The Misery Machine - The Case of Santina Cauley

Starting point is 00:00:00 Santina Colley was born on May 6, 2017 in Cork, Ireland to parents Michael Colley and Bridget O'Donoghue, who had been married since 2006. Santina was the youngest of five siblings. Her eldest sibling was a sister, and there were three boys between them. Before Santina was born, the couple had suffered a miscarriage, so when their sweet girl came along, the whole family was delighted and enthralled with the tiny baby. Santina was born premature, but was soon home with her family.

Starting point is 00:00:30 family. Unfortunately, Michael and Bridget separated when Santina was about 10 months old in March of 2018. Initially, when the couple separated, Michael moved out with two of the boys and Bridget kept the other three children. Michael and his sons lived in the Leeside apartments on Grattan Street in the city center. Hork City Center is an island between two branches of the River Lee that goes to the middle of the city. In December of 2018, Michael started seeing a new woman named Karen Hare. Harrington. The two entered a romantic relationship but continued to maintain their separate residences as the relationship progressed. Michael was known to regularly spend the night at her apartment. In the spring of 2019, just before Santina's birthday, an accident occurred on her mother's watch.

Starting point is 00:01:19 Santina was playing in her grandmother's house chasing her brother when she slipped and fell down three stairs. This fall resulted in a broken femur. Now, if you've listened to more than a few of our episodes, you'll know that a broken femur is often a big red flag for social services. Though there are instances where kids just have a freak accident that breaks their femur, more often than not, it is the sign of violence or the result of a car accident or a major fall. Due to the nature of her injury, the Irish version of CPS opened a case on Santina's behalf. The organization, known as Tustla, made the choice to remove Santina from Bridget's custody and place her with her father.

Starting point is 00:01:57 Michael and Bridget's two sons who had been living with Michael went back to live with their mother. This means Michael was solely in charge of Santina and Bridget had the four other children. As spring turned to summer, Michael continued to spend time with Karen and often brought Santina along. By all accounts, Santina and Karen had a good relationship and Karen was well known for being great with children. The age of 15, Karen had effectively become the parent in her household when her mother became ill. She raised her three younger siblings at their family home on Ravensdale Road and Mahan. Karen was 38 years old at the time of our story, and everyone in her life agreed that she was wonderful with children. In fact, she was the go-to

Starting point is 00:02:37 person to watch the kids of many of her friends. In some cases, Karen was the only person that some friends would trust with their children. On July 4th, 2019, Michael and Santina picked up Karen and brought her into Cork City Center. She spent some time in a casino, visited a friends, and also visited her grandmother that day. At some point in the afternoon, Michael and Karen reconnected at their friend Martina's house. Martina lived very close to Karen, and it was an easy walking distance between the two apartment complex. While Michael and Karen were hanging out with friends, they were partaking in a fair amount of adult beverages, and some sources say they were smoking weed as well. In the evening, Michael heard from a cousin from Limerick who was visiting Cork. Michael wanted to have his cousin come visit, and also

Starting point is 00:03:26 wanted him to stay at Karen's apartment. Karen and Michael had already decided that Michael would be staying with Karen that night. They had both been drinking so it wasn't safe for him to drive home and his apartment was too far to walk to. Karen was not happy about this change of plans as she

Starting point is 00:03:42 didn't want the cousin to stay at her place. This seemed to send Michael into a complete rage. Michael would later say he did not remember calling Karen any names. However, many witnesses with them at Martinez's house told nearly identical stories of what he said that night. He allegedly called her a whore and a prostitute.

Starting point is 00:04:02 He also used some racist terms, accusing her of fraternizing with Pakistani men in the casino, and he couldn't believe she was unwilling to accommodate his cousin. Karen decided to end the argument by leaving Martina's house party. As she went to leave, Michael asked her to take Santina with her. Karen refused, saying that it was his baby, and she left. CCTV footage shows her arriving back at her apartment at 26 Elderwood Park and Cork at 136 a.m. Several hours later, around 3 a.m. on July 5th, Michael finally left Martina's apartment to return to Karen's place. A walk back, he alternated between carrying the sleeping Santina in his arms and pushing her in a stroller. He arrived at Karen's home at 306 a.m. and left just four

Starting point is 00:04:47 minutes later at 3.10. During the brief four-minute exchange, neighbors heard yelling between the couple. It seems that Michael's plan had been to try to try and transfer the sleeping toddler to a blanket on the floor. The description from our sources makes it sound like the blanket had been folded into a makeshift sleeping mat. It would appear that the yelling match woke Santina up. Now, instead of staying to soothe his daughter back to sleep, Michael left Santina with Karen and headed out on foot to try to find his cousin.

Starting point is 00:05:15 For the next two hours, Michael was walking all over town in search of his cousin. He was not successful in locating him, so we returned back to Karen's apartment. Michael arrived back at her complex at 5.07 a.m., but was stopped before he entered her door by a neighbor. The neighbor said that Karen had gone mad. He told Michael he'd heard screaming and roaring inside the apartment. Michael seemed unconcerned as he went inside, but just 47 seconds later, he was back out on the balcony yelling that his baby was dead. Ireland's most prominent law enforcement and security agency is called the Garda Shihana. This is a primarily unarmed force that is involved in crime detection, drug enforcement, traffic enforcement, and more.

Starting point is 00:05:59 The name means guardians of the peace. They are most commonly referred to as the Garda or the guards. When Michael came out of his apartment screaming for his baby after just one minute, the neighbor who had warned him about Karen's behavior immediately called the Garda. When Michael had entered Karen's apartment, he had been met with a confusing sight. The space was disheveled and looked though as, there had been a struggle. There were overturned chairs, broken glass on the floor in the kitchen, and smears of blood on the floor, including bloody footprints and what appeared to be drag marks.

Starting point is 00:06:32 His daughter was also not laying on top of the folded blanket as he expected. Instead, she was under the blanket with her face covered. Karen was laying on the couch, not speaking, or reacting to the alarming state of the apartment around her. Michael lifted the blanket to check on his daughter and found her completely naked. Santina's body was also covered in bruises. Michael immediately noticed that one of her eyes was open and the other was closed. He felt for a pulse and found her skin warm to the touch,

Starting point is 00:07:01 but there was no heartbeat. He put his ear to her chest, but there was no signs of breath. The blanket that was covering Santina smelled strongly of urine and had blood stains on the underside toward her body, but they were not visible the way she had been laying when Michael came in.

Starting point is 00:07:17 Michael picked up his daughter as he frantically asked Karen what had happened. She did not answer. He handed the tiny toddler to her, but Karen immediately pushed the baby back into his arms and fled the residence without even stopping to put on shoes. The guarder arrived very soon after the call and asked Michael to wait outside. Sergeant David Tobin saw the blood splattered around the kitchen and declared the apartment a crime scene. Aramedics arrived shortly after and began frantically working on Little Santina, taking over for Sergeant Tobin.

Starting point is 00:07:47 They found her lifeless with pupils that were fixed and dilated. As Michael stood outside, Karen returned to the courtyard with a friend. At this point, many of the residents had been awoken by Michael's screams. They were standing outside with Michael waiting to see what was happening. When Michael saw Karen, he asked if the blood in the apartment was Santinas. Karen said no, the blood was from her. She said that she had cut her foot when she broke a glass, and asked her if she had suffocated his baby.

Starting point is 00:08:14 But a friend stepped between them trying to diffuse the situation. The paramedics soon rushed out with Santina and piled into an ambulance. Michael was unable to ride with her because they needed as much space as possible to work on her in an effort to resuscitate her. Garda offered to drive Michael to the station, but he declined saying that he needed to be at the hospital with his daughter. Michael left on foot and walked the five kilometers to the hospital to get to his baby girl. One of the guard eye, not wanting Michael to be alone, accompanied him on the walk to Cork University Hospital. Meanwhile, at the hospital, Santina had been hooked up to life support, but it was immediately apparent that her injuries were catastrophic. She was literally bruised from head to toe. Her head was soft where the bones of her skull had been broken.

Starting point is 00:09:00 Around 7 a.m., Bridget heard knocking on her door. She opened it to find the guard eye standing in front of her. They asked her if she was Santina's mother, and she was instantly filled with dread. Bridget asked them what was wrong, but all they could say was that Santina, was hurt and that she needed to come to the hospital. She pushed them for more information, but they refused to tell her until she arrived at the hospital. The guard eye called for a taxi for Bridget, and as she was leaving, her 10-year-old son sprinted out of the house and climbed into the taxi with her. When Bridget walked into the hospital, she was greeted by a team of five or six doctors who took her to a private room. There, she was told that her daughter was dead.

Starting point is 00:09:42 She tried to get answers to understand what had happened to her baby girl, but they did not have any answers for her. They did ask her if she wanted to hold her daughter, which she said, of course. Heartbroken Bridget said she'll never forget holding her baby's lifeless body the morning she died. I have to go into that room and I said, do you want to hold her? I said, do I want to what? Of course I want to hold her. I hold her and I was trying to bring her back to her for cold.

Starting point is 00:10:11 so I was trying to warm her up. I didn't want to believe she was dead. You know, she just didn't want to, she arises open and I want to just take her home. Bridget cradled her broken daughter in her arms and pled with her to wake up. She held her as she felt the dent in the back of her head where her skull had been broken.

Starting point is 00:10:32 She held her as she saw bruises from her scalp all the way down to her toes. She saw the spaces on her head where the hair had been ripped from her scalp. help. Her son pointed at her mouth and Bridget saw that her teeth were chipped and knocked backward into her mouth. She held her as the doctors turned off life support and Santina died in her arms at 9.20 a.m. on July 5th. It was quickly apparent to Bridget and Michael as well as the Garda and medical professionals that there was no way Santina had simply sustained all these injuries accidentally. Someone had done this to her. And according to Michael, his daughter was fine when he left her at 3 a.m.

Starting point is 00:11:11 He claimed the only person who was with her for those two hours was Karen. Authorities began searching for evidence in the apartment immediately. They found blood splattered and smeared throughout the kitchen as though there had been a struggle. The odd thing was that the living room had no trace of blood, with the exception of the blanket that Santina was covered with. They found two pairs of tiny toddler leggings in the apartment. One pair was pink leopard print and had a diaper still inside it as though it had been pulled forcibly from her body.

Starting point is 00:11:40 The other pair was yellow and had blood stains on it, which were found on the floor in the kitchen. They also found a pair of adult leggings in Karen's room with five blood stains on them. Tests would later show that four of those stains held Karen's DNA, and one was from Santina. They also found tufts of red hair on the couch and floor, which would prove to be from Santina as well. The hair they found still had the roots attached, showing they had been ripped from her head. Santina's tiny pink sequin tank top was found torn on the floor. They also found one of her earrings on the floor as well. The other was still in her ear.

Starting point is 00:12:15 In the search to find who had done this to Santina, the Garda's first job was to try and clear Michael and Karen as they were the two adults in charge of Santina that night. Both claimed they had no idea what happened to the little girl. However, they needed to figure out if either of them was telling the truth or not. After the initial interviews with both adults, the Garda had two suspects with no confessions. They turned to CCTV footage and cell phone records.

Starting point is 00:12:40 to try to verify one or both stories. Michael had claimed that Santina was fine when he left her at 3 a.m. with Karen. He then walked around the city for two hours before returning home to find her dead. In addition, Michael immediately turned over the clothes he had been wearing that night to authorities. They found no blood whatsoever on his clothing or any other evidence that would suggest he was present during the violent attack on his daughter. Karen claimed that Michael left the baby with her and she immediately fell asleep. She was awoken when Michael returned home at 5 a.m. frantic about his daughter's condition.

Starting point is 00:13:13 The Garda ended up examining over 300 hours of CCTV footage to help determine if Michael's story was true. This footage showed the very tight time frame of when he left Martina's home, arrived at Karen's apartment, and then immediately set out on foot to search for his cousin. Footage from the city showed him on foot on several occasions cooperating his story that he was not with Santina for. from 3 a.m. to 5 a.m. There was also CCTV footage from Karen's apartment complex, which had enough cameras in the area that both entrances to her apartment were able to be monitored to see if anyone entered her residence or if Karen left. The guard also examined the phone records from both Karen and Michael. These two sources showed that Karen could not have been asleep from 3 a.m. to 5 a.m. Karen made a few calls to her friends, her sister Michelle,

Starting point is 00:14:05 and another resident of the complex called Ifa. In addition, it is clear that no one other than Karen entered or exited the apartment during that time. The Garda's next step was to interview other residents of the complex in an effort to find anyone who might know more about what happened in those two hours. Considering that the time in question was in the wee hours of the morning, there was a good possibility that no one had seen or heard anything. However, this was not the case. Many neighbors that night reported hearing a great deal of noise from Karen's apartment. One neighbor recalled hearing yelling at 3 a.m. when Michael dropped Santina off. They were able to confirm that the voices they heard were from Michael and Karen.

Starting point is 00:14:45 She heard Karen yelling, I'm going to tell them and heard the sound of breaking glass. After Michael left, the same neighbor went to check on Karen to make sure she was safe. Karen did not initially answer when she knocked on the door. Instead of giving up, they went to her other door and knocked and kicked the door until Karen answered. While banging on the door, she heard someone inside who sounded very upset. She thought it was Karen. Karen's first question upon opening the door was to ask if the guarder were there. She then told her neighbor she was fine and apologized for being loud and causing trouble

Starting point is 00:15:16 and told her that she was going to go to bed. The neighbor described her as being distressed and quieter than usual. She apologized several times in their brief interaction. However, it does not seem that Karen went to sleep at that point. Dylan Olney, Karen's immediate next-door neighbor, was kept awake as the noises from Karen's apartment became alarming. He said he heard a commotion like someone throwing a fit or a tantrum. It sounded like someone was throwing things around in her apartment.

Starting point is 00:15:42 He heard her repeatedly opening and slamming her sliding glass door. Dylan shouted at her to stop or he would call the Garda. Instead, Karen left her apartment and went down into the garden area, still shouting and raging. She shouted at him to call the Garda. He said he had never seen her like that before and said, She was like someone possessed. I was a bit creeped out by it.

Starting point is 00:16:03 She was acting weird. She was acting crazy. She then calmly came to his door a few minutes later asking for a cigarette. He turned her away and locked his door. After he turned her away, Karen returned to her apartment. But things got worse from there. Dylan heard a child crying. He was immediately concerned because of Karen's demeanor.

Starting point is 00:16:21 He then began to hear Karen's voice. He'd hear her taunting the child with a loud, sarcastic tone. He heard her mocking the baby saying, "'Ah, poor baby, are you all right?' "'Followed quickly with a mean shut up.' At 4.31 a.m., he was finally so concerned that he called the Garda. However, by the time they arrived, the noises had stopped. There was no more crying, no more shouting, no breaking glass or things being thrown around.

Starting point is 00:16:45 He described it as dead silent. Officers knocked on Karen's door, but they did not get a response. David did not report the child to crying at this point. Rather, it seemed he had merely called in a noise complaint. After trying for several minutes, the guardo left at around 4.56 a.m. telling David to call if things got out of hand again. It was just 10 minutes before Michael arrived home to find his daughter dead. Karen was arrested on Monday, July 8th. However, she was released shortly after on July 9th. In many of Bridget's interviews in the days following Santina's death, she lamented that she just wanted her daughter's murderer to be brought to justice.

Starting point is 00:17:23 A flickering candle and a photograph of little Santina's death. in happier times. Why did you do to my baby? Why? Why? Why? That's answer. I'll ask her why. She didn't give that answer.

Starting point is 00:17:39 Why did she kill my baby? What did she do to her? She's only two, all. She's only a baby like. What does she do? Nothing at all? I'm very angry with that woman. She just sat there and said court

Starting point is 00:17:54 just as like nothing happened. She would play with nothing. in the game. That's where I see it. And she really upset me. We have her lovely memories and that's the best thing we have. But we'll never get over what happened to my little baby, her little, her little baby. Like, you know, she was so gentle. You can't believe like someone could do that. Whatever, the report came back as her, as we all heard, the beatings she got. That was horrible. You couldn't do that to have baby. You couldn't do that. You couldn't that. You couldn't that to nobody.

Starting point is 00:18:30 I don't know how the minute she got so much brutal beating. It's horrifying. And how she just looked there in courtroom, thinking there was nothing happening. And she'd done it. In the weeks following, both Michael and Karen were interviewed several times. Karen was interviewed five separate times by Gardai. On the final occasion, she was asked, Try closing your eyes.

Starting point is 00:18:55 I want you to think back to that night when you were in the apartment that night and Michael left. Keep your eyes closed for a second. I want you to think back on all the objects that were around you. I want you to think about that location, that time, and your best memory of what went on in as much detail as possible. In Karen's recollection of events, she thought she fell asleep. She had an argument with Michael when he arrived around 3 a.m. Santina was crying as Michael left her. Karen thought she was too hot, so she took Santina's clothes off and laid her on the blanket.

Starting point is 00:19:30 Karen said she went back to sleep on the couch. The interrogators challenged this, but Karen insisted that she had fallen asleep. She cried and then vomited as they showed her pictures of the clumps of Santina's hair on the couch. Karen could not or would not explain what happened to Santina. In August of 2019, Karen was arrested again and officially charged with Santina's murder. This was when it hit the news that Karen was also four months pregnant. Initially, she was not given bail and remained in custody for a few. few weeks. Ultimately, she got out on bail and stayed out until her trial in 2022. She gave

Starting point is 00:20:05 birth to her son in the last week of October of 2019. He was nine weeks early and spent several weeks in the specialist premature baby unit at Cork Hospital. While Bridget was horrified and devastated that the person she believed to be her daughter's murderer was out on bail, the rest of the community was just confused. Karen had an impeccable reputation with friends and family. Everyone was in shock that the trustworthy caretaker of their children was being accused of something so horrific. Many said that they could not fathom that the woman they knew could have possibly inflicted the injuries described in the media. Though it was well known that Karen had come from a dysfunctional family, she had made a change for her own life. She had frequently worked as a

Starting point is 00:20:46 babysitter and everyone trusted her. Karen's sister Michelle said that it just wasn't in Karen's nature to be mean to a child. She would never hurt, or worse, murder a child. Some noted that she was certainly not a person who put up with crap from anyone, but she had never been publicly violent. As Bridget and Michael waited for justice, other matters needed to be handled. Sweet Santina needed to be laid to rest. Either Bridget nor Michael had much money. With four other children to care for, the cost for a funeral seemed insurmountable. A friend of the family called some of the local news stations in a plea to help the family. As a result, a GoFundMe page was opened by the Neil Prenderville Show in Cork's Red FM, which raised 11,425 euros for Santina's service.

Starting point is 00:21:32 Fundraiser vowed that any excess funds will be distributed between local charities. Bridget would later go on to appear on the Neil Prenderville show, which we will link for you in our show notes. It's been a horrific 10 days for you. How are you bearing up? Well, I'm trying to keep strong from my kids, but my heart inside is broken. My world is destroyed. Santina was buried in a tiny white casket on July 12th. Her mother picked out a pink dress for her to wear. Now often at funerals of small children, we hear people say things like, they look like sleeping angels as they lay in their casket. When asked if her daughter looked beautiful, Bridget said no. Her daughter was so bruised that she had to wear a long-sleeved, high

Starting point is 00:22:19 neck shirt under her dress. You could see the extensive bruising on her face through the makeup. Bridget also said that her mouth looked all wrong because of the damage done to her teeth. Santina's family placed some of her favorite things in her casket with her. They buried her with teddy bears, a barney toy, and telotubbies. Santina's funeral was a ceremony called the Mass of the Angels. Now, this is a traditional Catholic funeral ceremony reserved for the death of a child. Some of Santina's mourners wore shirts with her picture on them with the words, R-I-P Angel Santina. Balloons printed with the photo of her face also decorated the church.

Starting point is 00:23:01 Michael stood with his hand on her casket throughout the whole ceremony. When the service ended, her casket was carried out by her parents and siblings. She was buried at St. Catherine Cemetery, Kilcully. After Santina was buried, the family spent time decorating her grave to make it as beautiful. beautiful as the little girl they'd lost. Her headstone was inscribed with her full name, Santina, Eileen, Barbie, Colley, O'Donohue. It wasn't until November that the complete autopsy results were released. Santina suffered a total of 53 injuries. There were 49 external injuries that consisted mostly of extreme bruising. There were four internal injuries including complex

Starting point is 00:23:42 fractures to her skull with a displacement of bone, two fractured ribs, fractures to her right arm, as well as a severe cervical spinal injury. A fracture to her femur was also noted. This femur fracture was clearly healed and appeared to be the femur break that happened several months earlier under her mother's watch. The bruises on Santina's body were on her forehead, earlobe, cheeks, side of her face, lower jaw, arms, hands, feet, and more.

Starting point is 00:24:09 Her scalp was so bruised, the examiner could not find a single space that was not bruised. The examiner couldn't even count how many blows to the head Santina had suffered because of the condition of her scalp. Santina's brain injury was so severe that she would have fallen into a coma immediately. Karen remained out on bail for years as her trial was repeatedly postponed due to delays caused by the pandemic. She was granted bail for just 5,000 euros and was released to stay with her friend.

Starting point is 00:24:36 She had twice daily check-ins with the Garda and a curfew of 8 p.m. to 8 a.m. She was not allowed anywhere near the address of the murder and was not allowed any contact with Santina's family. She also had to surrender her passport. As 2021 arrived, Santina's family was still waiting for justice. On January 26, Michael saw Karen boring a bus. This was right around the time that her trial was supposed to start, but had been delayed due to the pandemic for a third time. Michael followed her on the bus and attacked her. He threw her to the floor and kicked her a few times, and Karen sustained soft tissue injuries to her chest. His attack was caught on CCTV footage, but it wasn't needed. He turned himself in shortly after the assault. Michael admitted to losing control and wished

Starting point is 00:25:21 he had let the law take its course. It was later sentenced to 10 months in jail. The entire sentence was suspended as long as Michael stayed out of trouble for the next two years. Karen's final trial began in April of 2022 and was expected to last four to five weeks. Karen maintained a plea of innocence, always claiming that she had no memory of those hours. Through interviews and interrogations, that took place before the trial, Karen was repeatedly presented with evidence that there appeared to be no one else in the apartment that night. She even corroborated Michael's timeline

Starting point is 00:25:57 of when he was out of the house and how much time she was in charge of Santina. When asked what this meant, she admitted that it seemed like it must have been her or that all the evidence pointed to her. Now, one would think that at this point she might accept an insanity plea. It would seem that if she truly didn't,

Starting point is 00:26:16 have any memory of what happened, that she might have had some sort of psychotic break or disassociative episode. However, an insanity plea would also mean that she would need to admit that it was her that beat that trial to death. Throughout the trial, Karen was allowed to wear sunglasses and a surgical mask to hide her face. She appeared to have no reaction as weeks of evidence and testimonies were presented. Garda had used a force of over 90 officers to follow up on over 450 leads and take 320 witness statements. They left no stone unturned as they sought the truth of what happened to little Santina. Testimonies were given by neighbors about how much they trusted Karen, and others testified

Starting point is 00:26:59 about the ranting and raving that they heard that night. Medical examiners and doctors spoke of the catastrophic and completely devastating injuries that Santina suffered. It was stated that Santina weighed only 10.3 kilograms of the time of her death. Pounds, that translates to 22.2.2. Sergeant David Tobin, who was the first to arrive on the scene, testified about what he saw that morning. He said, when I went into the living room, I saw Santina Collie. She was lying on a quilt. She looked pale and she wasn't breathing. From looking at her, she looked deceased to me at that stage.

Starting point is 00:27:33 It looked like she'd been placed on the quilt. She was like a child's doll. Her eyes were only slightly open. He said her skin was gray and colorless. Her legs were spayed in an unnatural position. She had no pulse. When his head was placed to her chest, he found no heartbeat or signs of breathing. He performed CPR, but could only use two fingers for the chest compressions because she was so tiny.

Starting point is 00:27:55 At one point, Karen took to the stand where she again stated that she was innocent. She said, I did not murder Santina Colley, but she didn't say much else. She was only cross-examined for about 15 minutes out of the four-week trial and dug her heels in every time the prosecution tried to say that there couldn't have possibly been anybody else there. She maintained that she must have been unaware of what happened during those hours. Therefore, she could not confirm or deny that anyone else did anything to Santina either. Near the end of the trial, the prosecutor addressed the constant mantra from witnesses that Karen was trustworthy. He said, it is a refrain, it is a crutch, it is a drumbeat in those interviews.

Starting point is 00:28:35 There is evidence that someone trusted her with their own kids. I thought, what has that got to do with anything? But I am wrong. Karen Harrington being trusted with a child. actually is the point. Michael Colley trusted her. He had no reason to believe harm would come to that child. It is one of the first things that he said, but sometimes people you trust betray that trust. In the end, the jury of seven men and four women took four hours and 46 minutes to find Karen Harrington guilty of the murder of Santina Colley. The silence in courtroom number six

Starting point is 00:29:07 was broken when the jury announced that Karen Harrington seen here earlier this morning on a way into court was guilty of murdering Santina Colley. She showed no emotion as the verdict was returned. July 5th, 2019 and Harrington was caring for little Santina at her apartment in Cork while the infant's father was looking for a cousin of his in town. The trial heard Harrington and Michael Cawley had been arguing earlier in the night. Shortly after 5 a.m., Michael Cawley returned to find his daughter lying in a blood-stained duvet fighting for her life. She died in her mother's arms a number of hours later. A post-mortem found,

Starting point is 00:29:43 two-year-old Santina Kali, described in court as little and defenseless, sustained a complex fractured skull, an injury to her spinal cord, as well as 49 external injuries and four internal injuries. At all times, 38-year-old Harrington had denied

Starting point is 00:29:58 she murdered Santina Kali. But the trial was told, DNA and CCTV don't lie. Karen Harrington is now beginning her first night of a life sentence behind bars. And our southern correspondent, Paul Byrne, is outside court courthouse for us this evening. So, Paul, the sentencing happened straight away after the verdict was returned, and the court also heard some powerful victim impact statement today.

Starting point is 00:30:22 That's right, Caroline. This was an extremely distressing, a difficult case in trial for everyone to sit through. And, of course, remember that the jury have been listening to this evidence, hours and hours of evidence since April 25th. Experienced officers privately have been telling me that this was, was one of the most harrowing cases of their career. A team of top investigators have been working on this case, not since April 25th, but moments after Santina was found critically injured.

Starting point is 00:30:49 That's when this investigation commenced. They were working around the clock. CCTV, and the amount of CCTV footage they gathered proved vital in this investigation. Every eye was dotted, every T was crossed, and they brought this case before the courts. Earlier today, one of the lead investigators, Inspector Danny Collin, who spoke to the media, was part of that investigation team. The murder of Santina Colley has had a profound impact on Santina's extended family and across the community.

Starting point is 00:31:18 On Garda Shekana notes the decision the court has made today in the conviction and sentence of Karen Harrington for the murder of Santina. The early provision of statements, CCTV, social media clips, doorbell cameras and cooperation with house-to-house inquiries greatly aided this investigation. I would like to particular,

Starting point is 00:31:37 thank the dedicated investigation team who have worked in this case for almost three years. Justice for Santina was always the ultimate goal for the team since her murder on the 5th of July 2019. This was a particularly emotive case for the members that attended the scene and the investigation team, many having children of a similar age. Santina was always in our thoughts. We would like to again publicly express our sympathies to Santina's family and on Garters-Econa will continue to support them as they continue to grieve for Santina. Mr Justice Michael McGrath, who presided over this trial, also acknowledged and complimented the investigation team.

Starting point is 00:32:19 Now, just before Karen Harrington was sentenced this afternoon, victim impact statements were read out on behalf of Santina's mother, Bridget O'Donoghue, and her father, Michael Colley, who left court without making a comment. But basically, summing up those victim impact statements, Michael Colley said his daughter was beautiful and fun-loving. His little girl had a very, very cute smile. her beautiful eyes, blue eyes and red hair will be sorely missed.

Starting point is 00:32:42 May 6th, he said, was Santina's birthday. She would have been five during this trial, but he said all they have now is heavenly birthdays. Her mother, Bridget O'Donohu, said she can remember receiving a knock on the door in the early hours of the morning on July 5th, 2019, a guard standing there telling her that Santina had been involved in an accident, and she had to go to Cork University Hospital where a number of hours later, little Santina was placed in her mother's arms.

Starting point is 00:33:08 And she said she can remember the bruising and the swelling on her little girl's face. And she said, basically, my little girl, she said, was in a dreadful condition. Her anger towards Karen Harrington, she said, will never, ever dissipate. And she said she can always and always thinks about what Santina may have been thinking in the final moments of her life. Now, on the way out of court this afternoon, Bridget was accompanied by her solicitor, Donald Daly, who made a statement on behalf of Bridget O'Donahoo. I've been asked by Bridget, mother of Santina, to make a very brief statement in respect to this matter. She would like to thank the Guardee for their professionalism and humanity throughout this case.

Starting point is 00:33:47 She especially wishes to mention Guard of Brendan Ryan, Detective Kormack Trotty, Detective Inpector, Danny Collin. She would also like to thank her neighbours for their support throughout this nightmare. She will be forever in debt to the first responders and the medical staff of CUH who fought so long and so hard to save Santina's life. She has said all there is to say in her victim impact report and doesn't wish to make any further comments. She now wishes simply to get on with her life to mourn Santina with her children.

Starting point is 00:34:19 Thank you very much. The circumstances of this case were completely and absolutely shocking and no parents should have to bury their child. Those were some of the words for Mr Justice Michael McGrath while he was handing down the mandatory life sentence to Karen Harrington. She, of course, made no reaction, gave no reaction, action made no statement whatsoever. She was standing by her decision that she did not murder Santina Collie. She was then late from the courthouse to begin a journey where she will now spend the

Starting point is 00:34:47 rest of her life in Limerick Prison. Karen Harrington was convicted to a life sentence and is currently serving her time in Limerick Prison where she spends much of her time separated from other inmates for her own safety. Shortly after the conviction, Bridget received a letter in the mail claiming to be from Karen. The letter continued to claim that Karen was innocent. It begged for understanding and sympathy saying things like, The constant heartache is unbearable. It also contained a plea that the two women needed to talk in detail.

Starting point is 00:35:19 Bridget was understandably disturbed and scared by this letter as Karen shouldn't have any way to contact her. Any letter she wrote should have been screened before they left the prison. It is still unclear if this letter was truly from Karen or if it was a hoax. Now, around that time, Bridget was also facing the prospect of becoming homeless. Unable to return to the home that she had shared with her baby, she was staying with her mother. However, her mother was moving into a smaller unit and had no room for Bridget and her children. She made a plea for assistance in August of 2022 with help to find housing for herself and her kids.

Starting point is 00:35:57 There was no follow-up to that story, and we are unsure where the family is now. Early 2024, Karen attempted to appeal her sentence. Her basis for the appeal was that the Garda had breached her privacy by using the CCTV footage that showed both of her doorways. Her appeal was denied as all footage was all in public spaces. If Santina were still alive today, she would have turned five at the time of Karen's trial. Santina is remembered as being the most perfect little girl. Her mother described her as being the essence of pink.

Starting point is 00:36:31 She described her as being so perfect that one of her middle names was Barbie because she felt she was a perfect little doll. She's remembered as being happy, easygoing, and that she never cried. Santina's 15-year-old sister created a shrine for her in their home. She lit a candle for her sister every day.

Starting point is 00:36:50 At the end of Karen's trial, Bridget had the following to say about Santina during her victim impact statement. She loved her rhymes, her cartoons, and Barney. She loved her trips to town with me and her nana on a Wednesday. She would hop into the buggy and knew the routine. She was very cute for her age.

Starting point is 00:37:06 She was clever and bright. She knew all the names of the Telitubbies and was a happy child. She had an old soul. She seemed to be here before. She brought so much joy to our family and her brothers and sisters adored her. My last memory of Santina was her hugging and squeezing me and not wanting me to leave. I regret leaving her so much that day. I wish I could go back in time.

Starting point is 00:37:28 I never could have imagined I would get my baby back, passed away in my arms in a dreadful condition.

The Misery Machine - The Case of Santina Cauley

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.