You're Dead to Me - American War of Independence: Fourth of July Special
Episode Date: July 4, 2025Greg Jenner is joined in the eighteenth century by Professor Frank Cogliano and comedian and actor Patton Oswalt for a special Fourth of July episode all about the American War of Independence. Also k...nown as the American Revolutionary War, 2025 marks 250 years since the start of the conflict in 1775, when the first battles between the British army and the colonial resistance were fought at Lexington and Concord. But what caused Britain’s North American colonies to rebel against the king and government in London? At what point did they start to see themselves as American and not British? And how did a colonial militia take on an imperial superpower? This episode charts the growing rift between Britain and its American colonists, taking in famous events like the Boston Massacre, the Boston Tea Party and the calling of the first Continental Congress, all the way through to the Declaration of Independence and the course of the revolutionary war itself. We learn how America fought to free itself from the shackles of British rule, and meet some well-known names from history, including Thomas Jefferson, Ben Franklin and George Washington. And we also ask whose freedom was being fought for, and who – such as Black and Indigenous Americans – got left behind. If you’re a fan of fearless freedom fighters, political wrangling and stunning military victories, you’ll love our episode on the American War of Independence.If you want more American political history, listen to our episode on Becoming America, or episodes on abolitionists Frederick Douglass and Sojourner Truth. And for more independence movements, check out our episode on Simón Bolívar.You’re Dead To Me is the comedy podcast that takes history seriously. Every episode, Greg Jenner brings together the best names in history and comedy to learn and laugh about the past.Hosted by: Greg Jenner Research by: Charlotte Emily Edgeshaw Written by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow, Emma Nagouse, and Greg Jenner Produced by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow and Greg Jenner Audio Producer: Steve Hankey Production Coordinator: Ben Hollands Senior Producer: Emma Nagouse Executive Editor: Philip Sellars
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Ever wondered what you would do if you found yourself lost in the wild?
In the desert, the jungle, or the mountains?
Would you make the right choices to stay alive?
Introducing Real Survival Stories, the new podcast from Noiza.
Each week we'll bring you astonishing tales of ordinary people thrust into extraordinary
situations.
How the heck am I going to get out of here?
Am I going to be a pile of bones in the Australian outback or am I going to make it out? Hello, Greg here. Welcome to a special 4th July episode of You're Dead to Me to mark
250 years since the start of the American War of Independence in 1775. This is a special 4th of July episode of You're Dead to Me to mark 250 years since the start of the American War of Independence in 1775.
This is a special one-off. The series will start properly in a few weeks on the 8th of August.
But remember, if you're in the UK, you'll find episodes available 28 days earlier than any other app if you listen on BBC Sounds.
Enjoy the show!
Hello and welcome to You're Dead to Me, the BBC Radio 4 comedy podcast that takes history
seriously. My name is Greg Jenner. I'm a public historian, author and broadcaster. And today
we are chucking our tea in the harbour and charging back to the 18th century for a very
special 250th anniversary episode about the American War of Independence slash American
Revolution, whatever you call it. And to help our cause, we have two fearsome freedom fighters.
In History Corner, he's a professor of American history
at the University of Edinburgh,
where his research focuses on revolutionary
and early national America.
Maybe you've read one of his wonderful books,
including A Revolutionary Friendship,
Washington, Jefferson, and the American Republic.
It's Professor Frank Cogliano.
Welcome, Frank.
Thank you very much, Greg.
I'm thrilled to be here.
Delighted to have you here.
And in Comedy Corner.
He is an Emmy and Grammy award-winning comedian and actor.
You'll know him from many of my favourite sitcoms including
Bojack Horseman, AP Bio, Parks and Recreation,
Feep, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, The Goldbergs, The King of Queens,
what an amazing CV list.
His amazing film career has put him in the Marvel Universe,
the Zoolander Zooniverse, the Ghostbusters Ghouliverse
and the Pixar Tooniverse.
He is Remy the Rat himself from Pixar's Ratatouille.
It's the wonderful Patton Oswalt. Welcome Patton.
Thank you Greg. I'm looking forward to winning some big prizes today.
So happy to have you here. I'm a big fan.
But also you've played historians in things.
You've played a history professor in 22 Jump Street.
Oh, that's right. I did.
Yeah, you did.
Wow.
And also famously as a filibustering history buff in Parks and Rec, you literally changed
Star Wars canon.
I affected Star Wars canon, yes.
A thing that I riffed on Parks and Rec where I pitched the next Star Wars sequels, they
used it as the template for the opening shot of the series Book of Boba Fett.
It felt very gratifying.
I also believe you are named after General Patton.
I was, yes, I was named after George S. Patton.
My dad was a Marine, had high hopes, I guess.
And glad to be here today on this podcast.
I'm sure he's very proud.
If you've played a historian and you are the son of a proud
military man, do you know your fair bit about American
military history?
I mean, I like history a lot.
I read a lot of history.
I really enjoy Thomas Cahill's books.
I love hinged history moments.
That's something that I'm kind of obsessed with where, oh, something could have completely
gone the other way.
Sure.
Clive James is really deep into that kind of world of, I think his quote is like, history
is basically a record of the way things
didn't have to be.
I love that aspect of it.
So, yes, as much as I know about American history, and I'm speaking for a lot of Americans,
I did not learn about the Tulsa massacre until I saw it on the HBO show Watchmen, which I
think a lot of Americans didn't know about.
There's also in the new movie Sinners, Ryan Coogler's Sinners, there's a whole Asian diaspora that ended up in the
American South that we only learned about when we watched this sexy Rhythm
and Blues vampire movie. So that's how a lot of American history ends up getting
taught. You know there's worse ways in the pop culture movies. As long as it still gets
through. Exactly, exactly. All right so I feel like you probably a fair bit, but we'll be testing you today to see what's
stuck and what else we can teach you. So, what do you know?
This is the So What Do You Know? This is where I guess what you, our lovely listener, might know
about today's subject. And surely everyone knows that July 4 4th 1776 was Independence Day in America
or was it? Hence the episode. There's no shortage of pop culture reminders from the truly terrible
Mel Gibson film The Patriot to the truly incredible Hamilton musical by Lin-Manuel Miranda.
Or for slightly subtler references you've got Nick Cage in National Treasure featuring a treasure map
on the back of the Declaration of Independence or Will Smith nuking an alien spacecraft on the 4th of July in Independence Day.
Like I said, subtle.
But why did American colonists rebel against Britain?
How did they defeat an imperial superpower?
And can we spill the tea on why Bostonians spilled the tea?
Let's find out.
Patton, let's test your knowledge.
Oh God.
Did you, by the way, we're both Americans, did you bring us here to apologize or for
revolting?
It is a little weird you brought two Americans in for this.
Well, as Frank likes to point out, he's lived in Scotland for how many years?
32 years.
Oh, you're exempt.
All right, Padme, let's test your knowledge. How many British American colonies were there
in British America prior to the Revolution?
13? That's a good canonical answer, and that is the answer I would have given, but.
But?
Okay, the professor's gonna say, well, well actually.
You can't see it but he's pushing his glasses back up his nose before he speaks.
That's the classic, that's like a samurai bringing his sword out when the professor
pushes his glasses back, get ready bloods gonna get spilled
Well, actually Patton
There were 26 colonies in British North America and the Caribbean. Oh
This is something that we as Americans are not usually taught. I certainly was so if I may Greg, please
So what happened was the English and I'm using English deliberately in this context,
apologies to our Scottish listeners. During the 17th century, the English established colonies,
the colonies we know of on the eastern seaboard of North America. But under the Stuarts, they also
established colonies elsewhere in North America and importantly in the Caribbean. And by the mid
18th century, when Britain emerges victorious from the Seven Years War,
it's got 26 colonies. So there are the 13 that rebel and just for our listeners,
we'll see if I can name them, right? Yeah, go for it. New Hampshire,
Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland,
New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia.
He's done it.
So we have the 13 that rebelled that become the United States, but there were other colonies,
East and West Florida, Quebec, the Caribbean colonies.
So if they had 26 colonies here, they had a big stake in keeping this place. This meant more than just 13
States rebelling this was hey, we've got money in this area a lot of money
I'm gonna get one thing that I think frequently is not appreciated in the United States is the big money colonies were the ones in the Caribbean
Where of course slave-based agriculture was being practiced and they're raising sugar in particular
But that's that's the engine of the British economy in the 18th century.
You mean the crab economy in Maryland wasn't, the whole world wasn't hinging on that?
Shocking, I know.
Damn.
Okay, so we've got 26 colonies, 13 of them on the eastern seaboard of the states.
How do they work as colonies? What's the governance?
I mean, they're largely self-governing. They've kind of grown, developed under their own devices
for much of the period, the first hundred years after their settlement. And so each
of them has its own assembly, for example, which they see as equivalent to parliament.
They've achieved a degree of autonomy as a result of this. And when Britain wins the
Seven Years War, what Americans will call the French and Indian War, Britain emerges victorious there.
They have to govern this big space,
but they're pushing up against people
who've developed their own ways of thinking
and their own ways of doing things.
They're pretty used to governing themselves.
In Virginia, for example, there's an assembly,
the House of Burgesses, but in Virginia,
there's a large degree of inequality in society.
The great planters dominate the assembly, for example.
So there are differences in practice in the different colonies, but broadly speaking,
they share this culture, which they believe they got from Britain. They talk about the
rights of Englishmen all the time, and they're not wrong about that, but they talk about,
we've got the rights of Englishmen. When we're governing ourselves, that's because we're
English or we're British.
And they've won the Seven Years' War, which, I mean, you could have been speaking French
pattern. we're English or we're British. And they've won the Seven Years War. I mean, you could have been speaking French, Patton.
Exactly.
Well, kill them all.
That had happened because I can barely speak English.
Yeah, I mean, it's the beloved, handsome, wise King George III,
defender of the colonies, the proud defender
of the American people.
Why are you laughing?
The stable, chill George III.
It's funny, in Britain that's sort of how we know him.
Later on he's the mad king, but 20 years after the war.
So at this time he is kind of a chill, he likes farming.
He's farmer George.
Farmer George.
The enlightened king.
No kidding.
When did he start going crazy?
Very late 1790s, early 1800s, so long after the war.
Obvious question, Frank, how does it go so wrong for King George?
Because we've heard that Britain has won this seven-year war, this very expensive war, and everything is rosy.
It's a vanquished France finally, seemingly forever. We'll see.
They've driven the French out of North America. They have control over all of Eastern North America nominally.
This is a great moment of triumph.
You mentioned Hamilton a few minutes ago, the musical, not the individual.
As Lin-Manuel Miranda wrote, winning is easy, governing is hard.
So Britain now has all this territory to govern.
It's got these fractious colonists to the east of the Appalachian mountains
who are used to doing their own thing.
But it also has this massive debt.
It has a huge public debt as a result of the
war, and it's looking to pay down that debt. Here's a good factoid for you. The average
person in Britain pays 26 shillings per year in taxes. The average person in Massachusetts
pays one. So-
Well. Pay up, Patton. You owe it.
The crown says- Well. Pay up, Patton. You owe us. So the Crown says...
Oh really, hang on.
Let me get my...
Do you take Zell?
Oh my God.
The government says, okay, you need to pay.
You've benefited from this conflict.
You ought to pay for your own defense.
And what did we say?
How did we react to that?
Well Patton, you may know that Americans love to pay taxes.
Oh my God!
Get out of my way, let me mail this check in.
So what the British did was they instituted various governments, instituted a variety
of taxes.
The most famous, the one we did learn about in school, the Stamp Act, of course, in 1765
is the most infamous.
But prior to that, Americans had been paying customs duties. Dare I say tariffs.
I was waiting for that. Go ahead.
And they'd been paying customs duties historically, and they recognized and accepted the customs
duties were an acceptable thing for parliament to levy on them because it was about regulating
trade, not raising revenue. So there's a history there. There was something called the Sugar
Act, for example, adopted in 1763, which actually lowered the tax on sugar.
Oh. But Britain decided to collect the tax rather than ignore it as an admin doing. And so they say you'll pay less, but you'll actually pay it.
So they institute a bunch of taxes.
Hang on. You can have a higher tax that we're not going to bother with, or we'll lower. But when it once it's lowered, we're gonna make sure
That's it. Exactly. You've got it. Wow
I'm sure your listeners are really interested in the in the in the details of British tax policy the 18th century So it there was a 1733 sugar act Wow that levied a sugar duty that was high and nobody paid it
They all just ignored it and now for everyone listening on the treadmill right now, you can get it up to six miles an hour.
This is where you're going to really feel the burn.
We start talking about the British tax system
on American sugar, so let's crank those treadmills.
I know that you're, come on, we got you,
we're behind you, man, go ahead.
Okay, all right.
Anyway, there are customs duties,
but they also adopt this thing called the Stamp Act in 1765, and
that's unprecedented because it's a direct tax on Americans in their colonies.
By making them use stationery imported from London.
Yeah, anything.
If you need a will, if you need a deed, it all has to be on specially stamped paper.
If you buy a newspaper.
People in Massachusetts say, we pay taxes that are levied by our government.
We're represented in that government.
That's the way the system works. If you're paying 26 times more than we are, you're paying too much tax.
And so their position is not necessarily just greed. It's actually there is kind of intellectual consistency there.
And there's also the Quartering Act which allows colonial authorities to be forced to house British soldiers in public houses, even people's homes.
Yes, so there's a pretty large British army in North America at the war's end that Americans are being taxed to maintain,
but also those soldiers need to be quartered. And under the quartering act, they can be put in private homes.
Again, this isn't unusual in 18th century Britain.
No.
So to some extent, these people who've been claiming we're British are being told, well, if you're British, this is what being British is. That was a normal
thing in Britain. What was done back home. Have a soldier come. Yeah, come stay in your
house. Yeah. And that really led to the boom in romance novels. The handsome young soldier
and then the young daughter just fetching the water and then who knows where it leads,
you know? We got to keep that industry going.
We haven't mentioned the Townsend Acts. They are the one, they're the official parliamentary
acts which allow for the taxation of the colonists, right?
Yes. So what happens is there's widespread resistance to the Stamp Act in 1765. Parliament
repeals it in 1766, but adopts something called the Declaratory Act in 1766, which is basically
a parent saying, okay, I'm giving in to you, but next time you have to do what I say, because the Declaratory Act says...
Which always works. Always works.
They say, we're repealing the Stamp Act, but the Declaratory Act says, but we have the authority
to tax you in all cases whatsoever. And the following year they adopt the Townsend duties.
The Townsend duties are more import duties, more tariffs.
And they say, Parliament's view is, okay, hang on. You said you don't like direct taxes,
but you have been paying customs duties. Now you'll pay these customs duties. Americans
say, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Customs duties were okay when they were about channeling
trade. But if you're doing this to raise revenue, that's a sneaky backdoor way to tax us directly.
We're not having it. I don't know whether either of you are parents of teenagers.
Actually, I am.
I know exactly what they're doing right now.
Oh my god.
So I just love that so much of history
is just the same dynamic as a parent dealing with it.
Psychologically, OK, if I say they can't do this,
they'll go out of their way to do it.
So what I should say is and like history hinges on that.
It's just George III going, how do I parent my unruly teenager?
They want to stay out all night and wear black.
Yeah.
These harsh acts as the American soul, as the colonists saw them,
they're not Americans yet, right?
So I shouldn't use that word.
Did they call themselves Americans at this point or they were just colonists?
Columnists?
Oh, please edit that out. Oh my god.
They're actually bloggers.
They're often called British Americans or Americans.
American is somewhat used and we're going to get to this I think.
Anyway.
So Frank, these harsh parliamentary acts, they lead to violence right?
Because we've got the Boston Massacre in 1770 when British troops are actually
firing on people.
Yes. So what happened was the resistance to these taxes, beginning with the Stamp
Act and then through the towns and duties, which you mentioned, Greg, is
mainly centered in the port towns because those are the only cities in the
colonies. So Boston, New York, Newport, Richmond, Philadelphia.
And that's where the trade is. Yeah. Charleston, et cetera. And that's also where there are
crowds and sailors who can be mobilized, things like that. And there are groups that form
called the Sons of Liberty that enforce boycotts and resistance to these taxes. Unsurprisingly,
for any listeners who may be familiar with the cultural geography of America,
apparently, Pat, and I'm glad you're sitting down, people in Boston can be difficult.
Wait!
What?
We're going to take a break.
We'll be right back.
Wait, I'm sorry.
Laid back, beaned down is...
All right.
So the resistance was centered in Boston.
It wasn't only in Boston, but it was most kind of virulent in Boston.
And as a result, the British sent troops to Boston in 1768, Redcoat troops.
Now again, those troops previously had been on the frontier.
And when Britain said, we want to tax you to pay for your own defense, some people said,
yeah, that makes sense.
Once the troops are on American streets,
there to enforce the taxes, American colonists
say, you're not here to protect us.
You're here to take our liberties away.
And there's a lot of tension in Boston
between civilians in Boston, the Sons of Liberty in Boston,
and these British troops who are quartered amongst them,
as you mentioned.
There are a series of incidents that take place, the most
prominent of which occurs on March 5, 1770, an incident known as the Boston Massacre.
Eight civilians are shot, five of whom die.
There was a crowd of up to 300 people who were harassing British soldiers, and they
were throwing snowballs, ice balls, bricks, and so on at the soldiers.
Yeah, bricks.
And weirdly enough, batteries.
They were winging batteries, which history has yet to explain how they
had de-cell batteries to throw, but they had them.
By the way, I also heard they were throwing oyster shells.
Yes.
Yeah. A very Bostonian thing to do.
Oyster shells.
Yeah, with some shells over this guy's head.
And so this incident really escalates things. It should be said though, Greg, and I'm sure you probably know this,
the British Army shoots civilians in Britain all the time in the 18th century.
This isn't even a terribly big massacre.
It's standard behaviour for the British Army.
Because there is no police, so they're used for crowd control in 18th century Britain.
So this is a terrible incident, but it's not actually that unusual.
And the Sons of Liberty, they grab one of the commissioners and they kind of tar and feather him,
which sort of sounds cutesy until you realise what it is. It's horrific.
Yeah, it is horrific, right?
It is torture. I mean, you usually get beaten up and stripped before you're tarred and feathered.
They pour hot tar on you and then cover you with feathers.
Yeah, so it's horrific burns.
It is horrific. If you've ever seen the John Adams miniseries, there's a very good scene,
it's a harrowing scene about somebody being tarred and feathered.
Yeah, and not just that, if you somehow survived it, which a lot of people don't even survive
the initial tarring because of the pain, taking the tar off, it is brutal.
Yeah, that's right.
It's coming off, right?
Yeah.
Horrible stuff.
There was a waterboarding as well with pouring tea down his nose and stuff.
I mean, it's really, really horrible stuff.
We get the Boston Tea Party after that, which again, sounds like a sort of genteel Jane Austen thing,
the Boston Tea Party,
but it's a paramilitary organization, this Sons of Liberty.
They are certainly a political movement
that is willing to use force or threaten to use force,
and those threats are credible
because they've done it enough.
Yeah. In the Boston massacre,
you have them, you know, they're,
not that I'm justifying them being shot, but they're throwing stuff, they're attacking people, they're targeting and threatening
people.
The Boston Tea Party, was it just as aggressive or was it more a clandestine operation to
throw the tea in the heart?
Like what was the feeling of that one?
That's a good question.
It's much more controlled.
So the background of this is parliament adopts something called the Tea Act, which is meant
to help the British East India Tea Company, which has huge interest in parliament, a little
corruption there.
And this calls attention to people to taxation again.
And again, this tea is sent to Boston, among other port cities.
It also goes to New York, Philadelphia, and Charleston.
But in Boston, they resort to this protest.
It's not like the massacre and it's not unrestrained violence.
Instead, it's much more controlled.
So a group of about 60 Sons of Liberty, rather crudely disguised as indigenous Americans.
They board the T-ships.
There are three of them in Boston Harbor.
They destroy 342 chests of tea, but they clean up after themselves.
Wait, they do?
They do.
They also, they make sure that nobody's meant to pilfer anything else off these cargo ships
or off the wharf.
So it's meant to be a controlled demonstration to show that there are limits to resistance.
Equally, right after the Boston Massacre, the British soldiers who shot into the crowd
were tried in Boston and most of them were acquitted.
That was carried out to show that the rule of law actually still persisted.
And who defended them?
John Adams.
John Adams.
There you go.
So the point was with the Tea Party, there's a degree of restraint and control about this.
The tax tea is the target.
Now 342 chests of tea,
it's worth tens of thousands of pounds. Millions of money. Probably millions today. So it's a
pretty significant attack on private property. Yeah and they're dumping it,
they're not taking it home and stealing it. They're dumping it in the water. They
are dumping it in the water, although I was doing research many many years ago
and there was a guy who was accused of filling his pockets with tea. Oh so there
were some, they weren't doing the whole Joker thing of burning my
half of the money.
There were some people that were taking it home.
You know, loose leaf tea is very fashionable.
Wear it as a hat.
Yeah, my goodness.
Okay, so what does the King's government do?
What does George III do?
You know, you've got the tea protest.
Is he sitting and stewing?
Is he letting rebellion brew?
Is he stirring the pot until things boil over?
Tea pun, tea pun, tea pun.
What is he doing?
Two things.
The first thing, before I answer your question, is to say, this is a, you mentioned you like
hinge points in history, Patton.
This is a hinge point.
This is the moment America became a coffee drinking country and not a tea drinking country.
Really?
Well, this is my thesis.
Okay.
Well, let's hear it.
I want to know the origin of my addiction.
Which is to say, tea is horrible in America.
Hey, come on now.
The tea in America is terrible.
I am an American, I go to America all the time, I bring my own tea bags with me.
If you order tea in America...
No, when I'm in America, I drink PG Tips.
Oh, I have to drink...
But if you order it, you either get tepid water in the bag next to it, or you get something
the temperature of the core of the sun.
Yes.
They don't know what they're doing.
They don't know what they're doing.
I think it goes back to the Tea Party.
I think the turn to coffee happened then.
This is the ancient history.
And that's to do your actual question.
Okay.
We have an episode on the history of coffee if you want to know more.
But yes, back to my question, Frank.
Come on.
Parliament penalizes the colonies.
The king and his government want to take a hard line.
They adopt a series of acts called the Coercive Acts to punish Boston.
The Coercive Act or Intolerable Act, right?
Yeah.
And is that the official name of them?
No, no, no. Each of the acts has its own name.
So we've laid them...
Massachusetts Government Act.
So they call them the Coercive Acts or the Intolerable Acts.
Good branding.
Yeah, the governor of Massachusetts is replaced with the military governor.
The port of Boston's closed until the T's paid for, and so on.
There are a series of acts intended to punish Boston and also to separate Massachusetts
from the other colonies.
Okay.
Oh, like to make the other colonies go like we don't want anything to do with them?
Yeah.
Oh, okay.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So divide and conquer.
Divide and conquer, the British way.
That then leads to the outraged colonists forming the first Continental Congress, headed up
by the first president in American history, a great man from Virginia, such as yourself,
and his name is?
Hang on, George Hanson?
No.
Not George Washington?
No.
No.
I know that George Washington, who?
What's his name?
Frank?
Peyton Randolph.
Peyton Randolph?
What?
Who? Wow, wait a minute, go right ahead, please. What's his name? Frank? Peyton Randolph. Peyton Randolph! What?
Who?
Wow, wait a minute.
Go right ahead, please.
I've literally never heard this name.
I've heard the name George Hanson.
I've never heard Peyton Randolph.
I don't have a lot to give you, Patton, except he's a very prominent political figure in
Virginia in the mid-1770s.
He's a lawyer.
He's a planter.
He's a big deal in Virginia, and he gets elected to preside
over this first Continental Congress.
So technically he's the first president.
Yes.
Wow.
Okay.
And what is the Congress?
We have a problem of nomenclature here because we say Congress and we think Congress.
And it's more to coming together of representatives from 12 of the 13 colonies, Georgia didn't
make it, to kind of decide on collective action in response to these.
So parliaments tried to separate Massachusetts from the others and they're saying, no, we're
all going to stand together.
What's their policy then?
What do they agree?
They agree on a number of things.
They agree that the individual colonies should start raising militias to prepare for a possible
war.
Right, okay, so that's a serious one.
That's very serious, but they're not providing any money for that.
They're just saying you should do this.
They say that the colonies... Stand back and stand by.
Yes, exactly.
The colonies should boycott British goods, so they're responding to the British closure
of the port of Boston by saying, we're not buying any British goods.
They say British and Irish goods is a little bit of a-
That's Hosh and I.
Seems a little bit unfair.
They want to stop paying British taxes and of course not obey the Coercive X.
And they adopted Declaration of Rights in October of 1774 which says
that they, that is the colonies, are entitled to life, liberty and property and
that they have never ceded to any foreign power or whatever a right to dispose of either without their consent.
So this is about no taxation without representation. Yeah. Life, liberty and property, which comes from John Locke,
where not quite to life, liberty and happiness yet. We'll get there. Yeah, property and property which comes from John Locke. We're not quite to life liberty and happiness yet
We'll get there. Yeah property is more important than happiness. Come on
I'm not happy without my property
But yeah, so so that's what the first there's a line there you said those seed to foreign power
Mmm pattern that to me starts to sound like they're looking at Britain as a foreign power rather than...
Well, maybe they're looking at Britain as a foreign power, but maybe, like you said earlier,
the way that Boston was renaming some of these, the coercive acts as the horrible, like,
well, if we can start to image manage this and make them seem like a foreign power, then we can get ourselves,
if we can start thinking of them as a they, we will be a we and a united we.
Maybe that was a part of the strategy?
You should lead a movement, that's great.
I really should.
Okay, so the Declaration calls Britain a foreign power, which is an interesting term, but the
raising of militia, or at least the idea of raising militia, feels like a more serious
one.
Are these newfangled Americans yet? Oh, that's the question, Greg.
You have 14 seconds to answer.
They can't decide.
They're looking both ways.
In 1774, Thomas Jefferson writes something called the Summary View of the Rights of British
America.
In that he says, we are just British people who happen to live here.
We are the same.
We have the rights of Englishmen.
We have all those rights.
Two years later, in 1776, the Declaration of Independence will say, nope, authored by Jefferson,
we are Americans, our rights are natural rights.
They come from God and nature is God.
So when did you get the split between colonists and loyalists?
When did that split happen?
It's kind of two parts.
When the war breaks out in the spring of 75, it starts because people have to start making
choices but really with the Declaration of Independence because it's's whether you either support independence or you don't.
Right, right.
And that's when, so in this moment...
So when there's a referendum really, doesn't it?
Yeah, exactly, right.
In this moment, they're still kind of British, kind of American, and trying to work out what
the boundary between the two is.
So the Americans are starting to stockpile weapons, they're starting to sort of drill
troops sort of quietly in the corner, but the British authorities obviously not terribly
keen on this, and so Parliament declares Massachusetts in rebellion, so particularly
one state in rebellion.
That tea party thing really stung them.
It did, I mean it's a lot of money they lost.
They just really dwelt on that.
I've seen Mary Poppins, the Bank of England, very upset about that.
So Thomas Gage is someone we need to introduce here, Frank. Very quickly, who's Thomas Gage?
He is the commander-in-chief of British forces in North America.
He's also been appointed as the military governor of Massachusetts under the Coercive Acts.
He's got an American wife, interestingly.
He is believed to understand Americans.
Taking our women.
Man.
And Gage is in charge and he's ordered by the government in early 1775 to do something
about Massachusetts.
And so he wants the, he's ordered in February to kind of crack down, Massachusetts is declared
in rebellion.
He's ordered to crack down on the leadership of the resistance there.
In April, he sends troops to Lexington and Concord to both seize munitions that the
patriot militia, so-called patriot militia are stockpiling and arrest the leaders of
the resistance in the colony.
And this is where Paul Revere supposedly says the British are coming, but he doesn't say
that, right?
No, because they're all British.
They're all British. We're British. Everyone's British.
He says the regulars are out.
That's not as good.
Doesn't work.
Okay, so tell us about Lexington and Concord because this is famously where the war begins,
but it's a tiny skirmish.
Yes, I mean we've just marked the 250th anniversary of this first fighting in the war, April 19th,
1775, and what happens is the British, Lexington and Concord are now suburbs of Boston.
They're about 15, 20 miles west of Boston.
They arrive in Lexington first, they're confronted by some militiamen on Lexington Green, and
there's a brief exchange of shots.
Nobody knows who fired the first shot.
Eight militiamen were killed, the rest ran off.
Then the British go on to Concord.
There's a fight at conquered bridge
that only lasts about three minutes.
There's a larger fight over the course of the rest of the day,
but the fighting at Lexington and Concord is relatively brief.
Nothing good comes out of the suburbs.
I've always said everything bad comes out of the suburbs.
So there you go.
So the shot heard around the world
is the famous line given to this shot.
We don't know who shot first, right?
We don't know which side shot first, but it's a small skirmish times two.
And we then get the Second Continental Congress, because the first one achieved some things,
but now the shots have been fired.
So what is the second?
It's starting to act like a government now.
The first one wasn't really a government.
It was sort of, hey, let's get together and coordinate our response.
The Second Continental Congress is acting like a government because there's a war on,
but again, still looking forwards and backwards at the same time because what they really are
saying, they're saying, King George, please intervene and stop this. They sent something
called the Olive Branch Petition. So 17,000 patriot militiamen are besieging the British in Boston.
The Continental Congress is raising an army, but they're also saying,
hey, we want to make up. Let's just go back to the way things were. So they're in this weird,
between April of 1775 and July of 1776, there's a kind of really weird moment where they're
waging war, but also appealing to the king to intervene and stop it.
And Peyton Randolph, he's had to resign. He's no longer president.
He's gone.
When do we get George Washington showing up then?
When's his...
He goes to the Second Continental Congress representing Virginia and he wears his uniform
to say, hey, I happen to be a soldier.
And they appoint him commander in chief of the army.
He doesn't become president, of course, until 17...
So he'd fought for Britain in the Seven Years' War.
He did fight for Britain.
He's an experienced British soldier who'd fought for the king against the French.
He didn't fight for the British in the sense that he fought for Virginia and he desperately
craved a British commission and they didn't give it to him.
Oh, and that's why.
So if George Washington had got his commission in the seven years before.
There's a hinge moment.
That's if they had just given him his commission, this might not have happened to them.
And his favorite hot beverage was hot chocolate.
Oh, well that's adorable.
That's even more insulting.
You get defeated by a guy you didn't give a commission to and he basically, his favorite
beverage is like your aunt makes you a nice little hot beverage and he wipes out your
army.
I also love hot chocolate, so I'm team George Washington for now.
There you go.
On the 6th of July, Congress issued the Declaration of Causes and Necessity for Taking Up Arms,
which is a really serious declaration.
And this episode... 1775, 16 July 1775.
She was the epitome of elegance.
She was the epitome of mystery, intrigue and beauty.
One of the 20th century's most amazing characters, a Hollywood sex symbol whose story you might
think you already know.
Hedy Lamarr, the film star, but there's another side
to her story. She was an inventor at heart. Her scientific contribution, no other star has been
able to match. We really should put her into the limelight she deserves. From the BBC World Service,
Untold Legends, Hedy Lamarr. Listen now wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
Listen now wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
Ever wondered what you would do if you found yourself lost in the wild? In the desert, the jungle, or the mountains, would you make the right choices to stay alive?
Introducing Real Survival Stories, the new podcast from Noiza.
Each week we'll bring you astonishing tales of ordinary people thrust into extraordinary situations.
How the heck am I going to get out of here? you astonishing tales of ordinary people thrust into extraordinary situations.
How the heck am I going to get out of here? Am I going to be a pile of bones in the Australian
Outback or am I going to make it out?
Real Survival Stories, available now wherever you get your shows.
So the Olive Branch petition has been offered by the Second Continental Congress to George
III and George III says... He says, absolutely not.
He doesn't even read it.
What?
Doesn't even read it.
Do you think he did that as a power move, as an insult, or why didn't he read it?
Professor Frank, give us a psychological reading.
Well, to accept it is to recognize the authority of Congress, which he doesn't.
Okay.
Now, I find it hard to believe he didn't actually read it,
because how could you reject it if you don't know what's in it?
Someone would have read it for him. Some lawyer would have read it and gone,
Sire, the Americans are here. But he refused to acknowledge it or to
acknowledge the authority of Congress, so he didn't accept it.
And he declares the proclamation rebellion? He declares them in rebellion in October of 1775.
And we get a
proper battle? Yes, we get the actual proper battle before that. In June of 75 is the Battle
of Bunker Hill. When the British try to break the siege of Boston, they win the battle but
take so many casualties, almost over a thousand casualties totaled more than 200 dead. It's
one of the bloodiest days of the war for them that one of their officers says well if we keep winning battles like this America is lost.
Wow. That's a big win day one.
Yeah, dark.
Yeah, a little bit.
That's dark. Was there a naval element to this? Was there any ship battles during that
or was it all on the ground?
Not quite yet. I mean the British used their naval advantage. Bunker Hill is in Charlestown,
Massachusetts which is again a kind of inner suburb of Boston now. People in Charlestown, Massachusetts, which is again, a kind of inner suburb of Boston now. People in Charlestown will be really offended by that. And the British are able
to maneuver around Boston Harbor to get a rag. Charlestown is a peninsula like Boston
was at that time. So they're using their naval advantage, but there aren't big naval battles
yet because the Americans don't have the capacity.
They haven't got a Navy, right?
No, not yet.
So at moments like this, Patton, we need a bit of common sense. By which I mean common sense.
Do you know it?
Was that Thomas Paine's pamphlet?
Yeah, it is.
Yeah, it is.
Yeah, very good.
Yay!
I know something!
Well done.
All right, yes.
What do you know about it?
Nothing.
Great.
Thank you for coming in.
All right, go right ahead.
Please, take it off my hands.
Thomas Paine is an English radical who emigrated to Philadelphia in 1774, so he's arrived relatively
late.
He has no time for the monarchy.
This is a good reminder that this is really a transatlantic radical movement.
The colonists have a lot of sympathy in Britain, and that's going to be a crucial factor.
And Paine kind of represents that.
He writes this pamphlet called Common Sense, which is published on January 10th, 1776,
that basically says, independence is the answer here.
Give up your loyalty to the crown.
The king's not going to be there for you.
A parent doesn't wage war on its children.
He can turn a phrase.
The guy can write it.
It sells 150,000 copies.
It's by far and away the biggest bestseller of the 18th century.
Probably. I've only in the movie version.
I never read that stuff.
And he makes an incredibly powerful case for independence.
And one of the things he says is he says,
don't worry about the future.
It's going to be because skeptics say, look,
we can't win the war.
And even if we do, what will happen to us?
It's a big bad world out there.
He says, memorably in common sense,
America will thrive as long as eating
is the custom in Europe.
We'll be able to export food, we'll be able, yeah, we'll be fine.
And coming from somebody English, this is a reassuring
and incredibly powerful message.
And so the Continental Congress appoints a committee
to draft the Declaration of Independence.
And do you know who's on that committee?
Jefferson, Hancock, Clymer, each colony is represented?
Is there 13 people on it or more?
Is there more?
No, no, no.
What?
Less.
There are five.
Five!
Who are the five?
Okay, Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, Roger Sherman, Robert Livingston.
Never heard of him.
Never heard of him.
Sherman's from Connecticut, Livingston's from New York, they're the two that always get
forgotten.
Yeah, like these poor guys, they've done so much.
They wrote one of the most important documents in history and everyone's like, who?
And like all committees, they give the work to the junior guy, which is Jefferson, and
he writes the most.
No way!
He's the most, he's the-
Although I heard, maybe I'm wrong about this, I heard that one of the reasons that they
didn't let Benjamin Franklin write it, they were afraid he would sneak a joke into it.
Well, because he's really funny, right? He is really funny, but they were afraid he was sneak a joke into it. Well, because he's really funny, right?
He is really funny, but they were afraid he was kind of a prankster.
Yeah, he's a satirest and everything.
Yeah, he was an edgelord back then, and they were like, oh, he's going to sneak a joke,
he'll hide the word fart in here somewhere.
He's the founding father of comedians.
Yeah.
He's your patron saint.
He is.
Thank you, Ben.
It's drafted, Jefferson presents it to Congress on 20th of June.
It's voted for on...
July 4th, 1776?
July 2nd?
Oh my god!
American education, folks.
I mean, I understand why you've said that, but John Adams famously says on July 2nd,
I am apt to believe that it will be celebrated by succeeding generations as the great anniversary
festival.
It ought to be solonised with pomp and parade, with shows and games and sports and guns and
bonfire and
illuminations from one end of the continent to the other from this time forward forevermore. He's basically saying July 2nd will forever be.
Boy, could he call it. Yeah. Yeah. Why do we think it's July 4th? Yeah, why do we? And was it July 4th?
Well, what happens on July 4th is they so they vote on independence on July 2nd.
Twelve colonies vote in favor of it, New York abstains.
Then they spend the next two days editing mainly Jefferson's draft.
Taking out the jokes.
Taking out the jokes and cutting 25% of the text, including a clause on the slave trade,
which is really interesting.
And then they formally adopt the document, the declaration itself, on the 4th of July.
So that is the date, but the vote was on the 2nd. Adams recognized that the vote was incredibly
important, thought, this is the day!
And New York comes along on the 2nd of August and goes, oh right.
Guess if you're all going.
Fine, whatever, we're in.
The colonies are abuzz with people exalting the cause of liberty. They've drafted a document,
they've signed it. America is an independent kingdom or not kingdom.
No, no, it's a republic.
It's a republic, right? But I have to ask, what about indigenous peoples? What we might
call Native Americans. What about free and enslaved black people? Are their liberties
mentioned at all? Is anyone thinking about them?
And are women mentioned?
Right. Excellent questions. The declaration, of course, says all men are created equal.
So there's gendered language there.
There's no doubt about that.
Those three groups, of course, constitute
the majority of the population by a considerable margin.
There are two things you need to bear in mind.
In 1776, the vast majority of people
who lived in North America were indigenous.
Right.
Yeah.
Mustn't ever forget that.
And in those seaboard colonies that are rebelling and declaring independence, 20% of the population
was enslaved.
So on one hand, we can say this is liberty for me and not for thee.
Yeah.
And that would seem to be a pretty accurate statement.
On the other, you asked if they're on anybody's mind.
In Jefferson's draft of the declaration, there's a long clause,
it's that section there where he's indicting George III, you did this, he did this, he did that,
he did this. The longest passage in that section is condemning George III for the slave trade.
Now as history, it's terrible because George III wasn't responsible for creating the Transatlantic
slave trade. But what's interesting about that passage is Jefferson talks about the
rights and liberties of a distant people. He's talking about the people who've been
victimized and enslaved in the transatlantic slave trade having rights and liberties, the
same rights and liberties British Americans are fighting for. Now that's cut out by Congress.
The question of what will happen to both indigenous people and enslaved people. The war calls into question
all the time because both sides seek to enlist the support, black and indigenous soldiers,
for example, and we have the kind of horrible paradox that enslaved people are fighting
each other for their liberty because both sides promise them liberty if they'll support
them. So it's a complicated
question.
And for women, do any of the states allow women to vote?
You know, New Jersey.
Really?
Which doesn't get a lot of credit.
Wow!
New Jersey is...
Hey, let them vote!
Fine, you know. What are you going to do? Let them vote.
In the aftermath of the revolution, New Jersey adopts a constitution that allows women who
can meet the property requirements to vote in the state to vote.
New Jersey women are the first women in America to vote.
Now the vote's taken away from them in the early 19th century, but there's a period of
about two decades when women vote in New Jersey.
Amazing.
Let's get back to the war, because I suppose we need to talk about George Washington a
little bit, I mean not loads.
I mean you'll know the story of the crossing of Delaware, because it's probably something
you learn at school right?
Yeah that was, and correct me if I'm wrong, that was a Christmas Eve crossing.
Christmas day I think.
Christmas day, yeah.
Because they're like, well they're going to take the day off so we can just go over there
and –
The British will get them on Boxing Day.
We'll get them on Boxing Day, yeah. But they were like, because they were, weren't
there rules to war, like there are certain days certain days, like in, what is it,
the life and death of Colonel Blimp?
Like war started midnight.
Yeah.
Weird old traditions that he's like,
well, we're just gonna flout those
because we're the rebels.
Yeah, they don't normally fight during the wintertime,
for example.
Armies in the 18th century.
Yeah, and crossing rivers in the ice must be pretty tough
as well, the snow.
But they're desperate because the war has not gone well
for them to that point.
The British have chased them out of New York, across New Jersey, and in late 1776, things
are looking bad for the Continental Army.
Yeah, and also they're fighting German troops.
So I'd like to point out this is basically the plot of Die Hard.
A proud American man who's not meant to be there shows up on Christmas Day to fight some
Germans and wins.
Oh my gosh!
That is, wow.
That's amazing.
George Washington is John McClane.
Did not think about that.
In a vest with a machine gun, ho, ho, ho.
Yippee-ki-yay, red coat.
Wow.
We get another big win almost a year later,
Battle of Saratoga, which is a huge one for Washington Army.
And this is a big win over John Burgoyne,
the British general. That's over John Burgoyne the British
general that's right Burgoyne invades the colonies from Montreal he's going
south from Montreal down the Hudson River Valley through modern Vermont
really knows Canada right yeah to New York he wants to cut off New England cut
off the head of the rebellion and that'll be that he's defeated by the
Continental Army not not by Washington, unfortunately. He has another general in command, Horatio Gates.
Washington is-
Horatio Gates, good name.
Nice name, very good name.
And Benedict Arnold is prominent
in that fighting for the Patriots.
But the point is Burgoyne-
Now what happened to him?
He's been loved.
Never heard from again.
The reason Saratoga's important is
it's the first really big victory that the colonists,
the rebels inflict on the British in almost a year.
And it shows the French that the rebels are credible.
There we go.
And I think we have to now bring in the Mucky de Lafayette.
Yes, Lafayette!
We've all seen Hamilton, but I was surprised to learn he's a teenager.
He's like super young.
He's very young.
18?
Yeah, 18.
This revolution attracts a lot of European flotsam and jetsam who just turn up.
Some of them are frauds and grifters, but others are idealists.
Frauds and grifters in American politics?
What?
Shocking, shocking.
And so there are all kinds of Europeans who attach themselves to both sides, but particularly
to the rebel side, because you can get an officer's commission
Lafayette's, you know, one of the youngest generals in the war by the time, you know when he's about 22 or three barely left puberty. Yes
Go into attack these ships over there. I'm just gonna shave for my first time
And he brings within French money he pays for a ship of full of supplies. However, because of the victory at Saratoga,
Benjamin Franklin, who's then American ambassador in Paris,
negotiates a formal treaty with France.
And in February of 1778, France recognizes the United States,
enters into a military alliance, and suddenly Britain's
in a lot of trouble.
And ironically, the massive debt incurred
by supporting America against Britain
will lead to the French Revolution. Oh, wow. So Lafayette also takes the heart in.
Yeah. Oh, good for him, man. Hinge moment, hinge moment. So a monarchist supporting a Republican
movement leads to a Republican movement in the country that supported it. There we go, classic.
There's also a German general who trains American troops as well. Stubben? Yeah,
von Stuben.
Von Stuben, good name.
And again, not an aristocrat, but calls himself von because he's one of these people who's
just a bit of a...
Good for him.
Yeah, didn't he have kind of a sketchy background?
Like he had been kicked...
I don't know what the... but he had been kicked out of whatever he was...
He was in the Prussian army previously.
I think it was Prussia by AFD.
A lot of the... there's no internet then, so you can yourself. It's like going to college on the first day, actually I'm super cool guys.
Yeah and he plays a crucial role helping to train the Continental Army according
to European standards he's actually quite important yeah although a bit of a
he's not a fraud he just he enhanced his CV There you go. He's like Don Draper in Mad Men, right?
Yes.
He's talented, but he's lying.
Yes, yes, that's excellent.
That's excellent.
Look, he's helping, who cares?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
There's also huge ego clashes in the Continental Army.
There are big battles about whether to support Washington.
What do you mean?
Like other people wanted to be the main guy,
they wanted to be the alpha?
And they don't think he's good enough,
they think he's struggling,
they think he's not the guy to be leading the army. So he had to fight on that front as well
He's fighting the British and he's also fighting people that are trying to basically take his spot
Yeah, there's a dual fought between a guy called John Cadwallader
I think and a guy called a Conway that they're literally fighting a duel over whether John George Washington is good enough
Yeah, cuz Conway was briefing against George Washington and kind of created something called the Conway Cabal.
And after Horatio Gates wins at Saratoga, there are people saying maybe he should be in charge of the whole thing instead of Washington.
And the quote John Adams writes to his wife saying,
The military officers in the Continental Army are quarreling like cats and dogs. They are scrambling for rank and pay like apes for nuts.
Oh, what a bitch. How bitchy. Oh my goodness.
So this idea of the kind of great American army proudly fighting the...
actually they're kind of squabbling amongst themselves.
One of the things that makes you a great general is that you have a massive ego.
The way that you would succeed is to think that I am chosen by God.
And someone like Bradley, who is also a brilliant general, but is like,
listen guys, we don't need you with your
Pearl Handle pistol and your friggin umbrella let's just get
let's just save the world from evil can you just calm down let's just all wear
the right kind of shoes yeah yeah yeah yeah just down there and march in the right way
yeah the big military win that shocked everyone is Yorktown 1781 the Americans
defeat a big British army and this is the end of the war which no one's no one's
seen that come in right? Yes the French and the Americans defeat a big British army.
Oh, sorry.
That's really, really important.
Oh, pardon.
Yeah, je suis désolé.
So what happened is after Saratoga and the French alliance, the British concentrate on
the southern colonies because they're the more lucrative and they've kind of written
off the north and they send an army under General Cornwallis to the south.
That army fights around the south.
It ends up going to Yorktown, Virginia seeking resupply
it's blockaded there in the in the fall of 1781 a combined Franco-American army marches south from New York and
There's some fighting. There's a siege that goes on Cornwallis ultimately surrenders
It's made possible though Patton you asked about naval battles
There was a naval battle during the siege, the Battle of the Capes,
and the French defeated the Royal Navy, which meant that Cornwallis was not going to get resupplied, which leads to his surrender.
I was going to ask, how come that's the end of the war, because he simply can't get supplies in?
Now, it need not be the end of the war, though, because Britain fought France for 25 years.
I was going to say Britain is a superpower. We can fight forever. Britain has the means to continue. In the words of Captain America, I can France for 25 years. I was going to say Britain was super power. Britain has the means to continue.
In the words of Captain America, I can do this all day.
Yeah.
The government collapsed because the war wasn't popular in Britain.
We're back to the fact that there's considerable sympathy for the Americans in Britain.
Oh wow.
There's a lack of political will, not a lack of...
The Lord North is back home in Britain.
Everyone's like, this guy, yeah, okay, cool.
Alright, so the war ends and there are peace treaty.
Do you know where the peace treaty is held?
I don't.
Do you wanna guess?
Philadelphia?
No, it's Paris.
Sort of neutral territory, but not really
because the French have been at war, right?
So they've all got to go to Paris.
And it's a sort of big old kind of like,
we'll have this, you have that. But the thing that's
quite interesting is that they're discussing kind of boring stuff like fishing treaties.
It's not boring if you live in New England.
Sorry, take it back.
And John Adams is a New Englander. So North Sea fishery is an incredibly important industry.
But yes, they are there and argue about fishery.
How much cod can I catch? I gotta know. But they do talk about fishing.
Crucially, the Americans and British make a side deal.
According to the Alliance of 1778, the French say to the Americans, under the terms of
that treaty, no separate peace with the British.
We're in this together.
The Americans make a separate peace.
They betray the French.
Nice.
But hang on.
I heard...
A sure relationship. make a separate piece. They betray the French. Nice. But hang on. I heard-
Special relationship.
Again, I watched this long series about the War of 1812 and wasn't part of the British
thinking that, fine, we'll let them have this one. They won't be able to sustain this and
we'll just slowly chip away at them and we'll get them back.
Yes. So the British give incredibly generous borders to the new United States.
All the territories south of the Great Lakes and west to the Mississippi River.
Wow.
Okay.
So that's a huge time to them.
Wow.
It's basically a third of the present continental United States, with the exception of Florida,
which goes to the Spanish.
And the reason the British do that is they think this is going to fail.
They're going to fail.
You'll be back.
We're going to get all this back.
It's gonna fall into our laps. Now, if we'd said this a couple years ago, we'd say, well,
ha ha, they got fooled. Maybe they're playing a long game, the British, and then we are
gonna be back. Maybe it is gonna fail.
Yeah, actually. Hmm. Wait a minute. Are we seeing? This is a very long game.
The longest of long cons. Yeah, wow.
Okay, wow.
Okay, well listeners, if you want to know more about what happened after the Treaty
of Paris and America getting on its feet and creating a constitution, inventing the idea
of a president, we've got an episode on that called Becoming America.
It's all the way back.
It was a very fun one.
Way back in the timeline.
Scroll down in the app.
Who was the comedian on that one?
Chris Addison from...
Oh, he's great.
Oh, from Thick of It. Thick of It, exactly yeah. He's fantastic.
Yeah, wonderful.
The Nuance Window!
But it's time now for The Nuance Window. This is where Patton and I sit silently to ponder
our fishing-related treaty clauses while Professor Frank takes to the congressional floor for
two minutes to tell us something important about the American War of Independence slash revolution, whatever you call it,
my stopwatch is ready, Frank. Take it away.
The nuance I would like to develop in the nuance window is this is British history as well as
American history and we make a mistake in seeing this as American history only. It's why we don't
know there are 26 colonies, Patton, And I think that we need to interpret this
as British history as well as American history, these events,
because it takes two sides.
But also, I think we should rethink our understanding
of Britain in this period.
So what I mean by this is, to some extent,
the American Revolution is a failure
of the British Constitution.
The British Constitution can't accommodate
Britons who live overseas.
The Americans, that's what their message is
from 1765 down to 1775.
We're just like you and we have the same rights you do.
And Parliament can't accept that
and Parliament doesn't recognize that.
And the British Constitution,
as flexible as it is historically, can accommodate that.
And so to some extent, this is all a result
of what might be seen as a British constitutional crisis
that in turn leads Americans to create their own constitution
and they want a written constitution
because they say the problem with Britain
is the constitution isn't written.
So America goes off on its own way,
but then Britain, historically it was often presented
as a sort of failure for Britain, and it is,
except the British Empire continues to grow and thrive for another century.
However, they learn their lesson.
They don't give rights to settlers anymore and colonists.
They don't say you're on a par with us.
They don't allow them to have their assemblies, nor do they ever tax another colony again.
So Britain does learn and adapt and
its empire is not the same as a result of these events. So these are incredibly important
events for the United States. We need to see these events as British events as well and
see them in the context of British constitutional and imperial history.
Amazing. Two minutes exactly. Thank you. Exactly, thanks. Whoa! Professor! Yeah! That was a quill drop.
That makes absolute sense.
Not only is it British history, it was a crucial hinge moment in how Britain went forward.
Yeah.
It's a British hinge.
And how they modernized themselves.
Yeah.
Yeah, and it's interesting also, in many ways it wasn't an intellectual revolution, it wasn't
a French revolutionary movement in terms of ideas and philosophy. It was a logistics problem
Mm-hmm. We can't fit these people in they just can't fit in the tent
Yeah, and I'll also future colonists
Sorry for queering the pitch for you in terms of getting territory and stuff way
I didn't mean to mess that up, but you know it is what it is
America ruin the world we really. And we continue to do so.
Ruining the world since 1776.
That's right folks.
Pop it on a t-shirt.
That's what you can wear for the anniversary.
Yes, ruining the world since 1776.
Amazing.
So what do you know now?
So it's time now for the So What Do You Know Now?
This is our quickfire quiz for Patton to see how much he has learned.
Patton, I suspect you're a confident quizzer.
I feel that you're a man brimming with knowledge and trivia.
I'm an optimistic quizzer.
Oh, that's great.
Yeah, I'm optimistic.
Okay, well we've got ten questions for you.
Everything we've discussed, so let's see how we go.
So question one, how many?
There were 26 colonies!
Exactly right, well done!
Amazing!
Oh, there's more?
Let's see if you can do it again. Question two, which group were responsible for the Boston Tea
Party? Oh, the Sons of Liberty!
Yes, that's right.
Yeah!
Question three, name the British acts of parliament that punished Massachusetts
after the Tea Party. Those were the coercive acts, or also as the Boston called them, the
not horrible acts. They gave it like the atrocious acts or the...
Intolerable. The intolerable acts.
Yeah, very good. I'll give you that coercive acts. It was absolutely spot on. Question
four. Who was the proud first president of the First Continental Congress? A great Virginian
man. Yes, a great Virginia, Peyton Randolph.
Very good, well done.
Sounds to me like an American football player, but yes, sure.
Question five, what was King George III's reaction to the Olive Branch petition?
He claims he did not read it, but I sighed with the professor thinking,
I think he did read it and then said he didn't.
Yeah, he left it on red.
Power move.
He left it on red.
That's what he did, yes.
Question six, what was the name of Thomas Paine's
popular 1776 pamphlet calling for independence in America?
Why, that was called Common Sense.
It was.
Question seven, can you name two of the five drafters
of the Declaration of Independence?
I can.
Can you give me all five and I will give you a bonus point.
Oh God.
Wow, you're right, those two get forgotten.
Oh my God, I feel terrible for them.
It's happening again.
Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson.
Right, you've got the point.
Okay, then I'm going to stop there.
I can't remember the other.
John Adams, Roger Sherman, and Robert Livingston.
Livingston and Sherman, those sound like 50 songwriters.
They do, don't they?
Yeah. Well, we wrote Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow and a Teen Angel, and we also ratified
the Constitution. Question 8. Who did the Americans sign the Treaty of Alliance with
in February 1778? That would be France. It was France. You're doing very well, Patton.
Question 9. What was John Adams' complaint about the Continental Army officers during
the war? Oh, they were a bunch of messy bitches that were all fighting over George Washington.
They were, they were quarrelling like cats and dogs.
This for a perfect 10 out of 10.
Which siege in 1781 marked the end of the conflict?
Oh, the siege at Yorktown.
He's done it!
Did I do it?
You did it!
10 out of 10, never in doubt, and nearly 11 out of 11, but you bailed on Livingston.
Livingston and, oh my god, I've already forgotten.
Sherman.
Livingston and Sherman, they're just like, they were born to be forgotten.
Wow, what a weird, witchy power they have.
Let's face it, if you're from Connecticut and your name is Roger Sherman, you're kind
of forgettable.
Oh, there we go.
Well, thank you so much, Patton. Yeah, you are. Oh my god. Oh, there we go.
Well, thank you so much, Patton.
Do you feel like you've learned some stuff here?
I actually did learn some stuff.
There was a lot wanting in my high school and college education.
I think you did great.
Yeah, thank you.
And thank you, of course, Professor Frank.
That was a real eye-opener.
A listener for more American political history, check out our sequel episode on Becoming America,
which we mentioned with Chris Addison.
We've also got episodes on the abolitionists, the Journal of Truth.
We've got one on Frederick Douglass.
For more South American independence movements, we have one on Simon Bolivar, which is very
good fun.
And remember, if you've enjoyed the podcast, please share the show with your friends.
I'd just like to say a huge thank you to our guests.
In History Corner, we had the fantastic Professor Frank Cogliano from the University of Edinburgh.
Thank you, Frank.
My pleasure.
Thank you.
It was a lot of fun. And in Comedy Corner, we have the outstanding Patton Oswalt.
Thank you, Patton.
It's so good to learn about my home country of America.
Thank you.
And to you lovely listener, join me next time
as we fight to free another neglected historical topic.
But for now, I'm off to go and chuck 340 chests of coffee
into Boston Harbor.
It's not a political protest.
I just hate coffee.
Bye!
You're Dead to Me is a BBC Studios audio production for BBC Radio 4.
Hello, it's Lucy Worsley here,
and we're back with a brand new series of Lady Swindlers.
Here we are in cell number one. I'm just shutting us in, Ross.
Wow!
Following in the footsteps of some all new criminals.
Can you take me down to the other end of Baker Street, please?
Certainly. Jump in.
Thank you.
Join me and my all-female team of detectives as we revisit the audacious crimes
of women trying to make it in a world made for men.
This is a story of working class women trying to get by. This is survival.
Lady Swindlers Season 2 with Lucy Worsley from BBC Radio 4. Listen now on BBC Sounds.
First, they told the story of the moon landing.
60 seconds.
We choose to go to the moon.
30 feet down, two and a half.
I thought, wow, what have I gotten myself into?
Then came the dramatic rescue of the Apollo 13 mission.
Okay, you know, we've had a problem here.
I literally got on my knees and prayed.
Now from the BBC World Service, 13 Minutes presents The Space Shuttle,
the inside story of a dream to revolutionize spaceflight.
We had so much riding on something
we'd never done before.
Unlike anything that had ever flown in space.
This is the Space Shuttle.
Roger all.
We're just hooting and hollering and screaming and yelling
for the sheer joy of what you were taking in.
13 Minutes presents The Space Shuttle. Coming soon.
Ever wondered what you would do if you found yourself lost in the wild?
In the desert, the jungle, or the mountains, would you make the right choices to stay alive?
Introducing real survival stories. the new podcast from Noiza.
Each week we'll bring you astonishing tales of ordinary people thrust into extraordinary situations.
How the heck am I going to get out of here?
Am I going to be a pile of bones in the Australian outback or am I going to make it out?
Real Survival Stories, available now wherever you get your shows.