The Ultimate Human with Gary Brecka - 158. Exposing the $5B Coffee Creamer Lie - What’s REALLY in Your Cup?
Episode Date: April 17, 2025That coffee creamer you’re pouring every morning? It’s a metabolic wrecking ball, and I’m going to tell you exactly why. Your morning routine starts with liquid sugar, carrageenan, rapeseed oil,... and artificial dyes. This $5 billion industry has masterfully disguised itself as a “health product.” You don’t need to give up coffee, just check the food labels, and upgrade your creamer with natural ingredients. You’ll feel a massive difference in energy, focus, and gut health! Join the Ultimate Human VIP community and gain exclusive access to Gary Brecka's proven wellness protocols today!: https://bit.ly/4ai0Xwg Thank you to our partners: H2TABS - USE CODE “ULTIMATE10” FOR 10% OFF: https://bit.ly/4hMNdgg BODYHEALTH - USE CODE “ULTIMATE20” FOR 20% OFF: http://bit.ly/4e5IjsV BAJA GOLD - USE CODE "ULTIMATE10" FOR 10% OFF: https://bit.ly/3WSBqUa EIGHT SLEEP - SAVE $350 ON THE POD 4 ULTRA WITH CODE “GARY”: https://bit.ly/3WkLd6E COLD LIFE - THE ULTIMATE HUMAN PLUNGE: https://bit.ly/4eULUKp WHOOP - GET 1 FREE MONTH WHEN YOU JOIN!: https://bit.ly/3VQ0nzW MASA CHIPS - GET 20% OFF YOUR FIRST $50+ ORDER: https://bit.ly/40LVY4y VANDY - USE CODE “ULTIMATE20” FOR 20% OFF: https://bit.ly/49Qr7WE AION - USE CODE “ULTIMATE10” FOR 10% OFF: https://bit.ly/4h6KHAD HAPBEE - FEEL BETTER & PERFORM AT YOUR BEST: https://bit.ly/4a6glfo CARAWAY - USE CODE “ULTIMATE” FOR 10% OFF: https://bit.ly/3Q1VmkC HEALF - GET 10% OFF YOUR ORDER: https://bit.ly/41HJg6S BIOPTIMIZERS - USE CODE “ULTIMATE” FOR 10% OFF: https://bit.ly/4inFfd7 RHO NUTRITION - USE CODE “ULTIMATE15” FOR 15% OFF: https://bit.ly/44fFza0 Watch the “Ultimate Human Podcast” every Tuesday & Thursday at 9AM EST: YouTube: https://bit.ly/3RPQYX8 Podcasts: https://bit.ly/3RQftU0 Connect with Gary Brecka: Instagram: https://bit.ly/3RPpnFs TikTok: https://bit.ly/4coJ8fo X.com: https://bit.ly/3Opc8tf Facebook: https://bit.ly/464VA1H LinkedIn: https://bit.ly/4hH7Ri2 Website: https://bit.ly/4eLDbdU Merch: https://bit.ly/4aBpOM1 Newsletter: https://bit.ly/47ejrws Ask Gary: https://bit.ly/3PEAJuG Timestamps: 00:00 Intro 01:15 The $5B Global Coffee Creamer Industry 02:32 What’s Inside Your Coffee Creamer 04:48 Metabolic Systems 05:56 Neurological Issues with Fake Coffee Creamer Consumption 06:55 Rising Obesity Rates among the Younger Generation 07:30 Upgrading Your Creamer 08:48 Checking the Food Labels The Ultimate Human with Gary Brecka Podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing or other professional health care services, including the giving of medical advice, and no doctor/patient relationship is formed. The use of information on this podcast or materials linked from this podcast is at the user’s own risk. The Content of this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice for any medical condition they may have and should seek the assistance of their health care professionals for any such conditions. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Maybe you've upgraded your beans.
Maybe you're using organic.
Maybe you're grinding your coffee fresh.
But then you pour in your creamer.
And what you may not realize is that one little splash,
it's a metabolic wrecking ball.
It's the most damaging thing in your entire morning routine.
This isn't just about coffee.
It's about waking up to what you're putting in your body.
Because your body's not a science experiment.
Let's start thinking of our body like a temple.
Coffee creamer has become a $5 billion global industry.
How?
By disguising itself as dairy.
But it's not dairy.
In fact, most non-dairy creamers have absolutely nothing
to do with milk.
They're emulsified seed oils mixed with sugar stabilizers,
lab-made flavoring agents, and gut-disrupting emulsifiers.
And the worst part? It's being sold to you as a health product.
These fake creamers alter dopamine secret.
The sugar plus the fat plus the synthetic flavor combo
lights up your brain's reward system, just like junk food does.
That means more cravings, more crashes, less clarity.
And over time, this affects mood regulation and mental resilience.
What's actually in these bottles?
Let's start with...
If you're watching or listening to this episode,
there's a pretty good chance you drink coffee.
What if I told you in your morning routine you're starting off with something like liquid sugar, carrageans, rapeseed oil, or
dipotassium phosphate? Well, you might not think that you're drinking it, but you are. Today we're
going to go down the road of everything coffee creamer because we are putting so many things
in our coffee that are harming our cellular biology. It's the fuel that gets our engines running
and like many people trying to get healthier, maybe you've upgraded your beans.
Maybe you're using organic, maybe you're grinding your coffee fresh, but then you
pour in your creamer and what you may not realize is that one little splash.
It's a metabolic wrecking ball.
It's the most damaging thing in your entire morning routine because the
average coffee creamer is not even food. It's a chemistry
experiment of synthetic flavorings, blood sugar bombs,
seed oils and gut disrupting emulsifiers. And the worst part
is being sold to you as a health product. So today we're pulling
back the curtain. I'm going to walk you through what's really
inside the most popular creamers and we'll talk the science,
we'll talk gut health, blood sugar, mood cravings,
and even kids.
And then I'll show you what to use instead.
This is a deep dive, trust me,
it's gonna change the way you start your day.
Let's start with the big picture.
Coffee creamer has become a $5 billion global industry.
How?
By disguising itself as dairy, but it's not dairy.
In fact, most non-dairy creamers
have absolutely nothing to do with milk.
There are emulsified seed oils mixed with sugar, stabilizers,
and lab-made flavoring agents.
Some even have synthetic vitamins thrown in just so the label can say fortified.
This didn't happen by accident.
This happened by design.
Back in the 1960s, the war on fat began. Saturated
fat and cholesterol were wrongfully blamed for heart disease. So companies
like Nestle and Dannon saw an opening. They launched non-dairy creamers filled
with hydrogenated oils and corn syrup solids and they marketed these as heart
healthy and they were modern. They were cheaper to produce, had a really long
shelf life, and were made in labs not on dairy farms. When the science finally
caught up and trans fats were outdated as dangerous, the creamer companies just
pivoted again. They went vegan. They went plant-based. They switched to sunflower
oil, canola oil, and oat milks. And they leaned hard into branding, clean fonts,
calming colors, and buzzwords like
gluten-free, cholesterol-free, and no artificial flavors, even when the last one was a lie.
So let's break it down.
What's actually in these bottles?
Let's start with Coffee Mate French Vanilla, one of the top sellers in the country.
Here's what's in it.
Corn syrup solids, hydrogenated vegetable oil, mono-endiglycerides, sodium caseinate,
kerogen, artificial flavors, and cellulose gum.
That's not food.
That's an inflammatory bomb.
Corn syrup solids spike your blood sugar worse than glucose.
They actually cause a rise in insulin
faster than straight blood glucose.
The glycemic index is 130 130 and that is a metabolic disaster.
Hydrogenated oils are trans fats, still present in trace amounts. These fats damage arterial
walls, disrupt mitochondrial function, and increase the risk of heart disease.
Then there's kerogen, a very common thickener, and it's been linked in multiple studies
to gut lining inflammation, IBS-like symptoms and insulin resistance. According to the NIH, kirigien can exacerbate intestinal
permeability which can trigger autoimmune issues in vulnerable people and is the definition
of leaky gut. And then you have artificial flavors, which are proprietary chemical blends.
The FDA allows these formulas to be hidden from consumers, meaning you have no idea what's actually in them. Now let's look at Silk Oat Creamer. This one's
marketed as a clean, vegan, and heart-healthy. Sounds great until you
realize the oats are loaded with maltose, a sugar that spikes glucose even faster
than table sugar. Combine that with cane sugar and sunflower oil and you've got a
triple threat. Blood sugar instability, oxidative stress from seed oils, and gut disruption from galling gum.
What about Califa Farms Almond Creamer? Looks sleek, minimalist, non-GMO, but it's made with
sunflower oil, guar gum, locust bean gum, and natural flavors. All emulsifiers, all additives and all gut irritants. A recent
review in Frontiers and Nutrition showed that these kinds of emulsifiers thin the mucus lining
of your gut, disrupting your gut microbiome and can actually trigger systemic inflammation.
Even the clean ones like nut pods, they still contain gel and gum, sunflower lecithin and
natural flavors. Better?
Maybe.
Clean?
Not really.
So what's the big deal?
Let me break it down across four systems.
Metabolic systems.
These creamers drive blood sugar spikes.
Whether it's oat milk, cane sugar, or corn syrup solids,
the result is the same elevated glucose
and insulin overproduction.
This is what leads to fat storage, crashes,
and even cravings. Over time, this contributes to insulin resistance. This is the precursor to type
2 diabetes and metabolic syndrome. And then if we look at gut health, emulsifiers like carragean,
gelling gum, and mono and diglycerides disrupt the gut lining. They thin this mucus barrier and they
allow pathogens to enter the bloodstream directly. This is called leaky gut and it can lead to food intolerances,
brain fog, joint pain, even autoimmune diseases.
And then if we look at our hormonal disruption, seed oils are high in something called linoleic
acid, an omega-6 fatty acid that oxidizes rapidly. This interferes with cell signaling,
reduces testosterone production, and blunts thyroid hormone output. Studies in
endocrinology show a direct correlation between high linoleic intake and low
androgen levels in men. And then if we look at the neurological issues, these
fake creamers alter dopamine signaling. The sugar plus the fat plus the synthetic
flavor combo lights up your brain's reward system just like junk food does.
That means more cravings more crashes less clarity. And over
time, this affects mood regulation and mental
resilience. This isn't happening by accident guys. This is an
engineered addiction. Companies create what's called a bliss
point, a precise ratio between sugar, fat and mouth
feel that triggers dopamine and makes you feel good temporarily.
Then it leaves you needing more.
They use lab formulated flavorings to override your body's natural satiety signals.
They also use tiny serving sizes like one tablespoon on the label to under report the
sugar and fat, but no one's using just one tablespoon.
You're pouring three to five tablespoons
into a cup of coffee, maybe even more.
That turns five grams of sugar into 20 grams
before you even start breakfast.
So here's where it gets truly disturbing.
We're often giving this stuff to our kids.
Pumpkin spice creamers, for example,
flavored oat milk lattes, fun vanilla flavored almond drinks.
The next generation is being
conditioned to consume emulsified oils and synthetic sweeteners before they even hit
puberty. According to the Journal of Pediatric Obesity, kids today are consuming five times
more omega-6 linoleic acid than kids just 30 years ago. You combine that with sugar and
emulsifiers and we've got an epidemic of childhood metabolic
dysfunction and no one's talking about it. You didn't need to give up coffee, you just needed
to upgrade your creamer. Here's what I recommend. If you can, start with raw milk. It contains natural
enzymes, lactase, and even probiotics. It's rich in fat soluble vitamins like A, D, and vitamin K2
which actually support immune function and hormone balance.
I also use coconut creamers.
You can actually buy organic Thai coconut creamer
right in your grocery store.
It's inexpensive.
And if you like that creamy mouth feel in your coffee,
try an organic coconut creamer.
Add a touch of raw honey, not pasteurized, not filtered.
Raw honey contains antibacterial compounds, antioxidants,
and it doesn't spike insulin the way that sugar does. If you can tolerate dairy, go with grass-fed
heavy cream and pure maple syrup. Heavy cream provides clean saturated fat, which stabilizes
blood sugar, and maple syrup has compounds like quebacol, which are anti-inflammatory and loaded
with minerals. Or keep it simple, black coffee and cinnamon improves insulin sensitivity and reduces your post-meal
glucose spikes. Want a pre-made solution? I use the Alkamine Norotropic Creamer. Salted caramel
or vanilla are my favorite. There's no seed oils, no sugar, just functional fats, norotropics,
and adaptogens to fuel your body. So here's my challenge to you. Tomorrow morning, flip the bottle, read the label.
Ask yourself, would I eat these ingredients off of a spoon?
If not, stop drinking them guys.
Your body's not a science experiment.
Your metabolism, your gut, your brain, your hormones,
these are sacred.
Let's protect them.
Let's start thinking of our body like a temple.
Start your day with real fuel.
Start your day like an ultimate human
because this isn't just about coffee.
It's about waking up to what you're putting in your body.
And once you know, you can't unknow.
I'm Gary Bracca.
And if you'd love to know what my wife and I do
every morning to start our day,
how we hydrate, mineralize, what we put in our coffees,
what supplements we take,
head over to theultimatehuman.com forward slash VIP,
sign up to be one of my VIPs,
and we can do live Q and A's
where I answer all of your questions,
do private podcasts, and even give discounts
to all of my members on all of the products that we use.
And that's just science.