the nerd. Great show. God. This Matthew Stockton guy is infuriating. But I want to start
off with the warning that they give before the show starts. Dark Putine is not for the faint of heart
or squeamish. Our content is often intense and some listeners may find it disturbing. We're not
experts on the topics we present, nor are we journalists.
We are ordinary Canadian schmucks chatting about crime and the dark side of history.
Let's get to it.
Oh, okay.
So they have zero credentials.
Okay, that's good to know.
I mean, we don't have to announce that at the beginning of the show, do we?
Meaning, you know why we don't?
Because we're both professional podcasters.
Do you think that's maybe like a Canadian rule?
Hey, you better tell everybody you don't know what you're talking about there before you start
spoutting out of the mouth.
That's actually very possible.
I don't know.
This is a weird one, Carl.
And by the way, can I just say one thing?
Yes.
I fucking hate Poutine.
I think it sucks.
I do too.
It fucking sucks.
Not a big gravy guy, but, you know, if you're going to put gravy on mashed potatoes, fine.
French fries are good enough.
You don't need that shit.
Hey, Cam Critical with the $1.99.
Best of luck on your wheel spin, Carl.
Oh, fuck off, Cam Critical.
All right.
So now, Vinny, I don't know if you realize what cards these guys are, but listen to this
disclaimer and get ready to
laugh. You are responsible
for obtaining and maintaining at your own cost
all equipment needed to listen to Dark Poutine. Dark Poutine
can be addictive. Side effects may include, but
not be limited to you, pausing and questioning the system.
Elevated heart rate, pondering humanity.
Odd looks from colleagues as he laugh out at work. Family
members, not into true crime worrying about you.
Positive side effects may include some perspectives and opinions
that you disagree with as well as some won'tness and empathy.
If you don't think Dark Poutine is for you, consult
your doctor immediately. This dude is
fucking corny. Pretty
funny stuff, huh? Oh, it's addictive.
huh?
Yeah.
Yeah, I'm going to quit it after we get done with this.
I think I'm going to go cold turkey on this one, Vinnie.
They would throw you right the fuck out of the Betty Ford Center if you walked in.
It's like, I'm addicted to dark butteen.
Yeah, nobody is.
These Canadians are so fascinating.
Now, Vinny, what's one thing the Canadians can't stop talking about?
What's the one thing that if you get to a conversation with a Canadian, you know is going to come up?
Is it the weather?
Ice hockey is the answer.
The weather.
Have you ever spoken to anyone in Canada?
a girl, they're like, oh, beautiful day.
Everything is, oh, terrible day.
Oh, beautiful day.
It's all weather, man.
I thought they just talked about being America's hat all the time, but no, they talk
about hockey, and they're talking about this small town in Manitoba, and for whatever
reason, they have to bring up that that's where Ed Belfour is from.
Do you know who Ed Belfour is?
The goalie.
He is, yes, very good.
Now, this guy, Matthew Stockton, is a gay gentleman, and the fun thing about gay guys is
They don't know their sports.
This is going to be really funny.
Although tiny, Carmen is notable for being the hometown of Eddie the Eagle Balfour,
who played goal for the Chicago Blackhawks, Florida Panthers, San Jose Sharks, Dallas Stars,
and, of course, the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Also known as Crazy Eddie for his quirky behavior on and off the ice,
Balfour was inducted into the Manitoba Sports Hall of Fame after he retired from professional hockey in 2008.
I'm glad you mentioned it's hockey because you're naming all those teams.
Yes.
And I was trying to figure out what sport it was.
If I'm talking about a team sport, it's usually hockey.
That's the one where they're on blades and they shoot a disc at net with sticks.
That's correct.
In case our listeners don't know.
Yeah.
Good one.
It's pretty funny.
I feel like you don't know what hockey is.
Oh, what's that?
And then I'll explain it to you in the dumbest way possible to make me sense.
Like, you're just trying to put yourself over, dude.
You're trying to act too cool for the room.
Correct.
It's not like you're too fucking fat and ugly for the room.
So I was trying to figure out, like, what's the reason for this guy to be on this show?
Like, what does he bring to the show?
Well, dynamite drop-ins, like this example.
Now they're going through this true crime story.
Kyle had worked in Alberta since he'd left school the year before, so he was home for just that purpose.
For the summer, let's have a little bit of a whoop-de-do.
A whoop-do.
Dynamite drop-in, Monty.
that broadcast school has really paid off he repeated i'm going to start doing that to you i'm just
going to repeat whatever you said last g willigers g willikers minnie carl's a shithead whoopty-do
that's the name of this episode whoopty-do yeah uh Carl we need that drop okay we need that good
whoopty-do that's good stuff oh fucking horrible let me see if i could find that within the clip i
think it's right here oh whoopty-do good stuff
there, Matthew. Matthew's not done there, though, Vinnie. This is going to be, this is really
going to crack you up. I have a feeling. I'm so not addicted yet. So in Manitoba, there's a town
called Miami. Now, the reason why this is going to be funny is because there's also a city
named Miami in the state of Florida. And the weather there's very different than it is in
Manitoba. All right, maybe you were right. Maybe they do talk about the weather. Here you go.
Kyle and John walked around the festival grounds briefly
before becoming involved in a game of pickup football
and drinking beer with some other young men
the boys knew from school, Miami Collegiate.
Imagine if you move from abroad thinking you're going to Miami Collegiate
because that's what your parents told you.
Yes.
So you rock up and you arrive at school in the Manitoba winter
and you're totally depressed in your shorts.
Miami, Manitoba, yeah.
Oh, well.
I think that's probably an over-promise.
Yeah, it seems like it
Imagine that, Vinnie
Remember in the warning
They said you were going to be laughing
At your desk and co-workers
Be looking like, what's up with this guy?
What are we laughing at?
You're going to hear it more like
Sighing and groaning
Yeah
Oh, could you imagine
Somebody goes to Miami Collegiate
And then they have their shorts on
But they're really in Canada
Could you imagine that, Vinny?
They went to Miami of Ohio
Oh!
Whoa! Whoa! There's three Baha'is! Shut the fuck up.
I usually like Canadians. This is... If this is...
So now, Mike Brown...
Not doing it for me.
Our narrator here is going to set up Matthew and Matthew's got nothing all of a sudden.
He's got all these quips throughout the show until this.
She had been strangled and long, sharp sticks had been forced into her vagina and anus.
These were described as having been inserted with...
great force.
There were many other injuries to her body.
Where's the joke, funny, man?
There's your opportunity.
We're shoving sticks and eight instances of vaginas over here.
You got something?
Great Force, like Star Wars.
I bet it was Darth Vader who did it, right?
The old Sith Lordy.
Fuck that guy.
This guy's a real-life chip chipper said.
Fucking sucks.
So now we're going to get a little peek
into what his life is like at home
because they're talking about how
one of the kids who was convicted of this murder
talked to the police without having
an attorney present. Now, Vinny, you and I
have mentioned this before on our show.
Don't do it. Don't do that.
Well, this guy also feels very
strongly about that. Tim was
also a minor at the time, so his parents
wanted to ensure their son had proper
representation. You know, when my husband
and I watched a movie or true
crime documentary, we both
yell, lawyer. Yeah, me too.
At the screen, whenever a character's put into a police interview situation.
Yeah.
I tell you, if I was picked up for anything, even if I knew I was totally innocent and had a rock solid alibi, I would not utter a single word to the police without a lawyer.
Yeah.
I just wouldn't do it.
Not a single word.
We get it.
Yes, I know.
Have an attorney present.
Wow, you're so interesting.
You and your husband, both a lawyer at the TV?
Wow.
What else do you guys?
Fascinating, guys.
Good stuff.
By the way, that conversation goes on.
I know I'm trying not to drag down Arsha with these clips and it's brutal.
But that conversation...
But here you are anyway.
I know.
That conversation goes out for another 90 seconds.
And I'm going, yeah, I know, I would get an attorney.
Oh, I would always get an attorney.
You know, I didn't do it.
I know, we get it.
Fucking move on.
This guy brings nothing and relishes in it for some reason.
Matthew and his husband don't get invited to do a lot of parties, folks.
No.
I doubt they do.
Oh, this is a weird way.
So apparently, one of the suspects' hair, like a single strand of hair, was found in the victim's sweater.
Listen to how he says this.
A hair found on Bridget's pants was consistent with having originated from Tim Hulahan's scalp.
Why do you talk that way?
Was consistent with having originated from Tim Hulahan's scalp?
They found his hair.
You say it was Tim Hoolahad's hair?
Where did it originate from?
His scalp?
I believe his forearm.
What?
Dude, no one cares.
Where is my...
Hold on.
So bad.
I don't care.
I don't care.
Matthew would love this.
Matthew would be singing.
Everybody.
I don't care.
I hate them.
Yep.
I got one more clip for you, Vinny.
And this is always fun.
When you think you're going to have...
advertising and you don't that's always good only days after bridges death both kylunger and
tim hulahan were arrested and charged with first degree murder more after a quick break
and we're back matthew thoughts on this episode so far that always makes me laugh i know it's
Guys. And we're back, everybody. Yeah, we don't. Listen, if you, if you are just recording a podcast. Yeah. And you want to take a break. Just take a break. And then just pick up where you left off and clip it. Yeah. Thank you. You don't need to put in bizarre transitions. No, you don't. It's just not ad production. I put dynamic advertising in who are these podcasts. Oh, I've heard. And if you hear it, you hear it. And if you don't, you don't. I don't embarrass myself by going, all right. Now, hopefully the sales team has sold some inventory. And you're going, you're going. You're going.
going to hear an advertisement right now.
No, he didn't.
Oh, fuck.
All right.
Heads are going to roll.
I like that he comes back, too, from that break.
And immediately, he's like, hey, Matthew, what do you think about this so far?
He's like, no, why are you going to Matthew?
He's got nothing.
Don't ever do that.
This guy has, then they have a whole voicemail segment.
This is the problem with true crime.
You can build an audience no matter how bad you are.
These guys suck.
And yet they have an audience for this.
Is that why we have an audience just because it's true crime?
Yeah.
Oh.
I'm convinced.
Look at the two of us
We are visual cancer
It's not good
Wow
All right
So that is Dark Butene
A Canadian shit
podcast
Oh Canada
Please cut their mics
Carl
Yes
You want to do some voicemails
Let's do voicemails
All right
The voicemail segment on the creepoff
as always is brought to by our friends in Syracuse.
The Creepoff voicemail segment
is brought to by the city of Syracuse.
No Super Bowl commercial for us.
We are proud to be the exclusive sponsor of the Creepoff.
As they are the only show that accepts payment
in Circuit City gift cards.
See you in Syracuse.
I'm going to get a DVD player.
Ooh, I'm going to get a TV that has the DVD player built into it.
Lucky.
That's all the rage now.
It's going to go right.
in my dorm room.
Oh, God.
So, Carl, I asked people last week to send in their restaurant stories.
Oh, right.
Yeah, and I would give away a free Supercast subscription to somebody today as we go through
these.
There's lots of stuff mixed in.
Am I judging?
Do I get to be a judge?
Absolutely.
You could pick.
I'm pretty biased towards this one because this is pretty creepy, but also kind of satisfying.
Carl, Vinny.
I used to work at Pizza Hut
and my principal called in
so we took a thin crust pizza
and we put it on a toilet seat
before making it
it was glorious
creepy
I'm a little confused by that one
don't fuck the pizza
but if it's your principal
they put on their toilet seat before making it
it then they put it in the oven afterwards
yeah but then they bake it all the
fucking disease from a pizza on toilet i don't know about that all right it's fun though all right i'm
gonna skip this one here we go this is a message from vietnam uh an experience actually in
vietnam okay so about the restaurants uh i was actually in vietnam before and uh i don't think it
How many kills?
I'm a subscriber anyway, so, you know, I pay whatever.
All good, no worries.
But when I was in Vietnam, I had this food stand for about two weeks, and then, you know,
I drop off my dry cleaning, and the one day they wanted me to pick it up early.
So I figured, you know what, whatever, it's only an hour earlier than I wake up, and that's fine.
I'll do that.
walk past the food stand that I ate at every day
and a woman
cutting up half a cattle,
cow, whatever, water buffalo
on the sidewalk, using the sidewalk
as a butcher's block.
And it was pretty gross, but
don't think of it like American style.
Think of it as they're stray dogs and cats
walking all over,
shitting everywhere. People just
throw their garbage
on the ground
the road crew comes
along and
throws it along the curve and
burns it all at the end of the road
and then
not only that
there's a lot of flash flooding there
which means there's sewers flood over it too
and yeah
I ate there for two weeks
and then I saw that
and then I still went back and ate there
that was the best food I ate it was awesome
I love it.
All right
All right.
So is that a thing then?
Because I was mentioning on the show last week that there's a Vietnamese restaurant here
where I saw people cutting vegetables on the floor.
Is that just where they cut?
Apparently.
Okay.
Doesn't that dull the blade of a knife, though, if you're just, like, cutting on the floor?
Yeah.
I would imagine that's not the best way to go.
All right.
Well, that's not the problem there.
Probably the only thing, Vinny.
All right, since you play my voicemails, damn it.
number one
creepy-ass restaurant story
I never worked in one
but I
helped a guy go
pick up a commercial stove
from one for scrap purposes
and
walked into one of the
biggest restaurants in Charlotte, North Carolina
to find some
big ex-con
looking guy with his dreadlocks
hanging down into a
giant pot of grit
Yeah, that was fun
Never ate there
Thank God
That's so gross
Second thing
This is just something I thought of
Because I've been going through old episodes again
All right
Of
WAPP
Creepoff
All the shit Carl's involved in
Appreciate it
This question is for Carl
Yeah
Do we all remember
Carl's no shitting at work policy
Carl you now work at home
Does that mean you never shit?
I just want to know the answer to that one.
All right.
That's it for now.
Carl, what say you?
Do you shit?
I now shit at work every single day now that I work from home.
So that's the answer to that.
All right.
I'm not as upset with the shitting at work thing anymore, surprisingly, now that I don't have to go into work.
I should tell you, too, a quick backstory on that.
Yeah.
The building that my company was in, they didn't build it great.
the bathrooms didn't have any ventilation.
Neither of the bathrooms had a fan.
So when people would shit up the bathroom,
it just stunk up the hall and there was just nothing you could do about it.
Everybody had to smell their brand.
Yes.
Yeah.
So that was part of the problem, I would imagine.
I guess people gave me a lot of grief for being doubted on shitting at work.
A lot of people have to pass times.
I apologize.
Those are our restaurant stories we got.
If I didn't play yours, it's because it was really way too long.
Sorry, folks.
please. I mean, some of these were a little long
already anyway, Carl. I have a
voicemail for us real quick. Please. Speaking
I got a couple more, but I wanted to vote on
the who gets the supercast. All right, let's do
that. Let's vote on that real quick.
The Vietnam story I liked
probably the best.
But he led with
he already is a subscriber and doesn't want it.
Oh, okay. Pizza Hut was fun.
Okay. And I liked how short it was.
Yep. That was well done. Yep.
So what do you think?
I'll go Pizza Hut.
Okay. I'll go Pizza Hut.
Congratulations.
Call back in and leave me your email address
and I will send you a link for your free Supercast subscription
where you could get free bonus episodes of the creep-off.
Now, for the rest of you, you could support us on patreon.com.
You can find us on Supercast.
You can also find us on backed.
And we really appreciate your support.
You'll get a new episode every week.
We'll be back on Wednesday with a new one for you, a new bonus episode.
Carl, play your voicemail.
Hey, this is Dave from Buffalo.
I have one of these
funny, silly songs for everybody.
Here it goes. It goes a little
something like this.
Vinny's fat.
Vinny's fat.
Vinny's a fat, fat fuck.
He's a greasy fat fuck.
He's a fucking greasy pile of shit,
and he's a greasy fat fuck.
Vinny hits his fucking wagon.
into a greasy potato
because he was hoping
to eat some french fries
Vinny's fat, Vinny's fat,
Vinny's a fat, fat fuck,
Vinny's a fat piece of shit.
Fuck, Vinny, fuck the dolphins.
Vinny's a fat, fat piece of shit.
Gold polar pung you, fat piece of shit.
I hope you get hypothermia
and you die in Lake Ontario.
You're a fat, fat, fat, fuck.
You're a fucking fat piece of shit.
Charles's great.
Vinny's fat and worthless.
Yeah, yeah. Vinnie's fat and worthless. Vinnie's fat and he's really, really worthless. Fat, fat, Vinny. Go fuck yourself, Vinnie.
Fat, you're fat, Vinny. Wow. Holy shit. That's so I just got to keep getting better and better, didn't it? That was like Bohemian Rhapsody. That they just went different layers, different levels.
Fantastic. Oh, I think you should actually put that.
I don't listen to this. I want to listen to my master's before it goes up. I guess I fuck you, Vinny, you're a fat piece of shit.
All right.
Sorry, he was still there.
Jesus is great, Dave.
Great song.
Great song.
I'll probably have the ice test put some music to it.
We're going to the studio this week.
Oh, that'll be good.
I would really like to hear how that turns out with a nice, a nice orchestra.
Yeah, yeah.
We'll put a couple guitar solos in there.
It'll be great.
Good, good.
He's a fat fuck.
He's a fat, fat, fat, fat, fat, fat, fat, fat, fat, fat, fat, fat.
He's a fat, he's a fat, da, da, da, da, da.
All right, that's what's mean.
I don't know what to say that.
That was a little mean.
You're right.
Oh, cares.
Gives this shit.
Moving along.
What else you got any more, Carl?
No, that's all I have.
All right.
We'll get through these last two real quick.
Let's do it.
This is someone corrected me from last week and giving me a much better punchline.
Hey, Vinnie.
I'm not trying to do your job for you, but the joke is right there.
Jason and the Taco Collar Dreamcoat.
That's correct.
Thank you, sir.
Here we go.
Oh shit, Carl.
What?
This fucking thing.
I got another nomination.
Pizza guy, hold on.
Hold on, pizza guy.
Oh, no.
This poor guy's got a cold.
Okay, Vinny, you asked for some fast food or food work confessions.
Please don't nominate me as a creep.
Back in 2001, I used to working on Orange Julius.
Never get an actual Orange Julius.
It's fresh squeezed lemonade.
They had to, what you had to do is we had to cut the oranges in half, and they had this, like, weird juicing thing where you push that, the half of the orange on it, and it would just spin really fucking fast.
And I had, like, the dexterity of a toddler when I was 16, so I would skin my fucking knuckles every fucking time I made the orange juice.
Oh, no.
And I don't want to have to fucking juice all those oranges again, so I just leave the fucking.
skin and blood and shit in there.
I'm like, whatever.
And then
all the old people walking around the mall
would bring their drinks back like an hour
and a half later and be like, it's not cold anymore.
This is settled. You need to remix it.
Like, you've been walking around the mall
for an hour and a half. Like, come on, you fuck.
Like, I'm 16.
I don't want to, I don't want to remix your drink.
So what I do is I just take them
all in the back. And if they have
the same drink, I'd mix them all
together and just fucking re-pour them and
cups, I'd swap their lids, you know, put shit out, like, I, if I had to remix your drink
and you fucking complain to me, you did not want to put your fucking lips on that straw.
Anyhow, yep, I was not a good person.
Yeah.
Thank you, fuck you by.
Wow.
Wow, it's a blood orange Julius.
No, thank you.
Uh, Carl, do you want to change your vote?
Yes.
All right.
Congratulations.
Julius calling.
Sorry, Pete, that.
I might take care of him too
It was my mistake
So here we go
There's a suggestion for the wheel
Here we go
I creep off crew
I had a consequence suggestion
You can call it the Walmart pedophile challenge
One of you
Or the loser goes into Walmart
And the winner goes in and screams
This guy is here to meet an 11 year old girl
and just follows them around
and screams that for a little bit.
I think that's a great consequence
and I don't think it's too damaging,
especially at a Walmart.
You could just do it at another town or something.
Goodbye.
Yeah, I'm sure it'll be fine.
That's a great idea.
I can see Mitty really getting into it.
I can see Mitty be convinced
that I have a pedophile.
If I lose and you're doing that to me,
I'm just going, no, I wasn't!
No, I wasn't!
I'm retarded!
Leave me alone!
This man is harassing me
And I've gotten it
I need an adult
I need an adult
Oh god damn it Carl
It's a funny idea
Those are our voicemails this week
You guys are the funnest
Yes
We have good listeners on the show
Carl
I'm going to hit the music
And we're going to do a scum parade buddy
Let's go
Scum parade
Take me on a raid
Of these fucks your raids
That these creeps have made
Scum Parade
Vinny and Carl
Gonna tell you about some fuck shit
Scum parade
Like stories of a kid
Fucked by his mom or dad
Soking up the blood of a cat
Scum parade
I hate to feature
Girls Basketball two weeks in a row
Yeah
But a lot of shit is going out of girls' basketball
This is a bizarre story.
Multiple girls basketball coaches were fired from a Virginia high school after a 22-year-old assistant coach was caught impersonated to a 13-year-old junior varsity player who was out of town during a January game.
Video allegedly shows the Churchland High School coach Arlisha Boykin's posing as a youth player during the game on January 21st.
She made a layup.
she's grabbing rebounds.
She did miss a free throw.
Dude, honestly, the funniest part about this,
so how old is this woman?
She's 23?
Yeah.
And she's playing with 13-year-old girls.
She's not even very good.
She did make that one layup,
but she missed the free throw
and a field goal attempt
after the rebound on that.
And their team sucks.
Well, I mean,
girls basketball.
But I'm not sure what they were trying to accomplish here.
It was so embarrassing the team
that the team has now quit.
They're not even going to play.
any more games. They're like, you know what? This is
really just embarrassing. I mean, they should have spoken
up when the coach, like, showed up in uniform.
Yeah. Well, yeah, no shit.
I just think this is the silliest thing.
It's so, it's crazy. How did they think
they would get away with?
You, my friend,
have committed a crime. You cheated those other kids.
You think you could get away with that?
Without having legal
ramifications? You're
out of your fucking mind.
Well, she lost her job.
A bunch of the coaches got fired and the kids won't play anymore.
They should have just called her the prank.
Why couldn't they just say, oh, it's for the goof?
I would have just been like, what we all look alike.
Ooh, that's a good one, too.
That's how you do it.
That shuts people up quick.
Yep.
Let's keep moving, Carl.
Altuna, Pennsylvania.
Okay.
A 43-year-old woman faces 30 charges, including second-degree murder for allegedly setting a home on fire,
which killed a 75-year-old man.
Okay.
Now, according to a statement.
statement on February 15th.
The Altoona Police Department and fire department
responded to a house
where an occupant escaped out of a second
story window and called for help at a neighbor's
house. Three firefighters were injured while
extinguishing the blaze. Officials
located a deceased male in the house.
Hold on a second, Benny. Yeah. Three firefighters
were hurt putting out a house fire?
Yeah. Isn't that their job?
Volunteers, man. Fucking lame.
Did their fucking job? What next?
Carl Hamburger was injured podcasting
today. Like, come on, man.
How are you getting to hurt doing that?
So an autopsy reveal the man dies of smoke inhalation.
And as they went around and searched the house, they found accelerants in the stairs
and the common areas of the house.
Now, Atuna police said detectives learned that Heather Evans was seen leaving the home right before the fire.
The next day, Evans reportedly commented on a chicken coop that was located nearby this house.
and she commented on it to a friend
and the next thing everybody knew
the whole chicken coop was up in flames.
Then on March 3rd,
a garage on Crawford Avenue
in Altoona caught fire
and police had physical evidence
allegedly placed evidence at the seat
of the last two fires
in addition to being seen at the house
on 5th Avenue.
So she got arrested on February 7th
and she faces charges of cruelty to animals
recklessly endangering another person
and probably manslaughter, the victim who died in the fire, you know, his family's pissed,
the whole house that is damaged.
I mean, he's a 75-year-old guy.
This whole thing's crazy.
It's understatement.
She told police that she's a meth addict and what she uses, she believes that she's the Egyptian goddess Isis.
Yeah, so she says that she's a white witch and an Egyptian goddess.
Yeah, that doesn't work.
Which I'm like, look, and I'll go along with whatever you want to say, but you got to pick a lane.
I don't know what that means.
Yeah, you're a witch, you're a goddess, what are you?
She's being held without bail right now, and I think that's probably for the best.
So, Vinnie, I've never done meth, but I'm starting to think that I'm never going to.
Oh, you got turned off by it.
Yeah, I mean, the PR for it is not good.
I find only Donald Trump has more negative stories than meth at this point.
It's like Donald Trump,
math state of Florida
Yeah
Jeffrey Epstein's in there somewhere too
Yeah it's not good
It's not going well
Well Carl you know who it didn't go well for
Who's that?
A young lady in England recently
Did you read this story?
I believe this one was sent in
by a deeply unprincipled
Oh yes yes
I did read this one
Yeah Warrington England Carl
Wesley Rodden he's 33 years old
He was on the run from the police
When he stumbled upon an 18 year old woman
in Victoria Embankment Gardens
who was said to have been being
raped by another man.
Yep.
Now, the other man
has not been caught.
This guy has.
He denies this was a rape
because basically
the story goes
according to the woman.
She had drank a lot of vodka,
beer, and cider.
She got separated
from another group of girls.
She ended up with this guy.
She did weed, cocaine,
ketamine, and her blood
alcohol level would have resulted
in a significant degree of intoxication.
Hey, Vinnie, can I interrupt real quick?
I got to change into my victim blaming shoes.
Hold on a second.
Let me just pop these on.
It's a beautiful day in the neighborhood.
A beautiful day for victim blaming in the hood.
Let's get ready for some victim blaming here, Vinny.
All right.
So her friends went into McDonald's to try to sober up.
Like I said, she separated from her friends.
She was caught on a close circuit TV walking down the street with a mysterious male.
now she says the snapshot this is the quote the snapshot i have in my head is lying on the grass in the
park with a man over me and feeling pain around my hips right the teenager explained i remember
lying on the grass and my underwear and tights were around my ankles and my legs were pushed up
the first man i don't remember his face i could feel him having sex with me and a pain in my
hips it felt surreal i'd say i was 10 out of 10 drunk okay
I'd say too, yeah.
I remember his body moving over me.
She was trying to get into a club earlier,
and they wouldn't even let her in the club
because she was so wasted.
Yeah.
Don't get this drunk, ladies.
Yeah, it's not good.
My knees were up in my chest,
and I was just waiting for it to be over
and was blacking out, she said.
Then another man came over with the beard
and said, can I have a go?
And the first man says,
that's a bit weird.
The second guy says,
once I leave, you could do what you want with her.
The second man looked at me
and saw I wouldn't do anything or stop it.
He was over me and he was gone.
I woke up on the grass, realized everything that would happen.
I was on the grass and clicking.
And clicking in my head, all the snapshots leading up and ran to the gate, was banging on the gate.
And I told a man I needed helping to call the police.
I don't remember how I got to the park.
I don't know where my friends were.
I was scared and confused.
I do have to say, Vin, Mind if I cut in is a very odd thing to say when you witness a girl being raped.
Mind if I dance with your own day.
Yeah, exactly.
Now, also a funny response is
That's a bit weird
I think it's a funny response
I think what I would have said in that scenario
is I've got this sentence
but you go ahead and take the other out
That's fine
There's two other holes
Yeah
So prosecutor
The prosecutor said that when he was questioned
by the police
Mr. Roden said that
quote
She had the time of a life
Yep
He said she was quote a slut
And she told him
She had sex with strangers
Every weekend
and was, quote, a twisted little slag.
He also told police, she is trying to stitch me up,
insisting she physically pulled him towards her to carry out the sex act.
She wanted it.
Of course she did.
She's having a grand old time.
Drugs are, bud.
This guy's got 20 previous criminal convictions,
including assault, theft, harassment, criminal damage, threatening behavior,
and he's pled not guilty to raping the young woman.
In his defense, he wasn't looking to go out and rape some girl that night.
It's a crime of opportunity.
Correct.
Yes, it was presented to him.
That is really a bizarre, bizarre story.
Yeah, not good.
You want to hear another story that's not good?
Let's do it.
Let's go to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.
Back to Pennsylvania, all right.
A 12-year-old girl's body was found in the basement,
freezer of a home, leading to the arrest of her mother's ex-boyfriend.
Oh, boy.
39-year-old Jason Shackleford is charged with one count of criminal homicide.
police were called to the Wyndham-Lancaster home on Friday for a disturbance
and encountered a woman.
The woman said she was working the night shift from February 8th and 9th and that Shackleford told her he kidnapped her 12-year-old daughter from their home.
The woman explained she was going through a breakup with Shackleford and she had asked him to,
and she had asked him to move out.
Instead, when she was working, she got a text from him saying her daughter was sick in bed.
Okay.
When the woman returned home just over an hour later, she got into an argument with Shackleford, who showed her the daughter's empty bed.
He told the woman he took the girl to New York and that she was safe.
That's a fun way to get back at your ex, I got to say, kidnapping the daughter.
Magic tricks?
Yeah, that's always fun.
Over the next day, the woman said Shackleford raped her and then forced her to go to the hotel with him, where he used her daughter's well-being as leverage to sexually assault her again.
now here's where he messed up
where did he mess up
but yeah I know
so far as this is going well
but what did he do wrong?
First off everything
but then to top it all off
he let this woman
go outside for a cigarette
oh boy
and she went and found the hotel staff
and told them to call the police
now when the police detained Shackaford
and interviewed him on Friday
he admitted to raping and killing
the little girl on Friday
February 8th
and into the morning on February 9th
while the mother was away at work.
He told investigators that he was attempting to conceal the girl's body in the basement in the freezer.
Police found the girl's body during the first search of the home, and they did not identify the woman or the daughter.
And as of Friday, police had additional charges may be filed, and the autopsy investigation is ongoing.
So he hasn't been arraigned yet, but he, like, got her out of there, took her to a hotel.
Like, he was just trying, like, he was just going to go on the run with the mom, all while telling her that, yeah, I'll give you your daughter back one day.
to fucking try to keep her complacent and obedient.
It's fucked up.
This is a real rapy episode that we're doing this week, Vinnie.
Can we go back to talking about, like, putting pizzas on toilet seats and fun stuff like that?
This is getting pretty disturbing.
Yeah, well, lucky for us, that is the last story on the scum parade today.
Thank goodness.
Holy, wow.
Holy cow, folks.
Holy cow.
That's all I got to say.
Whoopty-do.
Whoop-do.
whoopty-doo.
Now, Carl, that's the end of the show this week.
We'll be back next week.
Remember to go vote on our subreddit.
Support the show if you'd like to.
We always appreciate it.
Patreon, Supercast, and Backed Up.
Bye.
Well, we're going to have a bonus show this Wednesday at 1130.
Oh, shit.
No, you know what?
I've got to talk to you about that.
Okay.
I'm in the studio on Wednesday.
There'll be a bonus episode coming out this week.
We'll figure it out.
We'll do something good for you.
Until we meet again, remember?
Oh, no, no, hold on.
Stop that.
I am around on Wednesday for our bonus show.
Wednesday, 11.30 a.m.
We'll have a bonus show for you.
My bad.
It's nice to be important.
It's more important to be nice.
Gagia.
The Creep-off.
Ciao Bella.
May your enemies be cursed in your podcast adventures.
