The Misery Machine - The Case of Aniya Day Garrett

Episode Date: April 3, 2025

This week, Drewby and Yergy head to Euclid, Ohio, to discuss the case of 4-year-old Aniya Day Garrett, whose cries for help fell on deaf ears. Nobody... Not teachers, not police, not even CPS took this little girl’s cries for help seriously. Even after she reached out to her father for help, the powers that be didn't take him seriously either. In the end, she fell victim to one of the most common monsters we see here on The Misery Machine... Mom, and her new man.  Support Our Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/themiserymachine PayPal: https://www.paypal.me/themiserymachine Join Our Facebook Group: https://t.co/DeSZIIMgXs?amp=1 Instagram: miserymachinepodcast Twitter: misery_podcast Discord: https://discord.gg/kCCzjZM #themiserymachine #podcast #truecrime Source Material: Obituary | Aniya Marie Day-Garrett | Strowder's Funeral Home Disciplinary letters show failures by children services in death of Aniya Day-Garrett | Fox 8 Cleveland WJW State shuts down daycare accused of failing to report abuse of Aniya Day UPDATE: Mickhal Garrett awarded $3M after filing suit that claimed inaction by Cuyahoga County Children and Family Services contributed to Aniya Day-Garrett’s murder Cuyahoga County Settles For $3 Million In Aniya Day-Garrett's Death Euclid day care attended by Aniya Day-Garrett will shut down in March | wkyc.com Daycare owner who failed to report abuse of Aniya Day-Garrett before her murder must pay $15 million to father, appeals court rules - cleveland.com Mother and her boyfriend sentenced to life in prison for killing 4-year-old Aniya Day-Garrett Ohio Supreme Court declines to hear case of mother's boyfriend convicted in murder of Euclid's Aniya Day-Garrett From murder to verdict: Timeline of events leading to murder of Aniya Day-Garrett Jury finds mother, her boyfriend guilty in 4-year-old Aniya Day-Garrett’s murder | wkyc.com Mother, boyfriend guilty on all charges for death of 4-year-old Aniya Day-Garrett Mom, boyfriend get life in prison in death of abused and emaciated 4-year-old 'Some justice has been served' | Mother, boyfriend sentenced in murder of 4-year-old girl

Imagine your child tells you that your ex-spouse is hurting them. And the court system due to a false accusation against you not only prevents you from seeking help for your child, but barring you from seeing them entirely. You have to sit at home helpless in saving your child's life. Now, does this sound like a made-up scenario to you? Well, this is exactly what happened in today's story. And nobody, not teachers, not police, not even CPS, took this little girl's cries for help seriously. We always hear people say that the worst thing about a child victim is that they can't properly tell anyone what's going on.

But the sad reality is that even when they speak up, too many times those that are mandated to care about the life of a child for whatever reason turn them away. Anaya Marie Day Garrett was born on September 2nd, 2013 in Euclid, Ohio to parent Sierra Day and Michael Garrett. her parents never married and separated before Anaya turned two. In turn, Sierra gained full custody of Anaya while Michael did everything he could to remain part of her life. Growing up, Anaya was described as energetic and outgoing. She loved to sing and dance, bringing laughter to everyone who watched her. Her favorite color was pink. But behind her happiness lay a fractured family dynamic that would set the stage for the challenges she'd face.

As Anaya grew older, cracks began to form in her once sparkling world. By 2016, concerns relating to her physical well-being started to surface. During his visitation time with his daughter, Michael noticed injuries that Sierra often downplayed or dismissed entirely. For example, he recalled instances where Anaya had visible bruises on her chest and back. Sierra explained these injuries away as accidents or minor mishaps, but Michael grew increasingly uneasy. For long, arguments between the two parents were, reached an all-time high, ultimately prompting Sierra to file a restraining order against her ex. Court order alleged that Michael was harassing Sierra an overstepping in his limited role as a

parent. While Michael fought very hard to gain full custody, he was effectively barred from contacting Sierra directly or visiting Anaya without a neutral third party present, such as a social worker or a designated court monitor. Sierra started isolating herself and refused to allow her children to visit with any of their loved ones. Rather than accept help from Anaya's father or extended family, Sierra chose to enroll her daughter in daycare. Shortly after her arrival at the Harbor Crest Daycare in Euclid, workers began documenting new injuries observed in Naya's body that seemed to appear daily. Abrasions, burns, and even black eyes were ultimately detailed in a total of 18 observation reports filed by staff, which were in turn filed to their supervisors.

In one of the reports, a daycare worker noted that Sierra frequently dismissed the concerns for her child, claiming that Anaya was a liar. In May of 2017, Anaya arrived at daycare with bumps on her head and a scrape on her face. That day, she informed a caretaker, and I quote, Mommy pushed me down the steps. Sierra assured the caretaker that her daughter had simply fallen at a park. Days later, Anaya showed up at daycare, this time complaining that she had, had a headache. Upon examination, blisters were found on her scalp and dried blood inside of her

ear. Sierra insisted that this was just an allergic reaction to a Johnson & Johnson baby wash that she'd been using. In the same breath, she proceeded to change her story, claiming that these particular injuries may have been caused by Anaya's braid that had been wound too tight. When Anaya was pulled aside, her story was much different than her mother's, insisting that, and I quote, Mommy hit me. Mommy hurt me. As a result, the owner of the daycare facility notified the police and Anaya was transported to the hospital for physical evaluation. Despite the multiple reports in medical treatment, Anaya was subsequently released back to her mother. Concerns for the little girl only grew when Sierra began dating a man named Deontay Lewis in July of 2017.

While Deonté had no previous criminal record, a 26-year-old who worked as a little bit of local security guard was the furthest thing from a protector, was incapable of keeping anyone safe, let alone Anaya. Family members described Deonti as controlling, and when he entered the picture, the family dynamic took a turn for the worse. While the child's biological father had been made aware of the reports, he also witnessed the violence firsthand. During a visit to the home in September of 2017, Michael discovered bruises on Anaya's chest and back.

On a separate occasion, Michael took notice of a rodent. tooth and I had been suffering with that had gone untreated. Michael subsequently photographed these injuries and filed his own report with the Cleveland police. It's by Michael's multiple petitions to the courts, expressing fears for his daughter's safety. Law enforcement failed to take appropriate action, allowing the violence to continue unchecked. A few months later in December of 2017, the Cuyahoga County Department of Children and Family Services received an emergency referral regarding allegations of violence and neglect involving Anaya. When a social worker visited Sierra's apartment,

she observed more bruises and burns on Anaya's body, but for some reason, deemed the child's living conditions as up to par after confirming functional utilities, food supplies, and requirements of basic necessities had been met. While law enforcement assured Anaya's father they were looking into the matter, the investigation did not escalate any further.

Surely recognizing that she was under the distorted microscope of law enforcement, Sierra Day made the decision to transfer Anaya from Harbor Crest to a new daycare, one where she herself was employed. This was a preschool in Euclid called Get Ready, Set, Throw. By the time Anaya arrived at her new preschool, things had gotten much worse. Staff noticed that she appeared malnourished, sickly, and emotionally withdrawn. When confronted by her co-workers' concerns, that her daughter's weight was low, Sierra assured them that she was fine and had always been

just a skinny child. Despite Anaya's condition that was worsening by the day, Sierra's mere presence as a teacher at Get Ready Set Grow, facilitated an environment where she was able to better disguise the violence. Naya's transition out of Harbor Crest and into her mother's workplace, essentially shielded caregivers from properly documenting her daughter's injuries, became a place where supervision was even more minimal. That fact was ultimately, proven in January of 2018. Cleveland PD's investigation into Sierra Day was closed altogether. The case against her was somehow deemed unsubstantiated.

Despite hospital visits, photographic evidence, witness accounts, and even statements from Anaya herself, the four-year-old was allowed to remain in a dangerous environment. Behind the closed doors at her mother's apartment, what happened over the next few weeks when ignored until it was far too late. The social worker who had visited the home had scheduled a father. follow-up meeting for March 9th, 2018, but Sierra postponed it to March 12th, and tragically for Anaya that day never came. On March 11th, 2018, Deonté Lewis called 911 to report that Anaya had fallen from the toilet and was having trouble breathing. After nearly four minutes, Sierra took the phone,

informing the operator that she had put her hand to Anaya's nose and that there was no air coming out. When the dispatcher ordered Sierra to administer CPR, there was no indication that either of the two adults followed her instructions. The dispatcher also noted how both Deonti and Sierra remained abnormally calm for the duration of the call. When paramedics arrived, they immediately noticed the heavy stench of bleach. In addition, Anaya's mattress had been stripped of its bedding aside from one small fleece blanket and smelled strongly of your. urine. Police also found court papers regarding Michael Garrett's custody battle torn up and thrown in the trash. Authorities also notice a scarcity of food in the home, aside from two half-eaten Chipotle bowls discovered in the microwave. But the worst discovery is when four-year-old

Anaya was found, dressed in winter clothing, lying on the floor underneath an air conditioner. It was a cold day in March and the presence of a running air conditioner struck the first responders as bizarre. It appeared evident that Sierra and Deonté had tried to disguise the smell of human decay by keeping the child's body cool. In addition, Anaya was found nowhere near the toilet Deonté and Sierra initially reported her falling from. Rigormortus had already set in, indicating that she had been dead for several hours. Her lips were cracked and her face was pale, showing clear signs of prolonged neglect. She was severely amazed. She was severely amazed. with her small body resembling that of a skeleton with her vertebrae and hip bones protruding from her small winter coat.

Anaya's face also bore a deep, dark bruise that had caused one eye to swell shut. A laceration above the same eye was also visible. Additional bruises, cuts, and burns were witnessed across her entire body, along with areas of her skin that had begun to droop and fall from her tiny frame due to severe loss of fat and muscle tissue. Anaya's knees and lower leg showed signs of bed sores as well, indicated that she been confined to one position for extended periods. When questioned by police at home, the couple claimed that Anaya had fallen off the toilet that morning

and hit her head, rendering her unconscious. Sierra also noted that Anaya hadn't eaten since the previous Thursday, roughly four days before, after becoming ill from a meal at a local red lobster. However, what Sierra's brother later told police suggested that Anaya had gone without food for much longer. In February of 2018, Sierra's brother, Isaiah Day, visited the apartment only to find Anaya lying immobile on a bed. When he asked if she was okay, Sierra casually replied, yeah, completely dismissing her daughter's alarming condition. She went on to nonchalantly explain to her brother that Anaya hadn't been any.

much, a vast understatement given the fact that Anaya had allegedly already lost all function of her legs. Despite a clear sense of urgency, Isaiah failed to notify the police and only revealed this information when he was questioned following Anaya's death. Investigators also learned that on February 21st, Sierra contacted local authorities, not regarding her daughter, but to report her laptop stolen. When deputies arrived at the home, Deonté answered the door. Police never went inside, but had they, a starving Anaya more than likely would have been found. Following these grim discoveries, Sierra and Deonté were both arrested. During her interrogation, Sierra admitted that Anaya began showing flu-like symptoms on March 8th and had been vomiting all day after the meal

at Red Lobster. She went on to say that she and Deontay tried feeding her multiple items. including soup and Tylenol, but her symptoms persisted. Despite not being able to keep down a sip of ginger ale, Sierra confessed that she believed Anaya was faking an illness, even going as far as to say that her daughter, and I quote, scared herself to the point of causing her own death. After giving her daughter a bath, Sierra told detectives that Anaya said she was sleepy.

Hours later, Sierra finally decided to call a 24-hour health hotline but never once sought medical attention for her daughter who was slowly dying inside her apartment. Throughout her interrogation, Sierra attempted to blame Deonté for her child's death, claiming he was responsible for feeding the child, not her, and contested the medical care Anaya desperately needed. Sierra also alleged that Deonti had beaten Anaya on several occasions

and was known to use a belt during these instances. Following their respective police interviews, Sierra and Deontay were charged with murder, aggravated murder, baloneyous assault, permitting CA, endangering children, and tampering with evidence. Upon recovering CCTV footage from local businesses in the area, surveillance footage showed that that night before Anaya's death, Sierra and Deontay were seen dining at a Chipotle restaurant

where they proceeded to enjoy burrito bowls together. Later, the two were seen shopping at a nearby Walmart, with her four-year-old daughter lay gravely ill at home. They were later witnessed purchasing snacks and other household items, including cleaning supplies while Anaya lay dying. An autopsy later performed by Cuyahoga County Chief Deputy Medical Examiner Dr. Joseph Fellow confirmed the harrowing details surrounding Anaya's death. The examination pointed toward evidence of prolonged neglect in severe injuries spanning weeks. It was determined that Anaya wages 26 pounds at the time of her death, placing her in the third percentile for her age. The medical examiner was also able to determine that the Breaweigh was also able to determine that the

bruise on the right side of Anaya's forehead was approximately one week old, and that the black eye had been sustained roughly two days before her death. Patikia was also found around her eyes, further evidence of her prolonged suffering before death. The autopsy also revealed a cerebral infarction caused by a subdural hematoma, consistent with blunt force trauma to the head. This hematoma had developed over weeks, leading to extensive brain damage and a stroke that affected the left side of her brain, which controls the right side of the body. This trauma resulted in paralysis, impaired speech, and a decline in motor function. Dr. Fellow also documented signs of starvation, noting that Anaya's body had begun to consume itself.

Her stomach lining showed ulcers from prolonged acid exposure due to a lack of food. Her pancreas was inflamed, and her lungs exhibited signs of collapse. The cumulative findings led Dr. Fellow to rule her cause of death as cerebral infarction due to blunt impacts to the head, with malnutrition as a significant contributing factor. Her manner of death was immediately classified as homicide. Upon analyzing the suspect's cell phones, authorities recovered a sex tape of Sierra and Deontay that was recorded at 3.28 p.m. on March 10, 2018. the day before Anaya's death. This was just one more disturbing detail, knowing that the four-year-old

was nearing her final moments, lying hopelessly in the other room. Justice for Anaya would finally come at trial when opening arguments began on February 28, 2019. The proceedings exposed the undeniable depth of the cruelty the little girl had endured, long before she was left to die inside her mother's apartment. During the trial, the defense attempted to suggest,

that Anaya's injuries were either accidental or caused by external factors. However, their explanations were contradicted by the overwhelming medical evidence and a total of 37 testimonies from witnesses, including daycare workers, first responders, social workers, family members, and more. The paramedics on scene that fateful day took the stand, recounting Anaya's emaciated state to the jury. Additionally, the surveillance footage of Sierra and Deontay, casually eating at local restaurants and shopping for bleach at Walmart were also presented in court. Those present in the courtroom noted that Sierra showed little emotion throughout the entirety of the trial, even when the graphic photos of Anaya's body were shown in the projector screen.

This lack of visible remorse was cited by prosecutors as further evidence of both hers and her co-defendants' callousness. One of the most impactful moments at trial was the emotional testimony of Anaya's biological father, Michael Garrett. Michael graciously described, his love for his daughter and his relentless but fruitless efforts to protect her. Michael also spoke about the last time he saw his daughter alive. During a supervised visit, he noticed how frail and withdrawn she was. Stark contrast to the bright and energetic little girl that he knew. He testified that Anaya's demeanor had changed drastically in her mother's custody and even more so when Deonté came into her life. On the stand, Michael expressed his frustration with the

state, the system solely responsible for protecting children, as well as the unwarranted restraining order Sierra had filed against him, which legally limited access to Anaya during a critical period where her life was clearly in danger. In the end, both Sierra Day and Deonté Lewis were convicted on all charges. During sentencing, the judge described the actions of both defendants as inhumane and unfathomable, emphasizing that Anaya's death was entirely preventable. As a result of the court proceedings, 24-year-old Sierra Day received a life sentence without the possibility of parole, while 27-year-old Deonté Lewis was sentenced to life with the possibility

of parole after 20 years. Anaya's death forced the state of Ohio to confront its own negligence, and outrage turned to action as community members called for reform. Michael Garrett filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the Cuyahoga County Department of Children and Family Services, which alleged gross negligence and failure to protect Anaya despite repeated reports of violence and neglect. It detailed breakdowns in the system that allowed Anaya to remain in not one, but two state-regulated child care facilities. While the lawsuit sought financial compensation, more importantly, it aimed to bring attention to the urgent need for reform within CPS.

Michael's legal team argued that had the state followed through on its duty to investigate and intervene, Anaya would still be alive today. CPS failed me. They failed us all. As a result of an external investigation, the internal disciplinary letters and failed investigative efforts by local law enforcement came into focus,

highlighting the gross lapses and oversight and protocol. The letters specifically drew attention to the blatant ignorance of Anaya's caseworkers who repeatedly failed to follow up on allegations of violence, perform thorough investigations or document key findings in compliance with agency policies. Among the findings were the multiple reports from Harbor Crest Daycare detailing visible injuries on Anaya that were dismissed without proper investigation. The little to no collaboration between caseworkers and other professionals, such as police,

medical personnel, and daycare staff to verify the consistency of the allegations, and finally, that supervisors failed to ensure their teams adhere to protocols for handling suspected CA cases. This failure ultimately cost Anaya her life. At the end of the investigation into the agency, multiple employees were disciplined while others were terminated. As a result, CPS was forced to implement significant policy changes aimed at preventing similar tragedies involving children in the future. Additionally, the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services took significant action against the two daycare centers connected to Anaya's death, causing both Harbor Crest child care and get ready, set grow preschool, to close their doors indefinitely.

As for Anaya's father, Michael Garrett, was awarded a total of $3 million in damages in June of 2020, a decision that underscored the state's accountability and failure to protect four-year-old Anaya date Garrett. Anaya's life was commemorated with a deeply emotional farewell

spanning two days. On Friday, March 16, 2018, a viewing was held from noon until 7 p.m., allowing loved ones and members of the community to pay their respects. Her father, Michael Garrett, tearfully reflected on her joy and innocence, describing her as a light in this world

whose story must never be forgotten. The following day on Saturday, March 17th, Anaya's funeral took place at River of Life Ministries in Euclid, Ohio. Attendees watched as her tiny pink casket, adorned with a tiara, traveled through the streets of Euclid in a horse-drawn carriage.

It was both a celebration of her short life and a heartbreaking reminder of her tragic death. Her funeral not only honored her memory, but also served as a call for accountability to protect other children. Deonté Lewis later appealed his conviction in life sentence, arguing that his trial was unfair and that the evidence presented did not support the jury's findings.

However, in 2022, the Ohio Court of Appeals denied his appeal and both his conviction and sentence were upheld. It is beyond heart-wrenching to reflect on how Anaya Day Garrett, at only four years old, found the courage to speak up for herself repeatedly, bravely telling the adults in her life that she was in danger. From daycare workers to her father, she voiced the harm she experienced at home, pointing to her injuries and outwardly naming the source of her pain. Tragically, those cries for help were overlooked, ignored, were dismissed entirely. The system set in place to protect her simply failed her. Often people highlight this one tragic fact involving child victims at the hands of their parents. That is that a child often cannot advocate for themselves or properly seek help.

However, Anaya did everything in her power to advocate for herself. She knew she was in danger. She knew what her mother and her mother's boyfriend was doing to her was wrong. But as we've seen so many times, even when a child does try to seek help, many people do not take it seriously, especially those whose responsibility is to protect children in need. By the time anybody listened, it was too late, and the vibrant little girl who had fought so hard to be heard

was left silence forever. Anaya's story stands as a devastating reminder of the cost of inaction by the powers that be. Through the tireless efforts of her father and community advocates, Anaya's story continues to inspire change, a testament of hope that no child will ever suffer in silence again. However, if we've learned anything from the cases we cover, the likelihood of a similar history repeating,

itself is not only higher than any of us would care to admit, it is sadly inevitable.