The New Yorker Radio Hour - Rachel Carson Dreams of the Sea

Episode Date: April 21, 2020

Before she published “Silent Spring,” one of the most influential books of the last century, Rachel Carson was a young aspiring poet and then a graduate student in marine biology. Although she couldn’t swim and disliked boats, Carson fell in love with the ocean. Her early books—including “The Sea Around Us,” “The Edge of the Sea” and “Under the Sea Wind”—were like no other nature writing of their time, Jill Lepore says: Carson made you feel you were right there with her, gazing into the depths of a tide pool or lying in a cave lined with sea sponges. Lepore notes that Carson was wondering about a warming trend in the ocean as early as the 1940s, and was planning to explore it after the publication of “Silent Spring.” If she had not died early, of cancer, could Carson have brought climate change to national attention well before it was too late?  Excerpts from Carson’s work were read by Charlayne Woodard, and used with permission of Carson’s estate.  This segment was originally broadcast on September 14, 2018. New Yorker Radio Hour listeners, we want to hear from you.  We have a few questions about the show and how you listen to it. The survey takes about twenty minutes, and your feedback will help us make our podcast better.  Take the survey here.

This is The New Yorker Radio Hour, a co-production of WNYC Studios and The New Yorker. Welcome to The New Yorker Radio Hour. I'm David Remnick. This week is the 50th anniversary of the first Earth Day in April 1970. We're going to remember Rachel Carson. Probably more than any other person, Carson helped to launch the environmental movement as we know it today. And it came with her book, Silent Spring. But Carson's earlier writings, also published in The New Yorker, contain the seeds of what made her so influential.

Here's Carson, speaking in 1951. I seem to have been born with a fascination for the sea. For years before I ever saw it, I thought about it, dreamed about it, and wondered what it could be like. Carson's writings about the sea were filled with a sense of wonder and poetry. Here's actress Charlene Woodard, Reading Rachel Carson. In midsummer, life in the surface water slacks to a slower pace.

The red jellyfish, Sienia, usually has grown from the size of a thimble to that of an umbrella. This great jellyfish moves through the sea with rhythmic pulsations, trailing long tentacles, and as likely as not, shepherding a little group of young cod or haddock which find shelter under its bell and travel. with it. And here's Jill Lepore, a staff writer for the New Yorker and a professor of history at Harvard. So Rachel Carson was born nowhere near the sea. She was born near the Allegheny River in western Pennsylvania in 1907. She grew up on a kind of dilapidated farm. It wasn't really a working farm anymore. Her father was sort of a bit of a traveling salesman, but not a successful one.

She went to college to become a poet. She was going to study English. She, though, changed her whole focus of her college education when she took a biology class. And she fell in love with her biology professor, became deeply, passionately attached to this quite incredible woman, Mary Scott Skinker, and who spotted in young Rachel Carson something quite promising and special and managed to secure for her a summer position at Woods Hole on Cape Cod, this path-breaking oceanographic institute. This was 1928. She was 21 years old. She'd never seen or smelled the ocean before. I had my first prolonged contact with the sea at the Marine Biological Laboratory at Woods Hole. There I never tired of watching the tidal currents racing through the hole, that wonderful place of whirlpools and eddies and swiftly running water.

And I love to watch the waves breaking at Nobska Point after a storm. She didn't really know how to swim. She was terrified of boats, but there was something just so magical. If you picture a little boy always wanted to be an astronaut kind of landing on Mars. The summer sea may glitter with millions of moving pinpricks of light, like an immense swarm of fireflies. This effect is produced by a shoal of the brilliantly phosphorescent shrimp, Meganiktyphonies, a creature of cold and darkness.

and of the places where icy water rolls upwards from the depths and bubbles to the surface. From that first summer at Woods Hole, Carson would roll up her pant legs and take off her shoes, and she would climb all over the shoreline. She would climb up and down the dunes. She would wade out into the water. She would be gone for hours upon hours upon hours. She would get up in the middle of the night to wander out to the beach with a flashlight looking for the nightlife. I remember a moss-carpeted ledge jutting out from the rock wall over sea depths where Laminarias rolled in with the tide. The moss was saturated, holding water as faithfully as a sponge.

Down within the deep pile of that moss, I caught a glimpse of bright rosy color. Corson became devoted to the study of the sea after that summer in Woods Hole, and she decided to go to graduate school. She entered a Ph.D. program at Johns Hopkins, really, ambitious thing for any woman to do. She started in 1932. We're in the depths of the depression by now. Her family has no money. Her family is entirely dependent on her and she's in graduate school. She moves to Baltimore, but her mother, her ailing father, her divorced sister, her sister's two really little children all come to live with her, and Carson has to support them. She works as a lab

assistant. She teaches biology. She ends up leaving her PhD program with a master's degree and takes a job at the Bureau of Fisheries, where, unsurprisingly, she's hired to write brochures. The kinds of brochures they were putting together were, you know, about as interesting as the terms of service when you click on to a new app. Like, they're just really technical writing. They might explain the life cycle of a seagull, for instance. So she's writing brochures, and they have this just majesty. They're just this majestic, and they're intimate, and they're also shocking, and they're dramatic,

and they have characters, but no one has heard anyone write about the sea like this before. Certainly not the Bureau of Fisheries. And so her supervisor says, look, your writing is actually too good for these brochures. You should start sending it around. And her first breakthrough essay in 1937 is published in the Atlantic, which I always think is somehow fitting. And it knocked people's socks off. People often seem to be surprised that a woman should have written a book about the sea.

This is particularly true, I find, of men. Perhaps they have been accustomed for a long time to thinking about the more exciting fields of science as exclusively masculine domains. In fact, one of my correspondence a few days ago addressed me as dear sir, explaining it, although he knew perfectly well that I was a woman, he simply could not bring himself to acknowledge the fact. Tide pools contain within their depths, mysterious worlds, where all the beauty of the sea is subtly portrayed in miniature.

I remember one so small that as I lay outstretched on the rocks beside it, I could easily touch its far shore. Its floor was paved with muscles. Their shells were a soft color, the misty blue of distant mountain ranges, and their presence gave an illusion of depth. The water in which they lived was so clear as to be invisible to my eyes. I could detect the interface between air and water only by the sense of coldness on my fingertips. This crystal water was filled with sunshine,

an infusion and distillation of light that reached down and surrounded each of the small and resplendent shellfish with its glowing radiance. Carson complained a lot about the way people wrote about the sea and the way they wrote about nature, which was they made a catalog of things. And there'd be no relationship between one thing and the other, between the environment and the creature. The shells of the muscles provided a place of attachment for the only other life that I could see in the pool.

fine as the finest threads. The basal stems of colonies of hydroids traced their faintly discernible lines across the shells. The hydroids belong to the group called Circularia, in which each individual of a colony and all the supporting and connecting branches are enclosed in transparent sheaths, like a tree in winter after an ice storm.

She saw when she looked down into a tide point, pool, how everything was attached to everything else, how everything was dependent on everything else. I lay beside the pool and with my hand lens brought the hydroids into clearer view. They seemed to me to look nothing so much as pieces of exquisite cut glass. Each of them, perhaps a segment of an intricately wrought chandelier. On what, I wondered, were all these certularians, carnivorous, like all hydroids, feeding. From their very abundance, I knew that whatever creatures served them as food must be many times more abundant than the hydroids themselves.

Yet I could see nothing. Then, somewhere in the crystal clarity of the pool, my eye detected... So you can picture Carson there lying on her stomach with her face pressed into that tide pool. That's how she gains in her. captures your attention, bringing you intimately into that world, and giving you this tour of it from what appears to be the most vulnerable, tiniest, most insignificant piece of this tiny, tiny, little tide pool and showing you step by step how you too are tied to them. Yet I knew that it was only the imperfection of human vision that prevented me from seeing

the microscopic hordes of water flea. copepods, and worms on which the hydroids were preying with those groping, searching tentacles that were themselves barely discernible. Even more than the visible life in the pool, the life I could not see came to dominate my thoughts, and finally the members of that invisible throng seemed to me the most powerful beings in the pool. Both the hydroids and the muscles were utterly dependent on this invisible throng. of the tides streams. The muscles as passive strainers of plant plankton,

the hydroids as active predators, seizing and ensnarring microscopic animals. And should the plankton become less plentiful? Should the incoming tide stream somehow become drained of this life? Then the pool would become a pool of death, both for the muscles in their shells blue as mountains and for the crystal coolness of the high. So what Carson does so effectively here is communicate just how important are things that we can't see.

She's teaching a reader who might wonder about whether invisible things matter, that they do matter. And that's really the same insight that she communicates that she brings to her most famous work, Salispring, which appears in 1962, but which Carson had been thinking about since 1945. The chemicals to which life is asked to make its adjustment are no longer merely the calcium and silica and copper and the rest of the minerals washed out of the rocks and carried in rivers to the sea. They are also the synthetic creations of man's inventive mind,

brewed in his laboratories and having no counterparts in nature. To adjust to these chemicals would require time on the scale that is natures. It would require not merely the years of a man's life, but the life of generations. Carson would say about the chemical companies that they thought that they could repeal the balance of nature, that you couldn't repeal the balance of nature any more than you could rescind the law of gravity, that this audacity of chemists and scientists and trying to conquer nature with these pesticides was wrongheaded. And she made that claim with great temerity and determination at a time when she herself, was suffering from cancer.

She had been diagnosed with breast cancer. She'd had a radical mastectomy. She'd had radiation. She was quite ill. She was considerably hobbled. She'd lost her hair. She was often in a wheelchair. And yet she hid her illness from the whole world,

went before Congress to testify, did her best to get her claims out into the world, and began planning her next project. She wanted to go back after Silent Spring to writing about the sea. Curious changes have been taking place, with many animals invading the cold-temperate zone from warmer waters, and pushing up through Maine and even into Canada. She'd noticed, as many scientists have begun to notice by the 1950s, that the world's oceans were getting warmer. This phenomenon is clearly related to the widespread

change of climate that is now well-recognized, a general warming up having been noticed first in the Arctic regions, then in the sub-arctic, and more recently in the temperament, in the temperate areas of the northern states. We tend to think the debate about climate change is a recent debate, or that the observation that the seas are rising is a new thing. But this is something Karsin noticed in the 1950s. One of the most impressive examples of this northward movement is provided by the green crab,

once unknown north of the Cape, but now well known to every clam fisherman in Maine, because of its habit of preying on the young states of the clam. At the beginning of this century, zoological manuals gave its range from New Jersey to Cape Cod. In 1905, it was reported near Portland. And by 1930, specimens had been collected in Hancock County, about midway along the main coast. I picture Rachel Carson sitting in her house on an island in Maine, looking down at the shore, puzzling over the rising of the seas

decades and decades ago and it's painful. It's painful to picture that and think about what might have been if she hadn't died just embarking on this study, this inquiry,

wondering what was causing the oceans to get warmer and these species to migrate. At a time when she had a tremendous purchase on American politics on international politics, she had a kind of authority

that scientists don't have anymore. What would that book have done in the world? Looking down into the small world that is limited by the walls of the cave, I feel the rhythms of the greater sea world. It is the green sponges lining the pool that for me give this cave a special quality, a sense of the continuing flow of time.

As I watch, a fish swims in, a shadow in the green lights. Compared to the ancient sponges, the fish is almost a symbol of modernity. Its ancestry traceable only half as far back into the past. And I, whose eyes behold the images of the two as though they were my contemporaries, am a mere newcomer, whose ancestors inhabited the earth so briefly that my present seems somehow anachronistic. And as I lie looking into the cave and thinking these thoughts, the surge of waters rises and floods across the rock behind me. The tide is rising.

That's Charlene Woodard reading from the work of Rachel Carson. And we heard staff writer Gilipur. Her history of the United States is called These Truths. I'm David Remnick, and I hope if you can that you can get some time outside this week with appropriate social distancing, of course. Be well, and please join us next time for The New Yorker Radio Hour. The New Yorker Radio Hour is a co-production of WNYC Studios and The New Yorker. Our theme music was composed and performed by Merrill Garvis of Tune Yards, with additional music by Alexis Quadrado.

This episode was produced by Alex Barron, Emily Boutin, Avey Corrieu, Riannon-Corby, Cala, David Krasnow, Gauphin and Putubuele, Louis Mitchell, Michelle Moses, and Stephen Valentino, with help from Alison McAdam, Mengfei Chen, and Emily Mann. With additional help from Isaac Jones and Josh Swartz. The New Yorker Radio Hour is supported in part by the Cherina Endowment Fund.