The Happiness Lab with Dr. Laurie Santos - Why Eating Alone is so Bad for You (An International Day of Happiness Special).
Episode Date: March 20, 2025It's the International Day of Happiness! It's a chance to talk about happiness and what we can all do to be happier. March 20th also sees the release of the World Happiness Report. A big finding of 20...25's report is that more of us are dining alone - and that's bad news. The report's editor Jan-Emmanuel De Neve talks us through the stark figures showing that shared meals are in decline - while Dr Anne Fishel of The Family Dinner Project gives us her tips on how to dine better with friends, families and colleagues. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
PUSHKIN
PUSHKIN
Happy International Day of Happiness
The world has been marking March 20th as a day dedicated to happiness for over a decade,
part of a worldwide push to get governments to take happiness more seriously,
and to enact policies that improve our well-being.
International Day of Happiness also marks the release of the World Happiness Report.
And the Happiness Lab has been given early access to all the new research this report
contains.
And over the next two episodes, we've got lots of highlights, including things you can
do right now to improve your life.
The most famous headline-grabbing part of each year's World Happiness Report are the country rankings.
People around the world are asked,
on a scale of one to 10,
how satisfied are you with your life?
The crown for the happiest people
usually goes to a country somewhere in Scandinavia.
And this year, the happiest country is...
Finland!
Finland! Again!
But closely followed by Denmark and Iceland
and Sweden and the Netherlands, I think.
This is Jan-Emanuel Deneve, Professor of Economics and Behavioral Science at the University of Oxford
and editor of the World Happiness Report.
During the years he's studied these country data, he's noticed some changes.
The rankings used to be dominated by the big rich nations, but all that's changing.
Mexico and Costa Rica enter the top 10, Which is hugely exciting and kudos to them.
Eastern European countries continue their ascent and that goes at the expense of the
large industrial powers.
So Germany tumbles out at the top 20, the UK tumbles out at the top 20, and the US drops
at 24th.
Wow.
And then at the very bottom, Afghanistan still.
And this time, average life satisfaction in Afghanistan is a type 1.34 out of 10.
Wow.
As I said before, the country rankings tend to grab the headlines, but scientists like
Jan and I are even more interested in what's causing these differences in life satisfaction.
And one of the big factors might involve eating.
There's been a ton of discussion about what we eat, but the World Happiness Report takes a different approach. It focuses on who we're eating with. We tend
to eat 14 big meals a week. Who are we spending time with during all those lunches and dinners?
Well, it turns out that the answer to that question seems to have a big impact on our
well-being because the World Happiness Report found that some people share meals with others,
while some folks are going hungry for company.
So why focus on sharing meals?
The extent to which people share meals together as a proxy for the quality of our social connections
and the quantity of social connections that we have, essentially our social capital, if
you will.
In the last seven days over the past week, how many of your lunches and dinners were
shared with somebody else?
So about one in six people
approximately in the United States were dining alone.
In the early 2000s, 2003 to be precise,
and that's going up to one in four people is dining
alone in the United States by about 2023.
So that's a 53 percent increase or so in dining alone,
but strikingly, mostly youth.
To be really precise, youth are almost twice as likely
to be dining alone today as compared to two decades ago.
And I thought, wow.
These findings are huge,
because eating alone is pretty bad for you.
And a lot of us are finding ourselves
having lunch or dinner by ourselves,
even when we have families around us at home,
colleagues at work, or peers at college.
It's so easy to end up eating alone, so I've turned to an experienced clinical
psychologist, family therapist, and an advocate for shared meals for advice.
You could set the clock by my father walking through the door at seven o'clock
and dinner started at 10 after seven.
This is Dr. Ann Fischel, associate professor at the Harvard Medical School.
He would get out of his suit and put on his play clothes,
and we would sit down,
my mother, my father, and my sister.
We didn't really do any other rituals.
We didn't have Thanksgiving,
but dinner was sacrosanct.
My mother didn't like to be stuck in the kitchen,
so every meal she made was super quick.
So quick that years later when I hosted my first dinner
party, I put a roast chicken in and took it out after 30 minutes because I'd never seen her spend
more than 30 minutes in the kitchen. And of course, it was a bloody mess. But anyway, those dinners were
really important to me as a child. And looking back, I realized that a lot of the things that
I know now about being a family therapist, I learned around my childhood dinner table.
You know, how to diffuse conflict, how even if somebody's quiet, it doesn't mean that they
don't have a lot of things on their mind, how important it is to draw everybody out so everybody
has a chance to talk, how fun it is to hear stories
about family members, to hear gossip about people in the building or the neighborhood. So all of
that I learned at my dinner table. And such a believer in the virtues of us all eating together
that she helped found the Family Dinner Project. I asked her to explain a little bit about it. So I was one of the co-founders in 2010, and the mission is to build on the research-based
benefits of family dinner, the benefits that come from regular family dinners that bring
nutritional, cognitive, and mental health benefits.
I define family really broadly.
Family is anybody who makes you feel like home. Family
is anywhere that you find community. That could be people who aren't related to you.
I'm starting to work with patients with dementia, and I would say part of their family are the
other residents in the memory care unit, as well as the caregivers. It can be college-age kids eating together in a cafeteria.
It can be friends coming over
for a tired Wednesday night dinner.
And what we found was that 90% of most American families
think that family dinners are a great idea,
but fewer than 50% of families are eating dinner together.
So the Family dinner project was designed to
bridge that gap to make it easier, more doable, simpler, more fun, more meaningful, so that more
families could harness these research-backed benefits of family dinner. And so let's talk
about why family dinners are so important, maybe starting with the physical health benefits. How
can our physical health benefit from kind of having more family dinners? So there are
a lot of nutritional benefits that come from home-cooked meals even if you're
not trying that hard. Portion size tends to be smaller than the restaurant
equivalents which may account for lower obesity rates associated with regular
family dinners. But also home-cooked meals tend to be lower in sugar and salt
and fat and higher in sugar and salt and fat
and higher in fruits and vegetables and other nutrients. It's also associated with better
cardiovascular health in young teens and also associated with lower asthma symptoms, which
may be a little puzzling. Maybe it's because sometimes asthma is associated with anxiety,
which is lowered if the dinner is relaxing
and not so stressful.
Maybe it's because parents can remind their kids
to take medication.
So these are some of the health benefits.
And so your anxiety comment also reminds me
that there are lots of mental health benefits
to family dinners.
What are some of those?
There really are.
I mean, there's so many that as a family therapist,
I sort of joke,
I could almost be out of business if more families had regular family dinners. So they're
associated with on the part of kids, lower rates of anxiety and depression, lower rates
of substance use and teenage pregnancy, lower rates of eating disorders, and on the upside
with more resilience, more self-esteem, and
kids reporting that they feel more connected to their parents when they have regular family
dinners.
And then it turns out their mental health benefits for adults too, lower rates of depression
and anxiety for adults who eat with their kids, but also adults who eat with other adults.
I can get very, very excited about the mental health benefits.
Another benefit that was surprising when I first started reading your work is this idea
that there are also, especially for kids, these cognitive and academic benefits that
come from family dinners. What do we know about those?
Yeah. So for young kids or preschoolers and toddlers, the language that they hear around
the dinner table as their parents are sort of casually catching
up about the day, those little stories contain 10 times more unusual or rare words than would
be expected for a two-year-old or a three-year-old to know and 10 times more unusual words than
would show up in picture books that kids are read to. I think why that's significant is
that kids who have larger vocabularies
read earlier and more easily than kids who have slimmer vocabularies. I was just quoting this
research to my son who has a two-year-old grandchild, and she was saying to her parents,
what are you two talking about? And I said, that's so great. I hope you told her what you
were talking about because that is going to give a little
boost to her vocabulary.
So it seems like there are all these benefits, but it seems like sometimes when families
think about figuring out a family meal, it sometimes feels just totally overwhelming.
Sometimes families even treat it with dread.
Is this the kind of thing that you hear in the Family Dinner Project too?
Absolutely.
I mean, we are such a busy, tired, harried people.
Most of our kids are doing so many extracurricular activities
that it can just feel like one more thing on the to-do list.
And that is the number one challenge or obstacle.
We're too tired.
Our schedules don't mesh up.
And so at the Family Dinner Project,
we've spent a lot of time talking
to hundreds of thousands of families across the country to find out some workarounds for
this common challenge. So let's talk about some of the barriers you hear about most often. I
just think the biggest one is just time. Right. Time, being too tired, picky eaters, whether
that's a partner or a child, you know. What's the point of going to the trouble of
making a meal if not everybody's going to eat it? I don't want to be a short order cook
and make four different meals. I go to the trouble of making the meal and then all we
do is fight or nobody talks. I can't get people to talk. Conflict and tension at the table.
Budget worries. Healthy food is so expensive. How do I get my dollar to stretch so that I can feed my children unprocessed healthy food?
Distraction at the table, my kids turn on their gadgets and I guess we do too.
What do we do about technology at the table?
So I'd say those are the recurring obstacles that I hear about over and over.
We hear these barriers, it seems really like hard to get to dinner, but you've argued that part of the barriers
comes from our minds.
So we have these misconceptions about the things that
count as family dinners.
And so let's go through some of these misconceptions
and see if we can clear the air.
One of the misconceptions is this idea
that for a family dinner to really count as a family
dinner, everybody has to be there.
Everybody has to be there for the whole time.
Is this really the case?
How should we think about this differently?
First off, I want to say this isn't a nostalgia project. We're not trying to go back to the
spotless kitchens of the 1950s where a mother was home all day baking a pork loin. Fortunately,
that ship has sailed. So family dinner is less about the food than about what happens once the family gathers
around the food. So, really, best to focus on the atmosphere around the dinner table,
conversation, having a good time. You know, I call that the secret sauce of dinner. And
you're absolutely right. Family dinner doesn't have to be the whole family sitting down.
As one family said to me, we have a rule,
no one eats alone. This was a family with five sons and they did kind of split shift dinners.
So they would have two people eating and then later on, maybe one of those people would join
another and so on. And they would have one meal that could be reheated, maybe a stew or a soup.
So that's another myth. It doesn't have to be
everybody. It doesn't have to be dinner. For some families, dinner time is just beyond the pale.
It's just too hectic. It could be family breakfast. It could be a fabulous Sunday brunch
with extended family. There are really 16 opportunities in a week. Seven breakfasts,
seven dinners, and two weekend lunches. And
then they're also intentional snacks. Push away from your computer, come down to the
kitchen table at 10 o'clock, and let's have apples and hot chocolate. And then it doesn't
have to be family. It could be you and a best friend. It could be a Tuesday night group
that gets together to talk about books over food. It could be elders at assisted living breaking bread together.
It seems like one of the reasons that meeting together to have
these meals is so challenging is we put
these ridiculous restrictions on ourselves.
We get perfectionistic about it.
It seems like your goal at the Family Dinner Project is just to say,
we don't have to do this perfectly,
we just should do this a little bit more often.
It's family dinner with a bit more grace than we usually give ourselves.
I love the way you put that. Perfect is really not our friend here. Dinner with a toddler
might be five minutes. That's fine. That's something to build on. You know, the average
American dinner is only 22 minutes. Doesn't have to be food made from scratch. It doesn't
have to be heirloom tomatoes. Doesn't have to be a perfectly roasted chicken. It doesn't have to be perfect manners. Yes, let go of the perfect and give
yourself some more grace.
So eating meals with family, friends and colleagues has a ton of benefits. We're going to take
a quick break now, but when we get back and we'll have more tips on how to overcome all
the obstacles that stop us sharing meals.
Before the break, Dr. Anne Fischel took us through a lot of the things that stop us from enjoying shared meals,
be that eating with our loved ones at home,
having friends over, or sitting down with others
during our lunch break at work.
I asked Anne to break down those obstacles
and offer some concrete solutions.
For a lot of families, it just feels like another thing on their to-do list.
And, you know, partly I like to, without being too preachy, I hope, to say family meal time
is really the most reliable time that we have to look eye to eye, to have fun, to relax,
to share stories about our day. We don't sit around
campfires telling stories. We don't write letters with stories. So just reminding families
what a rich opportunity this is and how it packs really such a punch.
And then really trying to come up with some meals that are very, very easy, that you could
almost make in your sleep, food that you have in your pantry, like a pasta with tomato sauce,
or what I call my yoga eggs that I can make when I get off work at six and have to be out the door
by 630, that are just quick sauteed vegetables with eggs on top. So coming up with those and
getting a list of meals from your family
so that you won't get belly aching. You'll have like a rotating list of meals you know
are acceptable to every, maybe they don't all adore every meal, but they'll eat them
and you can get onto the more fun things about family dinner. And taking stock of whether
dinner is really the best time of day for your family. Maybe it's
breakfast. Years ago, Cheerios came to us and said, we know you're the family dinner project,
but how about the family breakfast project? And we came up with breakfast that took seven minutes,
because that's the amount of time, if you don't press your snooze alarm, you can get seven minutes
of your day back. And so we built easy meals with a game to play
at the breakfast table and a conversation starter. They were all about anticipating the day rather
than reviewing it. If you came up with a weather analogy for the day, what would it be? Then we
might check it at the end of the day, or what are you most looking forward to, or what are you worried
about? let's write
some notes and put them in each other's lunch boxes or lunch bags.
So that's another thing for very busy families is to pivot to something else.
You've also mentioned the possibility of engaging in what you've called flexible courses, and
this is particularly for families that might not have everybody home at the same time.
How does this work and why is it so effective? Yeah, so I'm thinking about it at different stages of the life cycle. If a couple
has a toddler who goes to sleep at seven and they want to have a family meal, but they're really not
ready to eat. So maybe they enjoy some cut up vegetables or some cheese with their toddler
while the toddler has her family dinner. They put their
toddler to bed and then they have the rest of their family dinner. Or if you've got kids,
as they get older, coming home late from sports practices, you might have a big nutritional snack
with them at five o'clock. And that's really the time that one parent and a child plays games, has conversation starters, enjoys that meal. But then when the child comes home at
eight o'clock, maybe they join in the family dinner and they have dessert with
the other family members. So it's the idea of sort of flexible courses,
depending on the age and stage of the child and how busy the different
schedules are. You can sort of mix
and match who eats what with whom, when.
You've also argued that one of the things we need to do to fight against these busy
schedules is to really push back on this culture of commitment. I thought this was a really
important one. What do you mean there?
Yeah. So there's a colleague of mine named Bill Daugherty, who's also a family therapist in Minnesota.
He mounted a statewide pushback program where he would
organize parents to go together to talk to
the coaches or the director of a play and say,
we love what you're doing,
our kids love being involved in soccer and Macbeth,
but family dinner is really important to
all of us for all these different reasons.
Could you adjust the rehearsal schedules?
Could you make them a little bit later,
have them end earlier so our kids can get home for dinner?
That was so much more effective than having one
squeaky wheel going into go to
the soccer coach to say,
please, please change the schedule.
I think that parents really have that power to influence extracurricular activities, and
I think they don't deploy it very often.
So those are some strategies we can use to push back against this barrier of time, right?
Get a little flexible, maybe have some short breaks, push back against some of these commitments.
What about strategies for people who just think that the cooking is too much work, that
the overwhelming part is really figuring out the dinner part? How
can they deal with that?
Yeah. So I would say our website, the Family Dinner Project, has a ton of great, easy recipes
that are eight ingredients or less, take 30 minutes or less, and families can sign up
and get a dinner tonight, which has a recipe
and then a conversation starter and a game. We have budget friendly, which they're about
$2.10 per person. There's that. There's also maybe making double or triple batches over
the weekend and freezing half of them or two-thirds of them so that next week you can just defrost a stew or a soup
and you've got most of your dinner made.
You can ask other members of your family to help out.
That's, I think, a really important part of making dinner more enjoyable is getting help,
whether it's with the grocery shopping or cooking part of it or cleaning up or setting the table.
Kids and
partners of course can participate in this.
We've done quite a bit of work with military families who tell us about doing dinner swaps
when their spouses are deployed and they're single parents. And what they do is they make
four times one meal and then they meet and they, and they come away from the swap with four
different meals that they can deploy for the rest of the week. So that's something else.
I love that idea so much because I feel like this happens when friends have new babies.
Like I've been involved in lots of these kind of, oh, someone's really busy, they have a
new baby, let's, you know, I just make an extra batch of my lasagna to give to them
and other families do the same thing. But we forget that we don't necessarily need a
newborn to be able to use a strategy like that. Like a bunch of families
can do that every single week and get multiple different interesting meals for like a bunch
of families. Yeah.
Absolutely. Or it could be done. I mean, you may be have to be a military family to be
that organized, but you could do it once a week with a friend or a neighbor. So I think
there, there's some sort of lower hanging fruit there.
This also strikes me as another spot where just kind of giving ourselves grace and maybe
not going for the most perfectionist meals possible can be helpful.
Like, I think sometimes we end up putting so much pressure on ourselves that we never
do the kind of thing that we want to do.
Whereas if we just agreed to do it, you know, 75%
awesome family dinners, we'd wind up doing it much more often than if we were trying
to do it perfectly.
Yes. And doing some shortcuts, you know, getting vegetables that have been pre-cut or a rotisserie
chicken, you know, not making a salad, but putting all the different accoutrements for
a salad out plus some tuna fish or some egg salad and asking family members to assemble their own.
And that can be done with tacos, with crepes. That's also a nice strategy for selective eaters
if you've got very different tastes in the families. It's a way to have people be able to
customize and choose what they want. But it's also kind of a quick dinner, like a charcuterie board
kind of dinner. And so those are all ways to kind of fight this barrier that cooking feels like it's too much work.
How about the barrier of technology, especially the fact that it's harder and harder for us to put our tech devices away,
even for just, you know, 20 minutes over the dinner table? What are some solutions there?
Yeah, I did a survey a few years ago and found that parents were twice as likely to use their gadgets at the dinner table.
So my first bit of advice is to ask the parents to kind of model the good behavior that they
want from their kids.
Some families have a very strict no technology policy.
Everybody put their phones in the middle of the table and anybody who goes to reach for
it has to do the dishes.
Then some families have a more flexible version of that. It might look like we can check our
gadgets if it's to check a detail that we're having a fight about, like who won the World
Series in 1984. Then some families say, well, I want to be able to share a picture I took or a
funny email I got.
And that seems to have a kind of a different spirit because it keeps the focus on connection
at the table.
So for those families, the rule is we can't use our phones to connect with people who
aren't there.
So no texting with others or taking phone calls.
But it's okay to share things that came up on your phone today, as long as it's to the rest of the table.
And then there's even some games that can incorporate technology,
like a hot potato selfie.
You set the timer and you pass it around,
and when the timer goes off, you take a selfie,
and then you set the timer and you pass it around
until everybody has taken a selfie,
and then you have a funny little collection of photos from that dinner.
It's time for a quick break, but we'll be back with more tips from Anne, including advice
on how to diffuse the dinner table disagreements that can mess up so many meals.
The Happiness Lab will be right back.
When I think of shared meals with friends and family, my mind usually goes to meal prep.
What ingredients do I need?
And when should I turn the oven on?
But Dr. Anne Fischel thinks we should actually put more thought into preparing the dinner
table conversation.
Games and prompts are a great way to do this.
It could be old favorites like 20 questions or would you rather, or a suggestion from
Anne's family dinner table project website, a game of guess the ingredients.
Just like a meal needs salt and pepper, it also needs playfulness and fun.
I think we all need more play in our lives, and games are a really great way to do it.
I play games in family therapy, often the same games that I play at the dinner table.
I don't love competitive games at the
dinner table, but games often lead to laughter. They often lead to conversation. Let's go
around the table and say a rose, something funny or positive that happened, a thorn,
something difficult or unpleasant, and a bud, something we hope will happen tomorrow. Or
let's tell two truths and a lie. You know, tell two stories about
something that happened this week and one thing that's just a bold-faced lie and others
will try to guess which is the made-up thing. So, ways to get kids to share more without
just asking them, how was your day? And then I think food itself has so many different
properties that we can play with. You know, It can be slippery, it can have different smells,
it has different colors,
and so we can play with color.
Ask our kids what meal could we make that's all red or all green,
or what's a rainbow meal?
That way we can eat our colors,
which itself is a very nutritious way to eat.
Or let's play with space,
let's switch seats because families often sit in
the same seats night after night or let's have a picnic or let's have a dinner in bed.
Food is to families like Legos or to elementary school kids as music is to adolescents.
It's the source of play.
It's one of the few things that we can do with our hands and
all our senses and we can make
something together. How rare is that in 21st century America that we can create something
together? And that to me is just really fun.
I think I'm channeling some busy parent friends of mine who have toddlers and little kids.
And as you're talking about playing with colors and playing with foods, I'm hearing in my
head what they might say, which is like, oh my gosh, it's going to be messy and I don't have time to clean up. Any advice for kind
of making games that avoid the like kind of cleanup worries too?
Yeah. I mean, I tend to have a really high tolerance for mess, which I mean, so here's
just a small example. To have small kids smear olive oil on vegetables that they get roasted
at a high temperature will pretty much ensure that those kids will eat those vegetables
because they've put their sticky little hands on it and then the vegetables come out pretty
crispy. Young kids tend not to like slimy foods. So yes, it's going to be messy. Your
kids are going to be covered, hopefully, just yes, it's going to be messy. Your kids are going
to be covered, hopefully just their hands in oil. But think about the trade-off. They're
going to eat something really delicious and healthy that you can eat too.
And partly they're learning how to cook too, right? You're also kind of weaving in a cooking
demonstration while they're doing it.
That's right. This could pay you back big time when they're a little bit older and maybe
we'll do a little
cooking for you.
We had a whole series of podcasts about parenting and parenting strategies.
One of the things we often heard is that anthropologists who study parents and other cultures often
find that they have kids getting more involved in things like cooking and cleaning and so
on.
I think in the US, we sometimes don't want our kids to do that because we think they
won't do it perfectly or they'll mess of mess it up. But then we lose these
really interesting opportunities for teaching our kids because we don't have them involved.
It seems like dinner time is yet another domain in which we could be doing this a little bit
more.
Absolutely. It reminds me of two parents, Eileen and Mary, who had a little four-year-old
boy. And one of the moms really did not like mess at all and didn't
really like the idea of playing with food and all of that. They would get their vegetables
from a co-op each week. One week, they got a squash. They opened it up, and the little
boy exclaimed, oh my goodness, it's so different inside compared to outside. That was this
amazing jumping off point for talking about all the
different ways you can't judge a book by its cover. Sort of an analogy, I think, for family
dinner that there are all kinds of surprises that lie around the table. So it can be the
launching pad for lots of interesting conversations, not just about the food.
I think this idea of sharing meals as an intimate experience gets to yet another barrier I see
coming up, not so much with families, but with maybe single folks or friends who want
to get together for meals, which is I think we're often worried about having people in
our personal space, right?
I think about even tonight having someone over for dinner and my head instantly goes
to like, oh my gosh, I didn't put that stuff away that's in the living room or the kitchen
is kind of a mess.
Any ways to give ourselves grace and just allow our people into these intimate spaces so we can
get the benefits of sharing meals even outside the family.
Yeah. I think one way is to invite a friend over when you haven't completed making the
dinner so that you're bringing them into the making of the dinner. Often, particularly
on a casual Wednesday night, a friend would
like to help. They'd like to help you cut up those last salad ingredients. I think that
creates more of a feeling of we're all in this together and this is a shared meal rather
than you're a guest coming into it.
I used to when I would have guests over and they say, what can we bring? I would say,
oh, no, no, no, no, don't bring anything. And then I realized that that was kind of selfish
and kind of controlling and kind of perfectionistic. If I could ask them to bring a course, they
already would feel more included. And I would also feel less burdened by having to make
a meal.
I think there's so many different ways to involve outsiders or friends. I think
of a military mother who wrote a book called Dinner with Smiley's and her husband was deployed
for a whole year. And every month they would invite somebody from their neighborhood or
community to come to dinner and sit in the father's chair. One week it was a coach, one
week it was the governor of Maine. I'm sure
they felt the pressure to clean up for those meals. But it added such an interesting variation
on their regular family dinner.
And then I think of a family I worked with, a single mom, who often felt like there wasn't
enough liveliness at the table because it was just one adult. And so her friends and her relatives knew
that every Wednesday night was an open dinner night, and they never knew who would drop by.
And she always made extra for that dinner. I've heard a similar suggestion where it's like,
you just have one night where it's like, Wednesday is the open night, and maybe you don't even make
extra dinner. It's like, as a friend, you can come over, but bring your own, like bring a leftover,
you can microwave it. Don't expect me to be perfect, right?
But this is a night where like doors open and you can show up.
It also reminds me of a suggestion that I got from the journalist Oliver Berkman, who
talks about all these things we can do to kind of manage our time with less perfectionism.
And he has this idea that he calls scruffy hospitality, which is kind of like you were
saying, like you invite people over, but it's like, you're going to have to do the dishes,
you're going to have to help me chop these vegetables,
the house is not going to be clean. And we just sort of accept that at the beginning
that like we're going to have some hospitality, we're going to have some shared meal time,
but it's going to be pretty scruffy.
Right. Yeah, like set the expectations where they should be.
And it seems like that's just a message for all of this work, right? There's so many benefits
if we could find more ways to share meals broadly, even beyond our family. But to do that, we really just have to set our expectations a little bit
less perfectionistically. Yes. One thing that we've been doing for, well, 15 years at the Family
Dinner Project is hosting big community dinners. And these are anywhere where families gather,
libraries, military bases, homeless shelters, clinics, teaching
kitchens. They're often groups of families who don't know each other, but who come to
know each other in a 90-minute dinner where we cook together, we eat together, we play
games, we have conversation jars on the tables, and people reach in and ask whimsical or silly
or serious things of one another.
And then I talk to the parents or the caregivers and say, what do you do well when it comes
to family dinner? And what are your obstacles? And now let's take some of those obstacles
and use the wisdom in this group to share our workarounds and hacks. That's really where
I've learned probably the most about how
families find ways to have dinner, even though it's really not that easy.
AMT – So another barrier lots of families face is that sometimes around the dinner table,
there's tension, you know, maybe big tension, we have, you know, political disagreements,
but even like little tension. I'm just like pissy at you, mom, for that thing you said to me.
Any strategies for diffusing that?
MS – Yeah. So I want to start with a piece of research on that,
which I conducted during the pandemic.
One of the only good things I can say about the pandemic
is that it gave a naturalistic opportunity
to study what happens when families have more dinner
with one another.
So something like 60%, 70% of families shared family dinners during the
pandemic. And what I found was that as frequency increased, the positive qualities of family dinner
also increased. So parents reported that they talked more about gratitude, they laughed more,
they talked about their identity as a family. They also shared more conversation
about the news and public events. They used Zoom to connect with friends and family. But
they also had more conflict and tension at the table.
And at first I was sort of upset by that finding. And then I thought, well, of course, if you're
spending more time with your family, but dinner is a canvas.
It's an opportunity to do what families do.
And one of the things they do is have conflict and fight.
And I will say that the positive qualities increased way more than the negative ones.
So first thing I would say is some conflict intention is to be expected.
And I know growing up, we had drag out fights about politics. I love
those fights, and I think my parents did too. So, you know, for some families, those kinds
of philosophical or political fights are really part of their identity as a family. But in
general, I think there are ways to minimize conflict. Probably not the best time to bring
up topics you know are hot button issues for your kids.
Maybe don't talk about that D they got in chemistry.
Maybe go easy on teaching table matters.
That makes everybody tense.
Just focus on the matters that matter,
that everybody can do better,
not interrupting each other or maybe not talking with a mouthful of food,
but who cares about the elbows on the table.
Other things that kind of
mitigate against conflict is having fun, playing games, having conversations that make us laugh
or think. And yes, there can be guidelines that are offered, like we have a rule at the dinner
table. Let's just remember that when one person is talking, other people don't talk over them or
interrupt. Gosh, this
is getting a little heated. Let's just step away for a moment and take a break. Or let's
do a quick breathing exercise and just calm down for a minute.
I thought about conflict a lot and often do at Thanksgiving, which is, of course, after
elections. And in 2016, I was worried about my own conflict at the Thanksgiving
table. And I came up with a game that I've now played every Thanksgiving that I call
the Hat Game. And as people come in, I have a hat and post-its at the table, and I have
a prompt, and I ask everybody to answer the prompt anonymously. So that first year, it
was, what character
in a children's book did you most identify or do you most identify with or want to be?
Or what toy did you most love as a child or love now as a child? And people would answer
them and then I brought the hat to the table and pulled out the post-its and each person
tried to guess which person went with which answer,
and then that person could expound if they wanted. But it meant that for like 10 or 15
minutes, we had a lighthearted, interesting, conflict-free conversation.
Thanks to Dr. Anne Fischel and Jan-Emmanuel Deneve for walking us through the importance
of sharing meal time with other people. In the next episode, we'll examine another topic raised by the report.
Are we becoming less trusting?
And what does that mean for our well-being?
All that next time on the Happiness Lab with me, Dr. Lorie Santos.