The Misery Machine - The Case of Eduardo Posso

Episode Date: July 18, 2024

This week, Drewby and Yergy follow a circus performer family across the United States and discuss the tragic case of Eduardo Posso, and adorable little boy who just wanted to juggle and be free. After... essentially being kidnapped by his father and stepmother, Eduardo was taken across the country and made into the family scapegoat, with some of his siblings considering him to be "not part of the family." In the end, Eduardo died from malnourishment and dehydration, and had lost 50% of his body weight. Only hair was present in his stomach at autopsy. He was also beaten with a metal bat, shocked with an electronic collar, shot with a staple gun, and chained up in the bathroom.  Support Our Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/themiserymachine PayPal: https://www.paypal.me/themiserymachine Join Our Facebook Group: https://t.co/DeSZIIMgXs?amp=1 Instagram: miserymachinepodcast Twitter: misery_podcast Discord: https://discord.gg/kCCzjZM #themiserymachine #podcast #truecrime Source Material: https://thefuneralchapel.net/book-of-memories/3860815/Posso-Eduardo/obit.php?&printable=true https://fox59.com/news/mother-of-boy-shackled-starved-in-monroe-county-said-she-knew-something-was-wrong-no-one-will-listen/ https://eu.heraldtimesonline.com/story/news/crime/2019/07/25/life-without-parole-sought-for-dad-stepmom-in-starving-death-of-12-year-old/46644245/  https://www.fox13news.com/news/mourners-dont-let-abused-boys-death-be-in-vain.amp  https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/in-court-of-appeals/2153597.html https://fox59.com/news/mother-of-boy-shackled-starved-in-monroe-county-said-she-knew-something-was-wrong-no-one-will-listen/amp/ https://www.wfla.com/news/local-news/manatee-county/could-eduardo-possos-horrific-death-have-been-prevented/amp/  https://www.wtsp.com/video/news/crime/vigil-held-for-12-year-old-boy-restrained-with-shackles-and-a-dog-collar-in-motel-bathroom-before-he-died/67-775fa579-1b47-4740-a92c-c4c5387282d0  https://public.courts.in.gov/Decisions/api/Document/Opinion?Id=U5DaNqVzIKHgjelhjlyoqfi5Z8DGe5MAWOEzhuAYuRKIcdLT8_PAVo43RnHM6q2Q0  https://amp.bradenton.com/news/local/crime/article230991853.html https://casetext.com/case/posso-v-state-2/ https://fb.watch/sUY3Q7sar2/?mibextid=KsPBc6 - WTHR interview  https://thefuneralchapel.net/book-of-memories/3860815/Posso-Eduardo/  https://www.wtsp.com/video/news/crime/vigil-held-for-12-year-old-boy-restrained-with-shackles-and-a-dog-collar-in-motel-bathroom-before-he-died/67-775fa579-1b47-4740-a92c-c4c5387282d0  https://www.nationalchildrensalliance.org/media-room/national-statistics-on-child-abuse/  https://www.nationalchildrensalliance.org/media-room/national-statistics-on-child-abuse/#:~:text=Child%20abuse%20is%20deadly.,compared%20to%20girls%20at%202.15  https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/juliareinstein/circus-parents-indiana-chain-son-selfie-starved  https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7087223/amp/Boy-died-evil-parents-tied-bathtub-tortured-electric-shock-collar.html  https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1011851  https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_executed_in_Indiana#:~:text=A%20total%20of%2020%20people,with%20lethal%20injection%20in%201995  https://www.gofundme.com/f/eduardo-luis  https://cbs4indy.com/news/florida-investigators-say-they-found-no-signs-of-abuse-months-before-12-year-old-died-in-indiana/amp/ https://eu.heraldtimesonline.com/story/news/crime/2022/10/07/judge-gives-man-65-years-in-starvation-death-of-12-year-old-son/69545042007/  https://fox59.com/indiana-news/father-pleads-guilty-to-murder-in-sons-beating-starvation-death-in-monroe-county/amp/  https://fox59.com/news/florida-investigators-say-they-found-no-signs-of-abuse-months-before-12-year-old-died-in-indiana/amp/  https://indianapublicmedia.org/news/posso-sentenced-to-65-years-after-pleading-guilty-to-murder-of-12-year-old-son-in-2019.php https://public.courts.in.gov/Decisions/api/Document/Opinion?Id=zwXyVGcWCaCNoKD5x7RXSU_cS4qf78ZgGdkOD9uu4s0lMYQ2iX8CUziLyecymlE50  https://eu.heraldtimesonline.com/story/news/crime/2022/10/07/judge-gives-man-65-years-in-starvation-death-of-12-year-old-son/69545042007/#:~:text=Posso%2C%2035%2C%20has%20been%20incarcerated,Walnut%20Street%20when%20Eduardo%20died  https://www.mysuncoast.com/2019/05/30/manatee-county-sheriffs-office-releases-child-abuse-investigation-involving-year-old-boy-who-later-died-extreme-abuse/?outputType=amp  https://www.wbiw.com/2022/07/21/indiana-court-of-appeals-denied-a-woman-a-lighter-sentence-for-the-murder-of-her-stepson/  https://public.courts.in.gov/Decisions/api/Document/Opinion?Id=pKCMQe-7smEffEpjXuqG0Eg9lREUFXv6lskxYtW-fO9O6WgE4pOm5SsR2vX2Ttc00  https://eu.tmnews.com/story/news/2019/05/31/details-emerge-in-12-year-olds-starvation-death/117328246/  https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2019/06/04/us/boy-starved-to-death  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzbYi7mn0z0 https://www.facebook.com/profile/100063561125871/search/?q=posso

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Eduardo Luis Poso was born on November 28, 2006 in the small Floridian city of Arcadia. Right from the start, he had a beautiful, contagious smile and was sweet and loving towards everyone. Some of Eduardo's favorite pastimes were playing video games, banging on his drum set, and jumping on the trampoline. He also loved horses, motorcycles, dogs, cooking scrambled eggs, fishing and visiting the shoe store with his uncle. Eduardo's mother was Area Esmeralda Garcia, and she was born in September of 1983. Eduardo was her first child, and in January of 2010, she gave birth to his younger sister, Roxana. At the time of our story, Eduardo was a very kind, helpful 12-year-old boy who gave the warmest hugs. Luis Eduardo Poso Jr. was born on December 23, 1986.
Starting point is 00:00:57 He was 20 years old when his first child, Eduardo was born. Luis and Ereya tied the knot in the 2000s, but their marriage did not last long. November of 2015, Luis started dating Deanna Medina Flores, who was born in 1998 and had one son born in 2014 from a previous marriage. The pair became engaged by New Year's Eve, even though Luis was still married to Ereya. The two finalized their divorce in early 2016, and Luis married Deana in April of that same year. After their parents divorced, Eduardo and his sister, Roxana, lived with their mom and dad equally. However, one day, Luis picked the kids up and never brought them home. When Eduardo said goodbye to his mom that day,
Starting point is 00:01:35 she promised him that she was not going to let Luis take him away permanently. The two-pinkies swore that if he did, she would come after him and bring him home. Orrea took Luis to court in a lengthy custody battle. He ended up getting full custody of Eduardo and Roxana because Arrea had failed to attend a custody hearing. Eduardo and Roxana lived with their father, stepmother, five-year-old stepbrother, an infant half-sibling in rural Miyaka City, Florida. Diana loved her biological children, but did not like either of her stepchildren and considered them to be a burden. In text messages, she referred to them as her number one problem and described herself as just a maid that has to abide by being with a brood of kids that aren't mine. She also sent a text message, most likely about Eduardo, which said, he's the one who has to give in, an attitude and behavior.
Starting point is 00:02:26 The Poso family lived in an apartment unit directly behind a Dakin Dairy farm. The apartment was only supposed to be rented out to farm workers without children, and the owner, Jerry Dakin, is still unsure how the posos were allowed to rent the property in the first place when four kids lived there and neither Louise nor Deanna worked at the farm. Eduardo and his sister attended Mayaka City Elementary School. Until the summer of 2018, they attended an after-school club at the Magiore. Yacca City Community Center. A child care provider there, Jessica Nelson, expressed how Eduardo was extremely popular and just a great all-around kid who would help anybody in need. She also remembered that his parents seemed like nice, down-to-earth hardworking people.
Starting point is 00:03:14 However, the couple's neighbor named Karen Graham remembers them as the neighbors from hell. Luis would keep everyone awake at night screaming at his wife and kids in Spanish. The couple also left trash lying out, causing vermin problems in the neighborhood. They were too lazy to clean the garbage themselves, so they forced Eduardo to do it. Karen complained to her about it, and he went next door and started yelling at Luis for forcing his young son to pick up garbage instead of doing it himself. She also said she saw Eduardo eating some of the trash that he was picking up. Karen also noted how Eduardo ran around wearing taped shoes. She felt sorry for the boy, and Karen asked for him.
Starting point is 00:03:54 his shoe size and offered to buy him a new pair. However, the very next day his parents bought him a brand new pair. Karen and her husband would also try to sneak candy in bags of toys for Eduardo because he only had some juggling balls to play with. He was a talented juggler and would spend hours and hours in the driveway trying to impress his father who didn't care at all. The only time Karen saw Eduardo and Luis interact was when he was forcing him to move the heavy circus performing equipment on the porch and sweep the area. For a long time, Karen believed Eduardo was an only child because the other three children rarely left the house.
Starting point is 00:04:30 One day, her husband caught sight of Roxana as she went outside to fetch clothing from the washing line. He waved at her and Luis later warned him to never interact with his daughters or even glance in their direction. Karen and her husband hardly ever spoke to Eduardo, who seemed afraid most of the time and was even scared to pet the couple's dog without getting permission from his parents first. Despite this, Karen felt he considered them his friends, as he would smile whenever he saw them. After her kids moved away, Aerea tried to keep in contact with them.
Starting point is 00:05:01 But when she called, Louise always made excuses or flat out said the kids didn't want to speak with her. According to Aurea, her ex-husband also lied about her not paying child support and through any birthday and Christmas gifts she sent her kids in the trash. Area started to fear her children were being mistreated and made a report to the Florida Department, of children and families, but they never followed up on her concerns. She knew that Luis was a strict disciplinarian who believed in harsh punishment and felt in the back of her mind that something wasn't right. As many as five child neglect reports were made to the Manatee County Sheriff's Office
Starting point is 00:05:37 between March of 2017 and November of 2018, all from different sources. The first report in March of 2017 came from Mirea, but when an investigation was launched, no evidence of neglect was ever found. Six months later in September of 2017, Eduardo's grandmother, Dolores Poso, reported that her grandson had been hit several times on his head. Investigators went to the family's apartment and interviewed everyone in the home, including Eduardo. It all stated he had accidentally hit his cheek on his knee while he was trying to do a flip on the trampoline. Investigators decided that the accusations were unfounded and that no crime had taken place. Two additional reports were made in November of 2017 and February of 20th.
Starting point is 00:06:19 2018 from anonymous sources. The last report was filed in November of 2018 by Eduardo's school district who said their student had a bruise on his face. When investigators interviewed Luis and Deana, they claimed Eduardo was learning to juggle and one of the balls had hit him in the face. The report was closed and the documents concluded, and I quote, this is a circus performer family. Investigation shows the child obtained the bruise during juggling practice. Case is unfounded. On December 3rd, 2018, investigators visited Eduardo at home one last time. They questioned him about his home life and the relationship he had with his father and stepmother. He denied ever being mistreated and investigators noted he seemed happy and healthy.
Starting point is 00:10:10 They even took a photo of him smiling for the camera and looked happy but noticeably thinner. Two days later, Luis pulled Eduardo and Roxana out of Mayaka City Elementary School, telling the school district he would be homeschooling them from now on. The family then moved out of state without telling Orea, who hadn't seen her children since Thanksgiving of 2017. She remembers that day vividly as her son looked a lot thinner than before. When she asked why he had lost so much weight, he explained that he had only been eating cereal for dinner
Starting point is 00:10:43 after his school raised concerns about his weight. Area also noticed that Eduardo was unusually quiet and seemed afraid of talking. Now, Karen Graham, who was the Poso's Miyaka city neighbor, remember seeing Luis and Diana carrying leather restraints to the back of their card the day of the move. Diana was also selling the family's refrigerator and giving away all the food in the home, which Karen thought was strange. She got a glimpse inside their apartment and recalled how they had a big white cupboard in the kitchen with a lock on it. She thought that was very strange, but didn't think anything of it at the time.
Starting point is 00:11:19 Before the family moved away, Karen sat down with Eduardo and they had a private conversation. She remembers telling him that he could be anything he wanted to be in life and encouraged him to try hard at school so he could one day escape his current situation. For at least one month, the Poso family traveled from motel to motel in Monroe County, Indiana, earning money by distributing flyers for an advertising company contracted by the traveling circus, Circa Italia's big top gold water circus. The circus was to perform eight shows in Bloomington's college mall parking lot in June of 2019. Although it was Luis and Deana's job to distribute the flyers, they forced their kids into helping them. However, Eduardo was never spotted handing out the flyers, which seemed unusual considering that Luis had a history of forcing his son to work. While the rest of the family were working, Eduardo was kept shackled in the hotel bathtub with Luis monitoring him on a webcam to ensure he did not escape. Luis and Dayana chained Eduardo in the bathroom every single day and every single night.
Starting point is 00:12:23 In addition to forcing Eduardo to live out his days in the cold, hard bathtub, Luis added to the cruelty by chaining Eduardo's ankles and fastening the chain to the shower handrail. This meant his ankles were constantly elevated. He couldn't even stand. Luis also deprived Eduardo of food and water and shocked him with an electronic dog training collar almost every day. When Eduardo was given food, it was only spoiled leftovers or one half of a sandwich. It was also forced to eat cat food and a dog bone at one point. While Eduardo was being treated worse than an animal, the rest of the family ate McDonald's and Chick-fil-A and slept in comfortable beds. On top of confining, starving, and neglecting Eduardo,
Starting point is 00:13:07 Luis and Dayana savagely beat him in various ways. He was beat with a metal bat regularly, and a broken toothbrush was once forced down his threat. sometimes Luis would even take a staple gun and shoot staples into Eduardo's feet. Eduardo was also emotionally neglected, and they turned him into the family scapegoat. The other children did not acknowledge his existence most of the time, and his five-year-old stepbrother drew a family portrait without Eduardo in it because he was bad and not part of the family.
Starting point is 00:13:40 As June of 2019 was approaching, the neglect reached its peak. On May 20th, the family checked into the economy inn on Bloomington's south side in Monroe County. It would be the last hotel Eduardo would ever stay at. Every day and night, he lay shackled in the bathroom, dreaming of running away with the circus. One of the last things Eduardo said to his sister was he just wanted to juggle and be free. On May 23rd, Luis and Diana punched, slapped, and kicked Eduardo while the other children listened from the next. next room. After the beating, they stripped him naked and left him whimpering when the cold water from the shower pouring down on him. Later that day, Eduardo became incoherent and was too weak to feed
Starting point is 00:14:27 himself. Luis and Deanna tried to heal him with insuringpedeolites. They also gave him protein bars, and when he didn't eat them, they hit him again. In the early hours of Friday, May 24th, Diana went back into the bathroom and found her shackled stepson not moving and he was cold to the touch. At 2.52 a.m., Luis gone to his van and drove Eduardo to the IU Health Bloomington Hospital in Bloomington, Indiana. Eduardo was completely unresponsive and not breathing and he didn't have a pulse. Luis rushed Eduardo to the emergency room, saying his son had choked in his sleep. Staff noted how Luis's shirt was stained with vomit. A doctor made several resuscitation attempts, sadly, Eduardo was pronounced dead at 305 a.m.
Starting point is 00:15:14 Just 13 minutes after arriving at the hospital. Eduardo's autopsy was performed by Monroe County Coroner Joni Shields. The report noted he was severely malnourished and severely dehydrated at the time of his death. He had lost 40 to 50% of his body weight and had a body mass index less than the third percentile of children his age. The fat under Eduardo's skin had been depleted and his eyes were sunk into their sockets, its ribs and bones were protruding outward. Eduardo's organs also showed signs of shrinkage,
Starting point is 00:15:46 suggesting that his body had cannibalized itself out of starvation. When the coroner opened his stomach, all she could find was hair inside. The autopsy further revealed that Eduardo had severe blunt force injuries all over his body. These included bruises, scrapes, and lacerations on his head, neck, back, chest, shoulders, arms, and legs. The coroner wrote that the injuries were in an indiscriminate pattern and seemed to have been calibrated to inflict pain and suffering. The cause of death was ultimately ruled a homicide caused by a complication of severe malnutrition, dehydration, and soft tissue injuries. The CA investigation was quickly launched thereafter. Investigators from the Monroe County Sheriff's Office were called to the Bloomington Hospital.
Starting point is 00:16:35 and the first officer to arrive, Officer Elliott Jordan, got there at 3.33 a.m. Now, the coroner informed him that Eduardo was severely amaciated, weighing only 50 to 55 pounds with 0% body fat. This is a 12-year-old boy. Officer Jordan found Luis in the examination room sitting in a chair next to the bed and facing the door. The officer entered the room and said, tell me what happened, Bub. Louise explained that he had been sleeping but was awakened by a choking sound. He went to check on his son and found him gagging, so he picked him up and drove to the emergency room. Officer Jordan asked Luis if Eduardo had any health problems.
Starting point is 00:17:17 He said his wife told him that Eduardo had a little bit of a headache about five days ago, that it went away and today he fell in the shower. Apart from that incident, Luis claimed his son was perfectly fine all day and ate all his food. Two more officers had arrived at this point. Deputy Chitwood read Luis his Miranda rights, and Sergeant Hale asked him to sign a consent form so police could search his motel room in van. Louise signed the form without even glancing at the fine print. He then used his cell phone to warn Deanna that police were coming to search the room. The detectives left Louise's room at 3.54 a.m. with the keys to search his van. Another officer, Detective rushing,
Starting point is 00:17:58 then sat down with Luis and asked him what happened. Elise repeated the same story, but there were some obvious inconsistencies in it. When Luis spoke with Officer Jordan, he claimed Eduardo banged his head in the shower, and so he gave him ibuprofen. Now he was saying his son was bleeding from the shower injury, and he gave him an aspirin. Luis was also questioned about how he disciplined his son. He said that Eduardo acted out a lot and admitted to spanking him with a belt, a flip-flop and his bare hands whenever he misbehaved.
Starting point is 00:18:30 Luis also told the officer that the last time he spanked his son was three days prior. Eduardo had hit his sister and was spanked on his legs five times with a belt as punishment. Detective Rushing asked Luis if he ever withheld food from his son. And Luis said he denied ever withholding food and said he could not explain Eduardo's emaciated state. Police claimed his son was a healthy child who ate regularly, and that the day before he arrived at the hospital, he was completely fine and had been running around and jumping on the trampoline like any normal healthy child would. When the questions were over, Luis left the room to go and view his dead son's body in the hospital morgue.
Starting point is 00:19:07 Meanwhile, investigators began searching the economy and motel room where the Poso family was staying. They found wrist and ankle restraints, chains, padlocks, and an electronic dog shock collar hidden beneath the hotel bed. They also discovered a padlock, case that contained all of the food in the room. When Deano was confronted about the items, she admitted that Luis occasionally kept Eduardo restrained in the bathroom and monitored him with the surveillance camera while they went to work. She also said he would sometimes shock Eduardo with the dog training collar.
Starting point is 00:19:41 Deano was taken to the Monroe County Sheriff's office to be interviewed. Police examined her cell phone and Google Drive accounts and found several images of Eduardo confined in various bathrooms on five different days between April 25th and in May 23, 2019. Nearly all of the images showed him inside a bathtub, chained at the ankles and lying shirtless in a fetal position.
Starting point is 00:20:05 He was seen wearing the dog's shock collar in some of the photos. The most recent photo, taken the day before Eduardo died, showed him hunched over in a shower, weak and frail with protruding bones. Further digging uncovered
Starting point is 00:20:19 disturbing text messages Deanna had sent her husband. One was written in Spanish and was translated to, Eduardo was almost out of the chains. Detectives also discovered a selfie Luis took with his shackled son in a video of the other children coming and going in the bathroom
Starting point is 00:20:37 paying no attention to Eduardo. Diana's phone also contained a video showing Louise standing by the bathroom door with his phone in his hand. She could be heard telling Louise to shock Eduardo with the dog caller so that he sees that you're not just all talk. The couple controlled the dog caller with their phones. Another recording showed Eduardo's sister
Starting point is 00:21:01 going into the bathroom and staring at him and then walking back out. At 5.52 a.m., Luis was transported from the Bloomington Hospital to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office in a police vehicle and locked in an interview room. Deanna was already there getting interviewed in another room. Louise gave the detective's permission to examine his cell phone. Numerous incriminating text messages were found on the phone. One message from Diana read, Eduardo almost took off the chains. She sent another text 20 minutes later saying that she did not trust him but would keep watching. A month before Eduardo's death, Louise sent a text message to Deanna saying, this is CA. The couple also exchanged messages discussing the marks left on Eduardo's wrists and ankles from the chains. When asked why
Starting point is 00:21:49 he kept Eduardo chained in the bathroom, Louise claimed he only did it to prevent his son from wandering around the motel. He also said the webcam found in the bathroom was used to monitor the children in the shower. That's fucking disgusting. The detective then asked about the marks found on Eduardo's wrist and ankles. At that point, Luis asked for a lawyer and stopped talking. Both Luis and Deanna were formally arrested at around 5 p.m. on May 24th, 2019. The couple were held in segregation at the Monroe County Jail and $500,000 bail each. They were both charged with murder, neglect of a dependent, neglect of a dependent resulting in death, criminal confinement, and battery resulting in injury to a child younger than 14.
Starting point is 00:22:35 After Luis and Deanna were arrested, the three other kids who appeared healthy were placed with child services. Roxano was finally reunited with her mother, Aerea, after one month. Same day of the couple's arrest, the Monroe County Sheriff's Office held press conference announcing details of Eduardo's death and the arrest of his father and stepmother. Toward the end of the press conference, the speaker admitted that in 30 years of police work, he had never seen a case like Eduardo Posos in his life. He compared the 12-year-old's death to a fan gradually coming to a slow, painful, merciful, merciful halt and said he feels sorry for Eduardo's siblings. Deanna pled guilty to murder in July of 2021. Her trial took place earlier
Starting point is 00:23:18 than intended at her own request. She accepted a plea agreement on May 26, 2021, which dropped the charges of neglect of a dependent, neglect of a dependent resulting in death, criminal confinement, and battery resulting in injury to a child younger than 14. The agreement also ensured she would have a chance of parole one day. Deanna's attorney claimed she had been essayed as a child in her prior and current marriages. When she was nine years old, she was essayed by a man in his mid-20s who was employed by the circus in Mexico. Deanna also claimed she was essayed by her employers when she was 16 and 22 years old. Additionally, she claims to have been sexually, physically, and emotionally mistreated by her husband,
Starting point is 00:24:02 Louise, as the attorney argued there was a power dynamic in Luis and Deanna's marriage, and every decision made regarding Eduardo was Luis's decision. The attorney claimed that Deanna was too scared to report Luis to the police in case she would be sent back to Mexico and separated from her two children. Eduardo's case attracted significant media coverage, and Diana's attorney believed it made it harder for her to get a fair trial. He even requested funds to purchase clothing for Diana to wear during the trial as opposed to the green jail jumpsuit, hoping it would reduce bias from the jury. At the end of July of 2021, Diana was sentenced to 65 years in prison,
Starting point is 00:24:44 the maximum sentence for murder in Indiana. She appealed her sentence the following year, claiming she was a victim of battered spouse syndrome and should therefore have been given a lesser sentence. The appeal was denied by the courts in July of 2022. Diana is currently imprisoned at the Rockville Correctional Facility. Luis's two defense attorneys, Isabella Bravo and Kyle Dugger, also felt the news coverage of Eduardo's case was too much, and they even filed a change of venue request to try to avoid the media's glare. request stated that the news reports were, and I quote, saturating Monroe County with coverage while also reaching a wide audience in South Central Indiana, and that Luis would never receive a fair
Starting point is 00:25:29 trial because the jurors would be exposed to prejudicial information from the media. The request listed hate comments directed at Luis, including SOB should starve and public torture and hanging for both of them. A letter was also recorded on Luis's court file from a man in late in Utah advocating for Luis and Deanna to receive the death penalty. The letter read, people that are capable of this level of cruelty, this degree of torture. I would request if this case is eligible for the death penalty, that these people get it. It should be noted that the prosecution never had plans to pursue the death penalty for either Luis or Deanna. The death penalty is very rare in Indiana, and the state has only executed 20 people since the death penalty.
Starting point is 00:26:16 was reinstated in 1977. Luis appeared in court for murder in June of 2022. He changed his plea to guilty earlier that month after being offered a plea agreement that dropped his additional charges, as well as a petition from the prosecution seeking life in prison without the possibility of parole. During the trial, Luis called Eduardo's death terrible and heartbreaking. His defense team argued that Deanna had been the instigator, and therefore, Luis was not entirely responsible for Eduardo's death.
Starting point is 00:26:46 The psychology expert was also brought in to testify. They claimed that Louise suffered an overwhelming number of stressors in his life, and those stressors resulted in what they called involuntary psychological defense mechanisms that stopped Louise from standing up to Deanna when she mistreated his son. This narrative was thankfully rejected by the court. At one point during the trial, Monroe Circuit Judge Christine Talley Haysman held up an 8x10-inch picture of Eduardo, a happy smiling kid wearing a Disney World t-shirt. Then she displayed another photo, taken a few years later,
Starting point is 00:27:23 it showed him emaciated and near death, chained up in a motel room bathtub. As she displayed the image to the courtroom, she made direct eye contact with Louise and told him, he went from this to this while he was in your care. On October 6, 2022, release was sentenced to 65 years in prison, a maximum sentence for murder in Indiana. he's currently incarcerated at Monroe County Jail.
Starting point is 00:27:49 Eduardo's loved ones were absolutely devastated by his death. When police arrived at Area's door to break the news to her, she believed they were there to tell her she was getting custody of her kids. She felt relieved that her son had spoken out and someone finally listened. When Area found out that her son actually died and was never coming home, she started screaming and her husband had to hold her down. Arrea was beside herself, understandably, thinking back on the report she made to authorities, telling them her son was in danger.
Starting point is 00:28:21 They never listened to her, and now her beloved son was dead. In an interview just days after her son's passing, Araya sat down at a park bench with WTHR reporter Alan Carter. Araya expressed how painful it was for her to see photos and videos of Eduardo because she was still struggling to come to terms with his death. With a heavy heart, she explained how she wanted nothing more than to see her precious son again, so she can kiss him and tell him that she was sorry for not doing enough. Area tries to remember her son as the sweet boy she knew, who was always laughing and always smiling, rather than a victim of heinous child neglect.
Starting point is 00:29:01 The reason why Eduardo was put through months of evil torture is still a mystery to Aurea, who says she will never understand how Louise could do this to his own child, or how her son could have possibly done anything to make Luis or Diana treat him the way they did. At the end of the interview, Area broke down in tears discussing Eduardo's upcoming 13th birthday, as it would have been the day he was old enough to legally decide which parent he wanted to live with. Had Eduardo lived to the end of the year, he would have been reunited with his mother and finally free from his neglectful father and stepmother. One month after Eduardo's passing,
Starting point is 00:29:41 Arrea recorded a heartbreaking message on social media. It read. It took me a while to do this video because for me it's not easy. Today is exactly a month that my son was ripped away from his life. Today is exactly a month where my son wasn't allowed to complete his life the way he was supposed to. I just wanted to let my son know that it's been a long trip for me all these years. The tears that I cry wanting to have you by my side does not compare from the tears dropping now that I know I won't have you. It's just awful. It's just awful.
Starting point is 00:30:14 I hope from the bottom of my heart that no one ever passes for something like this. The pain. The pain. You can't describe the pain. When my mom passed away, to me, I thought it was the worst pain you could ever feel, but it's not. Using your son is the worst pain that can be. Knowing the way he passed away, the horrible way he passed away. They say when the time goes by, you start feeling a little better, but it's not helping me.
Starting point is 00:30:40 that's not working for me. The time goes by and the pain is even worse because I become more and more in the reality that my son is not here. The only thing keeping me up is my daughter because I have to be strong for her. I have to prove to Indiana State that I'm okay and I will be beside her
Starting point is 00:30:56 to raise her the right way after she's been seen so many bad things. But I can't. I can't be this way because only a mother knows how much we love our children, how much we want to take care of them. And I try to take care of my kids. and those monsters take them away from me.
Starting point is 00:31:12 The wrong way they take them away from me. I just wanted to tell my son that it was really hard for me to make this video, but I just wanted to tell him, I love you, baby, and I always did love you. Like a crazy woman, I loved you. Poppy, I tried, and I didn't stop even this year. We went to court twice. I didn't stop trying, and I know you know that. You know that Mommy was always trying to be with you.
Starting point is 00:31:35 Mommy was always trying to get you back to me. I'm sorry if you weren't strong enough to hold your stuff. I love you. I know you're with God right now and I know we're going to see each other again. That's the only comfort I have on my heart right now. Then we will see each other again in the eternity life. We're going to be together for eternity and there's not going to be no one to separate us. No one. Nothing. We're going to be together for the eternity, Poppy. Mommy loves you. I'm sorry. I know you did this to save your sister because you were a savior just like your name means. The meaning of your name is Savior. And that's what you.
Starting point is 00:32:09 you are. Love you, Poppy. On what would have been Eduardo's 13th birthday, Arrea posted the following. November 28th is the day my life changed completely. It was the day Eduardo was born. It was the day I found my first love. It was going to be 13 years old. The age I was waiting so much for so I could take him to court and save his life. On the 28th of this year, it will be Thanksgiving, but it's still going to be the hardest Thanksgiving I will ever see. But I'm still making the dinner and celebrating in his birthday at the same time because he deserves it. They didn't celebrate his birthday for four years. At least after he passed away, Mommy will do his birthday so he can see it in heaven
Starting point is 00:32:49 and be happy that his birthday finally was celebrated. I love you, baby. I can't wait to see you again, my love. I can't wait. It didn't take long before people started demanding answers from the authorities who had failed to protect Eduardo. Randy Warren, a public information officer for the Manatee County Sheriff's Office, told the media their investigators made very thorough checks on Eduardo's home life
Starting point is 00:33:13 and were at the time very confident that there were no signs of neglect during their investigations, despite finding bruises on Eduardo more than once and seeing him grow visibly thinner as time went by. A spokesman for Cirque Italia also released a statement after Eduardo's death. They called his passing a terrible tragedy and affirmed that their company had no no direct connection to either Luis or Deanna. They also promised to do whatever they could to assist in the investigation into Eduardo's death. Three days after Eduardo's death, Araya set up a GoFundMe page to raise money for his funeral
Starting point is 00:33:54 and for her to attend the court trials and to regain custody of her daughter. Sadly, not even half of the $10,000 target was raised in donations, so Araya was unable to give her son a send-off that he deserved. While there were no funeral services for Eduardo, a vigil was held in his memory. At 5 p.m. on June 2nd, 2019, dozens of mourners came together at the Mayaka Family Worship Center on Singletary Road to remember the 12-year-old. Attendees tried their hardest to focus on the good times in Eduardo's life rather than his tragic end. The pastor who led the vigil Lynn Howell believes Eduardo's death was a greater purpose and told the mourners, if Eduardo live for any reason, he live for this, to bring awareness to a system that is broken.
Starting point is 00:34:45 More than 600,000 children are neglected in the U.S. each year, and thousands die every year as a result. Eduardo's mother hopes his case will inspire change in how authorities investigate reports of mistreatment and wants to encourage anyone who sees a child being mistreated to speak out. The details of Eduardo's resting place have been kept private so we don't know if Edward's Warder was buried or cremated, but we do know that he will be deeply and forever missed by everyone who loved him.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.