You're Dead to Me - Emperor Constantine the Great: Christianity and the Roman Empire

Episode Date: September 4, 2026

Greg Jenner is joined in ancient Rome by Professor Lucy Grig and comedian Ivo Graham to learn all about Emperor Constantine the Great and the Christianisation of the Roman empire. Born not in Rome but... in the Balkans, Constantine’s life was shaped by the turbulent politics of the late third century. He grew up as Emperor Diocletian – remembered now as a savage persecutor of Christians – was establishing the Tetrarchy, with four rulers now in control of the empire. One of these was Constantine’s father, Constantius. But when Constantius died in York, his son was acclaimed emperor in his place, kicking off a violent civil war. This episode traces Constantine’s life, from his childhood through to his elevation as emperor, taking in his extraordinary victory at Milvian Bridge, the vision that allegedly encouraged his conversion to Christianity, and his founding of Constantinople as a New Rome. It also examines his relationship with his mother, later known as Saint Helena, the bloody path he carved to the imperial throne, and his role in the pivotal Council of Nicaea, a landmark event in Christian history. If you’re a fan of religious revolutions, bloody Roman power politics, and historical nepo babies, you’ll love our episode on Constantine the Great. If you want more Roman rulers, listen to our episodes on the Rise of Julius Caesar, Agrippina the Younger, or Emperor Nero, with Professor Mary Beard and Patton Oswalt. And for more on the Christianisation of the Roman empire, check out our episode on Hypatia of Alexandria. You’re Dead To Me is the comedy podcast that takes history seriously. Every episode, Greg Jenner brings together the best names in history and comedy to learn and laugh about the past. Hosted by: Greg Jenner Research by: Auréliane Perrin Written by: Auréliane Perrin, Dr Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow, Dr Emma Nagouse, and Greg Jenner Produced by: Dr Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow and Greg Jenner Audio Producer: Steve Hankey Production Coordinator: Gill Huggett Senior Producer: Dr Emma Nagouse Executive Editor: Philip Sellars

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. In a world where swords were sharp. And hygiene was actually probably better than you think it is. Two fearless historians. Me, Matt Lewis. And me, Dr. Eleanor Yonaga, dive headfirst into the mud, blood, and very strange customs of the Middle Ages. So for plagues, crusades and Viking raids,
Starting point is 00:00:27 and plenty of other things that don't rhyme, Subscribe to Gone Medieval from History Hit wherever you get your podcasts. Hello and welcome to You're Dead to Me with a Radio 4 comedy podcast that takes history seriously. My name's Greg Jenner. I'm a public historian, author and broadcaster. And today we're gathering our armies,
Starting point is 00:00:50 grabbing our crosses and marching back to the third and fourth centuries to learn all about the Roman Emperor, Constantine the Great. And to help us tell our Maximians from our Maxentiousists, that's hard to say, Maxentiousness, and to help us tell... And to help us tell our Max Simians from our Maxentius, we have two very special guests in History Corner. She's Professor of the History of Late Antiquity at the University of Edinburgh,
Starting point is 00:01:15 where her research focuses on society, culture and religion in the later Roman world. Maybe you've read her excellent book, Popular Culture and the End of Antiquity in Southern Gaul. It's Professor Lucy Grigg, welcome Lucy. Thank you, hello. Lovely to have you in. And in Comedy Corner, he's the UK's most apologetically posh comedian. But, you know, in a good way. Maybe you've seen one of his many stand-up shows
Starting point is 00:01:35 listen to his wonderful music podcast, Gigpigs, or read his wonderful new book, Yard Sticks for Failure, and you'll have seen him all over the TV on Last Leg, Mock the Week, Live of the Apollo, my favourite, of course, Taskmaster. It's Ivo, Graham, welcome Ivo. Hi, I'm great, hi, Lucy. Thanks for having me. We're thrilled to have you in.
Starting point is 00:01:51 It's first... First time on. First time on. So, contractually... Nervously noting already. I've written Maximians from Maxxenxes, even though I don't know what that is. But I just felt me.
Starting point is 00:02:02 very important immediately. It is going to be important. I have to ask Ivo, do you like history? I've really wrestled with this answer. And I've actually found it quite a bleak thing to contemplate because I do, but I don't think I do enough for this show.
Starting point is 00:02:19 And I think I'm a well-educated man who is steadily getting thicker. And I've reflected on that a lot. I like giving quizzes. I often do quite badly on them. I think people expect me to be into history. And I often have like a history joke in my show
Starting point is 00:02:37 and sort of enjoy the sort of smug intellectualism of like a bit about Garibaldi in my most recent one. It's about the Italian leader. It's about the biscuits. And then there's a joke about boarding school, which we don't need to go into it. But like actually, when you break it down, like, my mom, I've got a seven-year-old daughter
Starting point is 00:02:53 who's starting to learn stuff and I often don't know what she's talking about. There's so many comedy history podcasts now, the serious ones, the edge lord ones. And I feel I'm being left behind by all of it. So I will disappoint today. No, no, no, welcome for the history slipstream. Okay, yes, I want to get back into it.
Starting point is 00:03:09 Okay, what do you know about Constantine the Great? You know, the internet is obsessed with the Roman Empire. Yes. So are you equally thinking about him daily? No, again, I'm not thinking about that daily at all. And, you know, fair play to, I mean, of course, you're a bit of a busman's holiday, the idea of thinking about the Roman Empire every day. Yes.
Starting point is 00:03:25 My brother did ancient history at university, and so I did message him saying, do you know a lot about Constantine? And he said, the chrizos were never really my jam. So that's all I've got for this. What a quote. So what do you know? This is the first segment. It's called The So What Do You Know?
Starting point is 00:03:52 This is where I have a go at guessing what you are lovely listener or viewer. Hello. Might know about today's subject. And despite being one of history's greats, the great, indeed, Our Constantine doesn't really get much pop coverage. He's not really in the pop culture. There's a movie called Constantine with Rachel Weiss and Keanu Reeves.
Starting point is 00:04:11 Wrong Constantine. Nothing to do with ancient Rome. Some of you may know him as the first Christian Roman emperor. If you've been to York or if you studied there, like myself and producer Emmy, you will know there's a lovely statue of him outside York, Minster. Perhaps you've been to Constantinople,
Starting point is 00:04:26 the city named by him, founded by him, which of course is now Istanbul. I've always writing that down, very good. but why did he found this new capital city? What inspired his religious conversion to Christianity and is it okay to be a Christian emperor who kills so many people? Let's find out.
Starting point is 00:04:42 Right, Professor Lucy, we often have to deal with some pretty dodgy sources when we visit the ancient world, particularly for biographies of people. So how trustworthy are our texts today? Are we taking everything with a pinch of salt? Yes, pretty much. It's not that there aren't sources
Starting point is 00:04:58 and there are even pretty contemporary sources, Eusebius of Caesarea writes a life, lactantius writes about him. There's also sources written not long after. He's died, but the problem is that they're often very polarised. There's the pro-Constantine sources. They embellish some things, leave other things out. And then there's the sources that probably make all kinds of other things up.
Starting point is 00:05:19 There's religious bias. I mean, yeah, it's tricky. Okay, so we've got quite a confusing evidentiary record, but we know some things. So, Ivo, given that Constantine grew up to be emperor of Rome. Yes. What class do you think he was born into?
Starting point is 00:05:33 Do you think he was more Eton College or more eating out of the bins? I think Eaton College, I think. You think, born to rule. Okay. Posh. Princeley. Yes. You've given me two options and I've gone with the one I'm more familiar with.
Starting point is 00:05:48 But obviously I would fully support rags to riches story. Jamie Vardy, etc. We'll see the Jamie Vardy. I mean, that's a niche reference. Let's be honest. Who were Constantine's parents? Was he entitled and noble, or is this a rags the riches story? Well, what's interesting is it's a bit of both.
Starting point is 00:06:09 So his father, whose name is Constantius, get ready for all of these matching names. He's a soldier. He's from Moesha, modern Serbia. He's sort of a rising star in the military autocracy of the day when he meets Constantine's mom, who's called Helena. She is from ancient Pythinia, so part of modern Turkey. And this is where it gets interesting. The ancient sources describe her as, one describes it as vilissima,
Starting point is 00:06:36 which is very vile, very common even. And so we're not quite sure about her. It's thought they meet maybe in an inn where maybe she's working as a barmaid, a stable girl, sex worker, possibly. We don't know if she's a Roman citizen. She could have been enslaved. They meet probably in their 20s.
Starting point is 00:06:55 So Constantin Constantius, even I get them wrong. He's on his military travels. they meet, because we don't know whether she's like a proper Roman citizen, we don't even know if they're actually married. Some of the sources refer to her as his concubine, which is quite a common status at that time. So we don't know if they're married, but they are in their 20s. They meet. Constantine is born in the early 270s, not quite sure when. And this is a point when his father, Constantius, is busy kind of climbing the ranks of the imperial hierarchy. And eventually he throws over poor Helena for a more politically advantageous match. So he marries then the
Starting point is 00:07:30 daughter or stepdaughter of the emperor Maximian who's called Theodora. So that's kind of the end of their relationship. So young love, you know, talented young soldier meets girl in pub. That's absolutely fine. I love the word
Starting point is 00:07:45 villisina. I'm going to try and use that in my life as much as possible. So, Ivo, yes. We've got a fairly complicated family history already. Yes. I'm going to complicate things even more. No. Because we're going to talk about Roman politics. Okay. What was the... Do you know what the tetrarchy was?
Starting point is 00:08:00 No. I'm sorry. That was a delightful wince. Okay. I'm sorry. It looked like it hurt. Is it okay? It's all right.
Starting point is 00:08:08 It's all right. It's okay. I'm going to make peace with all of this. The tetra. I mean, you study classics. Yes. At a DETI college, a bit of money was spent on my classics education,
Starting point is 00:08:16 undenegely. Can you work out what tetrarchy might mean? Yes. It's obviously something to do with the number three. Yes. No. Four. Sorry?
Starting point is 00:08:23 Four. Four? Yeah. Yeah. Wow. Yeah, I guess so. So what does it mean then? I mean, Lucy, do you want to tell us?
Starting point is 00:08:33 Rule of four is what it means. I feel very bad that I laughed. I would never laugh at my last chance. No, I think that's great to produce such an unvarnished contempt. You did say you were getting thicker, so it's okay. Yeah, yeah. Didn't expect to prove it so early in the episode. Yeah, rule of four.
Starting point is 00:08:49 Because a tetrahedron is a four-sided, four-pointed. What's a tetrahedron again? I don't know. Luckily, it's not a geometry. Yeah, yeah, yeah, sorry. This is not a geometry podcast, so I don't know. But yeah, you're right. Tetrapak?
Starting point is 00:09:06 What's Tetrapak then? Tetris. Is it Tetris? I'm thinking of Tetris. I'm afraid. If you said what number does, well, you've seen what's happened, I don't know that Tetris signifies four. So what would a three version of tetrarci be then?
Starting point is 00:09:18 Well, Tetris presumably is four because they're like little squares that fall for four. But that's, oh, I don't know. We need to move on from the geometry quiz because clearly none of us know what we're doing here. The tetrarchy is the rule of four. Lucy, we are talking here about what's known as the crisis of the third century. Yes. I mean, and obviously, as ever historical trends come and go, people go, oh, there's no such thing is a third century crisis,
Starting point is 00:09:41 but it pretty much looks like a crisis. You've got this period, particularly over 50 years, up to 284, where you have political crisis, military crisis, everything goes wrong on all the frontiers, economic, melt problems, religious tensions, and lots of emperors. So, yeah, how many emperors depends on how you count? Maybe 26, definitely over 20.
Starting point is 00:10:06 If you count all the wannabe emperors, you're getting close to 50. But about 25 or so is usually... Yeah, accepted. That's usually accepted, 25 who ruled. So, I mean, as the UK, we've just lost another prime minister. Yeah, yeah. So we're doing quite... We're kind of heading towards our own crisis,
Starting point is 00:10:22 because we've had seven prime ministers in 10 years. The Romans went with 25 and 50. I feel like we're trending upwards. Yeah, yeah. We could win this. Yeah, it's weird that the Starma one feels like it's been a period of almost stability. And that's been, what, less than two years. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:10:37 Yes. It's horrible to be approaching Roman levels of turnover. I mean, it's dangerous being a Roman emperor. They are murdered constantly. There's a point where there are six emperors in one year, which is way too many emperors. So they're going through emperors like Chelsea Watford and Spurs go through managers, which is obviously a reference for Ivo, not necessary for all our listeners. But what was the Tetraarchy? How does it fix things?
Starting point is 00:11:01 Does it fix things? What is this idea of the rule of four? I mean, it's actually, yes, it's actually pretty successful. So we've had this period where it's clear that one autocrat cannot rule the empire, all of this territory by themselves. Tetraarchy, although pedantic point, because I am an academic, it's a modern term. It's not Diocletian who found the tetrarchy doesn't go around going, welcome to the tetrarchy.
Starting point is 00:11:25 And so you've had all. of these soldier emperors, they get called making it to the top. When Diocletian makes it to the top in 284, he does something different. He sets up what gets called the Imperial College, again, modern term, with two senior emperors, two junior emperors. Now, if anyone's been to Venice on holiday, you can see these lovely sort of stumpy purple statues of these four guys on the corner of St. Marks. And so you've got the empire sort of divided into two and then again into two, so into four.
Starting point is 00:11:55 you've got senior empresses, Augustus, and junior emperors who are called Caesars. And so we have Diocletian and Maximian as co-emperors for the East and the West, is where I get confused too. Diocletian's own son-in-law, who's called Galerius, he's his Caesar in the East. And then we have Constan's dad, who is the junior one in the West. So is it really merit-based? Well, what do you think?
Starting point is 00:12:23 probably not. But this does seem to usher in a period of relative stability for the Roman Empire unless perhaps you are a Christian, particularly in the east of the empire, because Diocletian and Galerius are sort of going for pretty violent repression of the Christians there. Yeah, I mean Diocletian is famous, isn't he, for the kind of horrific treatment of Christians. He's, you know, the martyrdoms and so on are. No, absolutely. And also this is where our sources get a bit muddy because the interconnections between Constantine and Diocletian,
Starting point is 00:12:53 which the pro-Constantine sources say and what to really like pretend that aren't there are clearly there. So Constantius, the dad of Constantine, yes. Is now Juniors, his junior emperor, basically, of the West. Yes. So how do you imagine Constantine's childhood? What do you think he's getting up to with his average Tuesdays?
Starting point is 00:13:14 Well, I mean, so if his dad's doing that, and this is now, it's Theodora, is his mother. Step-mom, yeah. Is step-mom? Is he still seeing any of Helena? Good point, yeah. You know, I'm thinking about co-parenting timetables, which is probably not a sort of top priority here.
Starting point is 00:13:34 But presumably, and I don't know if we've discovered this, but as well as the tetraarchy having the sort of four spread out, are there next of kins all being sort of prime to take over the four? Yeah, I think you're really getting this now, yes. Or is it like if Constanches doesn't really sort of pull his weight, is, you know, could, if someone who was really pulling the weight in the Tetraiki had two top sons, could it be like, you'll both get promoted?
Starting point is 00:14:06 Premium quality sons, yeah. Yes, that is pretty much how it is. I should say that we don't, Constanth doesn't really get rid of Helena until probably Constantine is sort of adult. But yeah, it's true, we don't really know what happens to her. She does just kind of disappear from history. while. Vizima.
Starting point is 00:14:22 So she goes well for her in the end. So Constantine is born in Serbia, Naissus, modern Serbia. So he has been kind of groomed for this life, as you're suggesting. He's sort of getting military training because it's very much a kind of military elite. He's also like Ivo learning Greek in Latin literature and indeed philosophy, but his mother is likely illiterate. So it's a big kind of social gap here.
Starting point is 00:14:45 And then, as you say, his dad becomes Caesar in the West. So he's traveling with his father and around. these other courts. He's really travelling. We think he went to as far east as Palestine, Egypt, even ancient Persia. Okay. As a soldier?
Starting point is 00:15:01 Yes. And as a soldier, maybe a kind of part of a sort of woodyguard unit, but definitely as a kind of junior sort of princeling. So he's sort of, you know, Ivo, you went to, you did Eaton and Oxbridge, the classic path for leadership.
Starting point is 00:15:13 Yes. You haven't ended up in politics yet. No, I haven't. But do you sort of feel a familiarity with Constantine's, life. Do you sort of recognise this and think, oh yes, that could have been me? No, I don't, no, I don't exude leadership qualities. Oh, I think that's fair. I think you're a man of tremendous charisma.
Starting point is 00:15:32 Well, that's very kind. I think I'm a man of occasional charisma, but I don't think even that is the most important quality in leadership. The closest I felt to that sort of thing, I think, is being a leader of a group at a festival, that I really do promote myself to that role quite early on from, particularly if I've been and others haven't. There was a great Glastonbury night last year where we were trying to get home at about 4 a.m. There were a lot of us, and it's a very sort of crowded, sort of central spine of the festival.
Starting point is 00:16:04 It's like the sort of zombie army sort of going through, and I brought a ball of string to the festival. And I was like, everyone stay on the string. And it was one of the more military things I've done in my life. You did a Theseus. I did a theatius. It wasn't in my mind. at the time, but he should have been, of course.
Starting point is 00:16:20 Two of the people are now who met on the string and now in a long-term relationship. This is the future of dating, Ivo. You've invented a new time. But everything changed for Constantine in the year 305 when he was, what, 30?
Starting point is 00:16:36 Yeah, so it's probably born in 272, but sometimes, yeah, something like that. Okay, early 30s. So what's this sort of crucial moment, 305? Why do we... Well, Diocletian does something incredibly unusual for Roman emperor. He voluntarily abdicates. I mean, really, that is incredibly rare. And he goes off to
Starting point is 00:16:56 look after his cabbages. Is that a euphemism? Or is that? Seemingly not. So he goes voluntarily, but his co-emperor, but his co-emperor, not so much. He doesn't really want to do it, but he's made to. So now we've got a kind of vacancy. So if you remember, we've got this four system. And so Galerius and Constantius get an upgrade. So we've now got two new Augustuses. So our junior Caesar's become the new Augustuses, right?
Starting point is 00:17:24 But what happens next? As you've already suggested, there's a range of potentials. And Constantine doesn't actually get the call at this point. His dad controversially perhaps picks somebody else, a guy called Severus, yeah, who becomes Caesar in the West. Galerius, he does it with an epitism, and he picks his own nephew. But it's pretty obvious. It's a slightly dangerous position to be in, definitely dynastic danger.
Starting point is 00:17:48 and Galerius apparently thinks it's a bit dangerous, having Constantine around. So he supposedly sends him on dangerous missions, like one-to-one combat with dangerous beasts. Wow. Okay. For his amusement? What sort of beasts?
Starting point is 00:18:03 Undefined, you can pick. Oh, yeah, okay. Which beast is we thinking either? Boar? Wild boar? Yeah, dangerous. Yeah, absolutely. Wild boar.
Starting point is 00:18:12 Yeah, I mean, panthers, lions. There's plenty of dangerous animals in the ancient Roman world. Yeah, and we're all seen. Daddy Aator, you know. Yes, absolutely. Well, yeah, I didn't want to go full sort of tigers and elephants. Yeah. Okay, so Lucy, while Daddy Constantius is now emperor of the West or East, I can't remember.
Starting point is 00:18:30 West, you're West. Thank you. His son is being bullied by his co-worker. So does HR get involved? How do you sort of solve office politics? Well, this is where Daddy does sort of come to the rescue bit. So he, this is like local interest, he's actually in Britain, in northern Britain, fighting the pects, and he tries to get Galerius to send him away. He's basically in this kind of
Starting point is 00:18:55 bullying hostage situation at Calerius's court, and there's a story that Galerius agrees to let him go, then changes his mind the next morning, but by the time he's sort of like got the order out, Constantine has already legged it off to be reunited with his dad. Yes, and Legdidoff is probably the operative verb there, because as far as we can tell, he's on the run. Yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. He's scared. He thinks Sclerius is going to get him. So how does he get to Northern Britain? In fact, Scotland, as we call it now, in record time, maximum pace. How do you get across Europe that fast? What's the best route? In what, in 305? Yep. They haven't built the motorways yet. No. Or the TGV. I think it's, it's got to be horse. It is horse, yeah. It's a horse network. And he's taking the fastest horses. Yes. But he's not going the normal route. No. So he uses the curse as publicus. So this is the sort of highway official transport system. And the story goes, he takes the fastest horse in each stable, they're spread out on the way. And not such a nice bit, you know, injures the other horses so no one else can follow him. And he goes a special roundabout route to avoid the Caesar of the West, who is Severus, who's been picked instead of him so he can make it to meet his dad.
Starting point is 00:20:13 So he's gone the long way around? Yeah. To avoid getting picked up and arrested. and sent back to Galerius to be murdered. And it works. He meets his dad probably in Northern Gaul, but then they head off to Britain to fight the pesky picks. They do, and they campaign together until they end up in Iboracom, which is... Sundland?
Starting point is 00:20:34 Not bad, York. York, which is where the statue of Constantine now is... I've written that down. Yorkminster. Iboracom, York. And in 306, Daddy Constanius dies in York. so our Serbian Roman emperor is dead, and the soldiers are like,
Starting point is 00:20:52 it's fine, because we've got another one. Absolutely. All hail Emperor Constantine. They do do that, but just saying it doesn't always make it happen because Galerius isn't so keen on this idea. He does agree, perhaps reluctantly, that Constantine can still be a junior,
Starting point is 00:21:10 a junior emperor, so is Caesar, but yeah, Severus then becomes Augustus. I mean, I hope you're keeping up, because frankly, it's a right mess at this point. And then we have to throw our new character into the mix, who is Maximian's son, remember Maximian's son, who is called Maxentius. He's currently hanging out in Rome. He's not actually got any official job, but he thinks it's frankly unfair. The Constantine, who he calls the son of a harlot, apparently, is now being acclaimed in this way.
Starting point is 00:21:39 Maximian was the co-emperor previously with Diocletian. Yes. So his son, Maxentius, is to sort of lay up. about waiting for power. Yeah. And is now angry that Constantine has got the power that he feels he should have. Yes.
Starting point is 00:21:53 Are you following Ivo? Sorry. Quite a lot. Yeah, it's, it's, uh, I've, there's a lot of names now, but I'm afraid I'm already at the point where I go, that won't be in the quiz. That's that, that, that, those names probably is in the quiz. Okay.
Starting point is 00:22:06 So, uh, so maybe get jotting down in the old notebook. But, so we've got two father-son pairs here. Yeah. But luckily for us, they've gone with the, kind of Kardashian family branding style because we've got Constantius and Constantine and Maximian and Maxentius. And it will only get worse. Yes, it is going to get more confusing.
Starting point is 00:22:22 So how do you think Maxentius dealt with Constantine being named the new emperor? This son in Rome who thought that he should be king, emperor. What do you think he does? I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. Certainly maybe published something,
Starting point is 00:22:38 maybe wrote something to Di Clesian. No. Diocletian is abdicated. He's with his cabbages. Sorry. Okay, that's annoying. But he's too far away to go and deal with the issue directly, I would say. So maybe he raises an army in wait, in wait for his return. Oh, that's good. I mean, that's not a bad instinct, right? I mean, I think many people will know the quote, I am Spartacus. By this point, it's more I am emperor, right?
Starting point is 00:23:08 Because now everyone is sort of putting their hand forward and saying, I'm the emperor, not that guy, it's me. Yeah. And you need an army. Yes, and as Ivo says, you've still got the kind of retired, but are they really emperors as well? So there's a big cast. So yes, Maxentius gets the imperial troops, the guardsman in Rome, which in Rome is a pretty good place to be, let's face it. He gets them to acclaim him as emperor. He persuades his father, Maximian, to come out of retirement.
Starting point is 00:23:34 So as I said, he's kind of waiting in the wings and join his cause. So we've got civil war. We've got Roman Empire back in civil war. And so Max Sanchez, he's raised his troops, as you say. He does well in Italy. If you remember, there's also this problem of this guy called Severus, who's not related particularly to our main people. He's in Italy, and so Maxentius and his troops do very well.
Starting point is 00:23:56 They capture him. They kill him. Of course, they do. And Constantine, for this point, just stays out of it. He's calling himself a senior emperor of the West, but he stays out of Italy, so he doesn't control Italy, which you think is quite important. And he just stays on the Rhine.
Starting point is 00:24:11 He's a very good soldier, seemingly. He's fighting the Frankish. tribes there. So he's in Germany? Ryan, yeah. So the border of France and Germany. Right, okay. So Maxentius has taken power, got his dad out of retirement to back him up, killed Severus. Yes. And now we're waiting for the
Starting point is 00:24:28 Smackdown with Constantine. Something like, yes, yes. Yeah, exactly that way. Okay. But I vote, Constantine then gained a surprising ally in his fight against Maxentius. Who do you think yours? So it's really just a case of which names are still on the table. Shock. It's,
Starting point is 00:24:48 is it the retired Diocletian? It's a good guess. Okay. It's even more surprising than that. Okay. Well, it's, surely, it's not Maximilian. It's Maximilian, not supporting his own son. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:25:00 He gets, his enemy's dad joins his side. Wow. Which is very awkward at Christmas. But, um... Yes, so Maximian has been building an alliance with Constantine. And history also repeats itself, because at this point, So his first wife, Minervina, we don't know much about her. Maybe that's because she was Diocletian's daughter,
Starting point is 00:25:19 and the pro-Constantinian sources are trying to disassociate them. But he gets a new wife who is Maximian's daughter Fauster. So he's had a son with his first wife. Yes. The son's called Crispus. Yes. But he's ditched that wife and he's onto the new wife. Yes.
Starting point is 00:25:34 And she is Faustra. And that's in 307 they get married. Okay. So it's all going quite well. He cemented the relationship with his new allies. Well, his new ally who is his enemy's dad. Yeah, yeah, yeah. How old is he by this point?
Starting point is 00:25:49 34. Yeah, yeah, something like that. Something like that. Not quite ready for a mid-life crisis, you would think. I don't know when you say that, but I mean, he's... Yeah, yeah, I'm 35 and I'm on the fast train. So if Constantius had been married to Maximian's daughter Theodora, does that mean that Fauster, his new wife, his second wife,
Starting point is 00:26:09 is Constantine's new step-aunt as well as his new wife? I mean, who even knows at this point? Are we going to be hearing any more about Christmas? Not loads. That's a shame. I mean, you'll hear one thing about him, and it's not nice. So, yes, Christmas will get his comeuppance. Okay, so after the wedding, this lovely, beautiful wedding,
Starting point is 00:26:32 the two families are united. Presumably Max Sancher's not invited to the wedding. You would do a thing not. He's at war with him. Yes. Yes, so Max Zimian quarrels with his son, Max Simeon. obviously, but doesn't manage to quite get rid of him. And this is where, okay, imagine we've got Diocletian back with his cabbages,
Starting point is 00:26:51 he comes out of retirement for an emergency conference. This is great. Yeah, in 308 in Carnuntan, which is near Vienna, but he says he won't come back to rule. They try and sort out the situation. Maximian is forced to abdicate for the second time, second or even third time, but it becomes clear that he doesn't really want to go.
Starting point is 00:27:11 So when it comes to Maximeon, he's forced, in what is very much traditional Roman style to die by suicide. So that's Constantine's sort of succession moment. That's where he really, like the claws come out. So up to this point he's divorcing, he's dumping, but now he's killing his enemies. And they're not even an enemy, a former ally.
Starting point is 00:27:29 Is he back in Rome by this point? Not yet. Okay. He's doing all of this from York. No, he's more in sort of... Oh, so the Rhine. The Rhine, Gaul. Yeah, sort of France, Germany, that sort of area,
Starting point is 00:27:41 fighting the Franks. At this point, Diocletes, vegetable garden, sounds quite appealing, right? It's just sort of sit there with the cabbages and the carrots. So did Maxentius take maximum revenge on Constantine for killing his papa? Doesn't quite go that way. Right, okay. So, yes, we've had Constantine on the Rhine.
Starting point is 00:27:58 Then in 312, he decides to deal with Maxentius. So he marches to Italy. He defeats Maximian's troops in the north of Italy. Yeah, the names are too much. And then finally, when it's at the 28th of October 312, they're in Rome, and we get the kind of end game for Maxentius. They have a battle at the Milvian Bridge, which is just north of Rome. Although the sort of pro-Constantine source is trying to bigger up as like a great victory, it's probably a foregone conclusion. It's awful Maxentius's troops.
Starting point is 00:28:32 They've cut the bridges, lots of them drown, including Maxentius himself. And Constantine is then, yeah, he's the winner. He's been acclaimed liberator by the same. Senate. So he's now definitely the senior emperor for the west of the empire. But even though Galerius has died in the east, there's a new eastern Augustus called Likinius, who has been busy killing off all his rivals as well. Just, I mean, they're all at it. So Maximian is dead, Maxentius is dead, his head's on a pike. Yeah. And there's a new senior emperor in the east, Likinius, and a new senior emperor in the west, our chap, Constantine, not yet the great.
Starting point is 00:29:11 Still married to Fauster. Still married to Fauster. Okay. In a world where swords were sharp. And hygiene was actually probably better than you think it is. Two fearless historians. Me, Matt Lewis. And me, Dr. Eleanor Yanaga,
Starting point is 00:29:29 dive headfirst into the mud, blood, and very strange customs of the Middle Ages. So for plagues, crusades, and Viking raids, and plenty of other things that don't rhyme, subscribe to gone medieval from history hit wherever you get your podcasts. So Constantine and Lichenius now have to cement an alliance,
Starting point is 00:29:54 the Eastern and Western emperors, and so they do so through marriage. And that is the marriage of Constantia. Yes. Who's that? Constantine's half-sister. Okay. Not even just normal sister, just half-sister.
Starting point is 00:30:11 I think. Okay, sure. Okay, so Constantia marries Lachinius. Great. Yeah. Thank you. Brothers and law. Brothers and law.
Starting point is 00:30:19 Okay. So it's been waterwall politics, family confusion, murder, intrig, battles and wars and all sorts of things. But the Battle of the Milvary and Bridge is in 312 and this is supposedly the beginning of the Christian story. Yes. This is where we start to introduce the religious journey or conversion. So can you talk us through that sort of conversion or that moment? Yeah.
Starting point is 00:30:41 And this is one of the most debated really. arguments in ancient history. So there is a story, versions of a story put together that the night before this battle, so in October in 312, Constantine has a vision, or maybe not the night before, in which he sees a heavenly sign of a sky with two letters, a kai in a row, which are the first letters of the Greek word Christus, and another sort of slogan almost saying, conquer by this. And then the story goes, having seen this sign, he puts Christian symbols on the shields of
Starting point is 00:31:15 all of his soldiers, and then they go off and defeat Maxentius. But even that version is slightly contradicted, even by pro-Christian authors, and awkward fact, there is a speech two years earlier, 310, an official speech of praise about Constantine, which says that he had seen a vision of a pagan god, Apollo, and had a victory. So how many visions did he have? Trying to put these together is tricky. I mean, there's a lot of debate around his conversion. I mean, did he see anything? Was he sincere?
Starting point is 00:31:50 But, I mean, it is pretty clear that he does an awful lot very quickly to support the Christian church regardless. So he issues pro-Christian legislation. He builds churches at Rome. And he and Lycinius, remember his co-emperor in the East, they get together and agree a kind of package to extend measures in support of Christianity, including across the East where the Christians have been persecuted. And this sort of package of measures that they agree,
Starting point is 00:32:17 there's a kind of historical myth that this is then called the Egypt of Milan. But as I tell my students, there was no edict and there was nothing at Milan, so we don't call it that. But there we go. Okay, the not-so-Edict of Milan. Not-so-Eadict of not Malay. That's it. Okay, great.
Starting point is 00:32:31 Okay, so he converts to Christianity possibly, has visions possibly, puts the Cairo on his soldier shields. So they're fighting for Christ. Do they know who he is, Christ? These soldiers? Have they heard of Christianity? It will, you know, are ordinary soldiers in the army, in, you know, are they Christians too?
Starting point is 00:32:50 Or is this just... I mean, to me, it seems pretty unlikely at this date. But, yeah, no one asks them. Just paint this on the shield, lads, and off we go. Yeah, we've got the Cairo, there you go. Okay, so Edith of Milan didn't happen, but the Council of Nicaea did. Ivo, do you know what happened at the Council of Nicaea in 325? It's a very important and famous, one of the best...
Starting point is 00:33:13 One of the best councils, gatherings of bishops. They decide on a very important Christian doctrine. Do you want to have a guess what that would be? The Bible. Okay, so you think it's then getting together to compile the Bible? Well. No, maybe that's a bit ambitious. Well, what do you think, Lucy?
Starting point is 00:33:31 I mean, I think it is quite ambitious. And it is a sign again that Constantine's really getting in on the game. He fancies himself clearly as a bit of a theologian. All those studies are coming in handy. And so the church, it's not really just one church, is actually quite a lot of controversy and division. He's already got involved with a dispute between rival Christian groups in North Africa. And the Council of Nicaea, as Greg says,
Starting point is 00:33:57 is where they come up with this statement, still known today as the Nicene Creed, and that's to deal with this debate over the nature of Christ and the relationship between the Father and the Son and the Holy Trinity. and so there's been the so-called Aryan heresy. So the way Christian Heresy's work is if you win, you name your opposing version a heresy and then you name it after a person.
Starting point is 00:34:23 So it's named after a priest called Arias, A-R-I-A-N. But basically they come up with a compromise, what is the Nicene Creed? And just in case you want to know, the compromises that the father and son are of the same substance. So he is a committed Christian at this point, we think, maybe, possibly. He's doing Christian things. He's definitely doing Christian things.
Starting point is 00:34:41 Okay. So how do you think this new found converted Christian treats his co-ruler Likinius over in the Eastern Empire? Do you think he extends him, his charitable hand, God's love, kindness? I think I can tell the answer from the way you phrase the question. I think... Am I leading too heavily? I think Constantine is a very hypocritical Christian already. I think he's very controlling and it'll justify whatever he wants to do with whatever
Starting point is 00:35:09 part of the Bible, he's just made up, or whatever. And this is all from a dream, all from a, like... Yeah, he's had visions, yeah. Yeah, I mean, and not to take anything away from Christianity, which I broadly respect, but it all feels quite opportunistic on Constantine's front. Yeah, I mean, it's hard to argue with Ivo's logic there, because...
Starting point is 00:35:31 No, lots of people have said this. So Constantine sends his brother-in-law, Bassanius, off to the court of Likinius, and Basinius is married to Anastasia. So that's the sort of family connection there. And Bersanias, it goes wrong for him quite quickly at the court of Lakinius, doesn't it? Very much so, yes. He tries to convince Lakinius to betray Constantine.
Starting point is 00:35:50 Allegedly. So Constantine has Bersenius killed. And then Constantine and Lakinas go to war. Yes, in fact, for 12 years after Milvian Bridge, although they're co-empros of brothers-in-law, they're periodically fighting each other. Finally, three to four, Constantine, and, oh, we get critical. His oldest son, Crispus, they get together.
Starting point is 00:36:12 So there was a bit of a pretext. Likinius, who had been doing Christian things, starts enacting anti-Christian measures in the East. And so Constantine uses this as a pretext to go and fight against him. And so he and Crispus defeat Lichenius. At first he says he'll spare his wife. Likinius's wife is begging him, but in the end, surprise, surprise, ends up executing him.
Starting point is 00:36:35 Oh, and of course, his son is also executed. Who would have been like him? and he is the second. And so now Constantine, and this is a big deal, no one's been emperor of the whole Roman world for some time at this point. He's now in charge of East and West. He's got the whole Roman Empire
Starting point is 00:36:50 and he's got three sons of his own. So he's in full control. Yeah, yeah. So he's now the Emperor of Everything. What happened to the Tetrarchy? Well, he's tetrarched it. Wow, fantastic. Yeah, so he's the Emperor of Everything.
Starting point is 00:37:04 East and West, Constantine, heading towards the Great, we'll see. Lucy has mentioned his children. there. So Christmas is his son with his first wife, Minavina. But he's also had five kids with his second wife Fauster. So three sons,
Starting point is 00:37:20 two daughters. Ivo, I'd love you, to guess their names, please. How many of them start with Constan? Three? Four, actually. The three boys, one girl. Right. So the girl is, but we've already had a Constancia, haven't we? His sister, who married like Ineus. Good, yes. Okay.
Starting point is 00:37:39 So Constancia must be off the table. Constant, you know. Yeah, you're nearly there. Constantella. Constantia. Tina? Constantina. Well done. Okay, Constit.
Starting point is 00:37:54 We've got one. Okay, give me the boys. Constant. Constantus. Constant. Constant. It's not my improv forte, this, I have to say. Tell me the names.
Starting point is 00:38:11 Constantine, Constance. Okay. So one is named after himself. One is named after his dad, in honor of the granddad, I suppose, and Constance. And then we have Constance. So it's Constantine, Constanceus, Constance. The daughter is Constanina. The other daughter is Helena.
Starting point is 00:38:27 Great. Named after his mum. Great. Which is nice. It's nice, right? So he's got his kids. In some ways, you can think, oh, happy families. Dynasty building.
Starting point is 00:38:35 It is very Kardashian. But it's not happy families. Because it's Constantine, of course it is. So in 326, Constantine had Fausta and Christbus killed. What do you think they had done, Ivo? Something to do with the Christianity? Mm-hmm. Not converted, not respected.
Starting point is 00:38:55 So you think they're worshipping the old gods still? Yeah, and who can blame them? Sure, okay. It's a good guess. Lucy, unfortunately, the word I'm going to have to use is a lot less charming. Incest? Oh, no. Allegedly.
Starting point is 00:39:09 the pro and anti-stor is difficult to say. So what we do know is that in 3-2-6, Constantine has Christmas executed. And Fauster dies reputedly by being locked up in a sort of heating room at the Roman Biles. And so she is dead. So he sorens her to death? He sorens, yeah, he steams her to death.
Starting point is 00:39:29 Wow. Is what happens. And so we don't know why either of them was killed or if they're connected, as is the case, we've got these problems with the sources. So the pro-Constantilian sources just say nothing. They pass over the whole thing in silence, whereas the anti-Constantine sources say they were bumped off
Starting point is 00:39:47 because they were having an as zestious relationship as stepmother and stepson. Which is sort of a standard slur in the Roman world, right? That's how you destroy your enemies, is you say they've been sleeping with the wrong person. Because you can't disprove it, right? It's a kind of, it's a trope. Absolutely. Ancest trope and getting at stepmother is another absolute part of it.
Starting point is 00:40:07 He's murdered his son, his wife, his father-in-law, his enemies, his friends, his brother-in-law, Bassanius is dead. They're kind of dropping like flies. But that's okay because he's going to build a new city. Yeah, and he's got three sons still. He's got three sons and daughters as well. His new city is, of course, called Constantinople. Very good. And do you want to tell us what he's going to do there?
Starting point is 00:40:36 What's he going to build? What would you build? If you get to start Ivopolis, your own brand new city? Well, it's infrastructure, isn't it? Well, no, it's churches, obviously, because that's got to be a big part of it for here. Sure, okay. So, but maybe also, particularly if he spends much time in York,
Starting point is 00:40:57 there'll be some castles and walls. And then, you know, maybe I've never been to Istanbul, so I'm not able to draw from present-day experience, but obviously, football stadium. You know, dental, you know, massive dental sort of studios. Air transplant surgeries, yeah, absolutely. Everything we love and benefit from today. These are all excellent guesses.
Starting point is 00:41:25 I think church was good. Yes, and not quite a football stadium, but a very famous hippodrome. Oh, great. So that's actually... Chariot racing is the number one sport in the Eastern Rwomen Empire. And it will become the high. home of the most rabid fans.
Starting point is 00:41:38 They riot and they burn the thing down. Yeah, absolutely. In the Uka riots. So tell us more a little bit about Byzantium that becomes Constantinople. Yes. Yes, it's nice to get away from the murder. So in 324, Constantine entirely rebuilds
Starting point is 00:41:54 this new city that had been Byzantium and calls it Constantinopolis. It's inaugurate. It takes six years to build, very quick by HS2 standards, and it's inaugurated in May 3,000. 30. And it's not entirely news because the tetrarch's gone around building tetrarchic capitals. But Constantinople is more than just that. It has, as obviously, it has churches. It has a Senate
Starting point is 00:42:17 House. So that's like Rome. Obviously, fortifications, as you said. It has an imperial palace with a massive great hippodrome, impressive public spaces. It's referred to as New Rome. It's referred to as as second Rome. But very much, Constantine has left his mark, so we know that in the middle of his forum there's this colossal bronze statue of him, on top of a purple column,
Starting point is 00:42:43 nearly 40 metres high in total. Just if you try to picture this, it's a classicising statue, so he was naked, holding a globe and a spear to symbolise he's emperor of everything. Ivo, if you were going to have a 40-meter naked statue of yourself,
Starting point is 00:42:57 what would you be holding? I think glovenous fears. That's fantastic. There was a boy. my prep school who was holding a globe on the front cover of the school magazine and he ate um it's not dated very well it's it's such it's such as it satisfies every like born-to-rule stereotype foreign school like an incredibly airy an eight-year-old just looking at a globe so yeah maybe maybe not um you say new rome obviously um the eastern
Starting point is 00:43:27 the eastern part of the empire spoke greek yes constantine spoke greek and latin yeah absolutely So does he code switch when he's out there? Does he speak Greek when he's in Constantinople? And then back home in Roman speaking Latin? Yeah, this is a really interesting question. And then when Justinian, who's Byzantine Empire, introduces his law code, it's still in Latin. So Latin continues being a kind of language of power.
Starting point is 00:43:50 But yeah, there's kind of code switching between Greek and Latin is definitely key to this era. Is it important politically? Yeah. I mean, obviously it becomes important later on. The Byzantine Empire is enormously powerful and, you know, keeps going to 1453. But is it important to him, to his rule?
Starting point is 00:44:04 I think it is, yes. Obviously, it's just not like any other imperial capital because it has a Senate. So it's effectively set up as a rival, a Second Rome. The Roman Senate is back in the real Rome. Hate it. And so, yeah, there's a whole new geopolitical era. We've been all of these problems on the East
Starting point is 00:44:23 and sort of facing East. Yeah, that's what will happen in the end. As you say, it's the Eastern Roman Empire, the Byzantine Empire, that will end up being the Rome that did not fall. Sure. And there's another city we need to talk about, another holy city, Jerusalem.
Starting point is 00:44:38 Do you know why we're going to talk about this? Because... No, I don't. You had such confidence for a second. It's his mum. It's Helena. What do you mean? It's his mum.
Starting point is 00:44:53 Constantine's mum. She's going on tour. She's going to go check out all the best Christian sites because she's converted to Christianity too. Because of her son? Because of her son or has her son conversing with her? No, they're different. Yeah, that's what we don't know.
Starting point is 00:45:06 The source is going both ways. So do we know when she converts and why she converts and why she ends up in Jerusalem? No, we don't know. No, no. Okay, thanks for coming. But the interesting thing is the stories are all about, oh, the whole point of the tour is to go to Jerusalem. So this is, she sets off in 3-2-6. So perhaps in the aftermath of the scandal,
Starting point is 00:45:26 the stories about her being very angry and upset about the murders of her. of Christmas and Fauster, but she heads off to the east. So she's an Augusta. So after a really bad period in her life, she's now named Augusta Empress. She goes off on this massive Eastern Tour. She doesn't just go to the Holy Land, but she does go there,
Starting point is 00:45:47 and this is part of the story later on. So she goes to Jerusalem. She goes to Bethlehem. She sees the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, the Church of the Nativity. And this story develops, not at the time, but maybe 75 years later after her death, we first can trace her.
Starting point is 00:46:05 The story comes that she discovered the relics of the True Cross. Ah. But she, I mean, she didn't, sorry. Maybe she did. Okay, so... Yeah, so she goes off on this massive tour, and she's really old at this point. I was going to say, yeah, yeah, yeah. Constantin by this point, he's in his 50s.
Starting point is 00:46:23 Yes, and so we think that by the time she dies, yeah, 3-28, she could have been around 80. So she returns home after this grand tour. she dies and her son has her buried in Rome. She is hugely important as a role model for later Byzantine empresses and of course she is declared a saint. But then so is Constantine who I think maybe devalues the brand somewhat. So Ivo we have Constantine, the first Christian Roman emperor and his mum is this sort of Christian who's gone on tour
Starting point is 00:46:51 and seen all the holy relics. So we can imagine that this faith is very important to them. So I want to ask you, at what point did Constantine get baptized as a Christian? Oh, a ludicrously late. How late can you go? Couldn't fit his head in the font. You know, 60, at the age of 60. Later than that,
Starting point is 00:47:11 later than that, 69. It's, I mean, it's as late as you can go, really, Lucy. I mean, they're quite keen on a deathbed baptism. To be fair to Constantine, deathbed baptism is quite popular in early Christianic as you're not supposed to sin after you're baptized, which is quite hard for most people. Certainly for Constantine.
Starting point is 00:47:29 going around murdering everyone. So he's probably about 65, 337. He's out east preparing for a military campaign against the Persians and he gets ill. And at this point, pretty much on his death, he's baptized by the local bishop, anti-San Constanches, brings his body to Constantinople,
Starting point is 00:47:49 which seems fitting, and he gets buried sort of with full honours in the Muslim of the Holy Apostles. And the bishop who baptizes him, Bishop Eusebius, is that the same person who is. rights of sources. No, that would be too useful. People having the same name, I'm sorry.
Starting point is 00:48:03 Euseb of Nicomedea versus Eusebius of Caesarea, sorry. I'm not everything in this episode is simple. Just one simple thing is all we want. Is this an above-averagely complicated episode? I mean, honestly, I am struggling to figure out what's happened and I'm going to be hosting this. It's a very complicated life.
Starting point is 00:48:21 I'm so sorry, Ivo. You've come in for your debut and, you know, we've thrown you a hospital pass. That's absolutely fine. I think getting tetrarchy wrong suggests that I would have struggled even with the simplest stories. Yeah, I still feel bad about that. No, not at all, please. What do you think happened to the Roman Empire after Constantine's death? You know, he had reunited it as one consolidated thing and he founded this brand new city.
Starting point is 00:48:42 What do you think happens? Strength to strength. Yeah? Yeah, absolute dynasty. Still going, isn't it? No, I think it's obviously a hotbed of opportunists, ready to jump on the grave of any freshly baptized. Constantine, I think there's, but I could work out,
Starting point is 00:49:00 one of his sons maybe. Yeah, he's got three sons and a daughter. So that should be able to have a bit of protection of the... And Constantius just did something good, didn't he? What did Constanius do? About two minutes ago? Buried his dad. Oh, he buried him. Oh, yeah, sorry.
Starting point is 00:49:17 So, yeah, I think surely the family name sort of stumbles on a little longer. I think that's a really good answer. Yeah, and basically it doesn't. but with a good bit of added murder. Yes. So Constantine, he's got these three sons. He's also got two nephews, a bit optimistically, perhaps, to have five potential successes.
Starting point is 00:49:38 So, yes, what do you think his sons do? They go on a total killing spree. They kill off the cousins. Basically, any surviving male relatives are either killed or put under house arrest. In fact, only two sort of extended family male members survive. one of whom will then become the exciting Emperor Julian, the apostate. That is a story for another day. But yeah, so we're left with Constantine the second, Constantius the second,
Starting point is 00:50:07 and Constance Empire goes on. So they split the empire three ways? So he reconciledated back into one, and they split it into three, which is the same thing that happened after Alexander the Great, isn't it? Yes, it's, well, yeah. I mean, there's a very boring, nerdy thing about how it doesn't officially get divided into some years later, but you really don't want that. So there we go.
Starting point is 00:50:27 So the Roman Empire sort of barrels on afterwards, changed, because he's introduced Christianity. Some emperors resist that again and push back again. Only, yeah, just Julian apostate. Yeah, but then eventually Christianity wins out. So it's been a wild and bloody ride. How do you feel about Constantine? Does he deserve the title The Great?
Starting point is 00:50:46 They were just doling that out, weren't they? Back in the day, like, I'm fine with that. I mean, it's very impressive what, you know, everything he's done. and I have had a fair bit of Christianity in my own life so you know, cheers. I think what's so bleak about the relentless sort of normalization of murder is like you then hear, well, the sons divide it three ways and they obviously, you know, brothers is better than nephews.
Starting point is 00:51:20 but surely if secondary family members can be dispensed with so easily how are you not constantly looking over your shoulder at your own brother as well I'm sorry to refer so incredibly basic to the opening scene of the dark night
Starting point is 00:51:35 where just every single person gets picked off as soon as they cease to be useful to the operation and that's sort of what this feels like really yeah it is I love the sort of conclusion to be the great way that comes to him is not only did he
Starting point is 00:51:49 was he such an impressive conference of the world, but he's Christian values really inspired a bit of loyalty in subsequent generations of his family. No, I'm afraid not. I mean, the son and the father were united in the Nicene Creed, but the son and the father didn't really unite politically. They were just at each other's throats, and that's the story of Rome, I'm afraid, until the fall of Rome, or the fall of the Western Roman Empire in the 470s. So there we go. That's Constantine. He's dead now. Sorry. And only just baptized. Heartbreaking. But that's the point. That's the point. Quite clean of all the sin.
Starting point is 00:52:22 The nuance window! Okay, it's time now for the nuance window. This is where Ivo and I sit quietly for two minutes, drawing up blueprints for our dream cities, while Professor Lucy takes to the forum to tell us something we need to know about Emperor Constantine. So my stopwatch is ready. Take it away, Professor Grigg.
Starting point is 00:52:44 Thank you. So as I've made it clear, it's very hard to find a reliable account of the life of Constantine. We've got these very polarised sources. we've got a propaganda, you know, the remains of a propaganda campaign that sends out to deliberately obfuscate. His legacy is very important. Not all of it is controversial, though. We do know that he brought about massively important changes, geopolitical changes. He made massive reforms in the army, the economy, obviously religion, and founded Constantinople. But he's also very famous for something he didn't do
Starting point is 00:53:16 at all, which I wanted to talk about. So as we discussed, he was baptized on his deathbed by an area bishop, Eusebius of Nicomedea, despite the Nicene Creed. It's an inconvenient fact. Don't let an inconvenient fact get in the way of the story. So a new story develops that he's baptized by a much more respectable bishop, Sylvester, Bishop of Rome. And this then becomes part of one of the most famous historical forgeries of all time, the donation of Constantine. And so the story here is that Constantine has leprosy and is cured by Bishop Sylvester. That's when he converts to Christian. and he grants Sylvester, the Pope, you might say, and the Roman Church some major powers.
Starting point is 00:53:57 So supremacy over all the churches in the world. Also, he grants to the Bishop of Rome, temporal authority over Rome and territories. And this is backed up by a document, the donation of Constantine, and that's repeatedly invoked for centuries in battles between the church and governments, but also between the church in the East and the West, who obviously are not very keen on being ruled by the church at Rome. but guess what, of course, as I've said, it's a forgery. And it doesn't get uncovered until the mid-15th century, a Renaissance humanist and indeed priest, good for him.
Starting point is 00:54:31 Lorenzo Valer proves that it was a forgery. But the legacy of Constantine as a legacy of fake news really went on for a long time. Amazing. One minute 57, that's very impressive. Incredible timekeeping. So fake news, forgeries. Is there anything legitimate about Constantine the Great? I mean, I guess there are plenty of legacies of him politically, but I mean, how do you feel about his posthumous life?
Starting point is 00:54:56 I don't know anything about it. Yeah, everything I know about Constantine's coming in the last hour. Charlie good. But I've got a statue to visit when I go to York next on tour. You do, it's a nice statue. He's sitting in his throne. Fantastic. He looks very imperial.
Starting point is 00:55:08 Are we pro or anti or neutral on Constantine the Great? I think anti. I've got to say, it sounds like a bloody nightmare. So what do you know? now. Okay, well it's time now for the quiz. This is so what do you know now? This is where we find out how much Ivo can remember from our absolutely chaotic conversation. Do I get to look at my notes? Absolutely. That's what they're for. Ivo, generally, I imagine you're quite good at quizzes. I imagine, you've said you're not, but I think you, I think you test well. That's good. It depends
Starting point is 00:55:42 how much I'm able to revise. I've done okay on a couple of quizzes. You've made some notes? And I've made some notes for this. Fab, so let's see what you do. Ten questions. I will be generous as a market because honestly some of this stuff I can't remember because it's been so chaotic. But let's have a go. Okay. Question one. What was unusual about Constantine's parents' relationship? Different classes. They were absolutely. They were sort of, you know, she was maybe lower status and he was higher status. Question two, which Christian persecuting emperor founded the first tetrarchy then retired to his garden? Of course, it was diocletian. Very good, Mr. Cabbage himself. Question three. What mode of transport did Constantine use
Starting point is 00:56:20 Very good. But in a round of a sort of not direct horse. Absolutely. Fast horses, but long way round. Fantastic. Very good. Question four. In which city was Constantine first proclaimed emperor by his army?
Starting point is 00:56:33 York. It was. Ibaricum. York. Question five. You'll accept the English translation meaning. Sorry. After receiving a vision, supposedly, what did Constantine put on his soldier's shield before the Battle of Milvian Bridge?
Starting point is 00:56:46 It's there. It's there. The Cairo. It was the Cairo. The Christian imagery. The first letters. of Christ's name in Greek. Question six, what city did Constantine found in 330?
Starting point is 00:56:55 Constantinople. It was. That's quite an easy one, isn't it? Question seven. Why did Constantine kill his wife, Fauster, and eldest son, Crispus? Incest. Supposedly. Supposedly. It's a trope.
Starting point is 00:57:07 Question eight, you're doing very well, by the way. Question eight, what happened to Constantine's co-emperor, Lichenius and his son Lakinius the second? Um... What did happen to them? I mean, dead. I'll take dead. Executed by Constantine.
Starting point is 00:57:23 Question nine. What did Helena, Constantine's mother, allegedly find in Jerusalem? Oh, some... The relics of the true cross. Absolutely. Very good. And question 10. For a perfect 10 out of 10,
Starting point is 00:57:36 Ivo Graham. When was Constantine the Great baptized? On his death bench. Yay! You've done it. Well done. Hugely impressive, given that we... Even the historians in the room didn't know what was happening
Starting point is 00:57:48 for half of the point. I mean, absolute chaos. I think you gave me the benefit of the doubt on a couple of those. No, no, I think you do very, very well. It's a one where I just rather pathetically said, murder. True. Absolutely true. Thank you so much, Ivo. I hope you've enjoyed that slightly, I mean, wild ride.
Starting point is 00:58:05 I've enjoyed it a great deal, of course. We've loved to have a new in, thank you. It's a real there but for the grace of God. Yeah. Another big thumbs up for the 21st century. And this is why you want to avoid politics, right? You've made the right decision. Comedy, not politics.
Starting point is 00:58:17 Listen, of course, if you want more murderous Roman Emperor, as check out our episodes on the rise of Julius Caesar. We've got Agrippina the Younger. We've got Emperor Nero, that's with Pat and Oswald and Mary Beard. To hear more about the Christianisation of the Roman Empire, we've got an episode in Hypatia of Alexandria. Plus, of course, we've got an episode on Constantinople, the city that Constantine founded.
Starting point is 00:58:35 We talk about the Ottoman era with Sue Perkins. If you've enjoyed the podcast, please subscribe to You're Dead to Me on BBC Sounds to hear the show 28 days earlier than anywhere else. And if you're outside the UK, you can listen at BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts. I'd just like to say a huge thank you to our guests in History Corner. We had the legendary Professor Lucy Grigg from the University of Edinburgh.
Starting point is 00:58:56 Thank you, Lucy. Pleasure. And in Comedy Corner, we had the incredible Ivo Graham, the great indeed. Thank you, Ivo. Thank you very much, great. And to you, lovely listener, join me next time as we launch another campaign into the far reaches of the past. But for now, I'm off to go and retire my microphone
Starting point is 00:59:13 and plant my vegetable garden. If it's good enough for Diocletian, it's good enough for me. Bye! Hello, it is Danny Robbins here for years now on Uncanny. We have explored real people's potentially paranormal experiences. But one thing that listeners have often asked me is why don't we look at supernatural cases from the past? Well, you asked and we listened.
Starting point is 00:59:49 Our new series, Uncanny Cold Cases, takes a deep dive into some of these stories from the most haunted house in England to the original UFO abduction cases. Can we make sense of these strange stories that have haunted history? Uncanny, cold cases. Listen on BBC Sounds. In a world where swords were sharp. And hygiene was actually probably better than you think it is.
Starting point is 01:00:22 Two fearless historians. Me, Matt Lewis. And me, Dr. Eleanor Yanaga, dive head first into the mud, blood, and very strange customs of the Middle Ages. So for plagues, crusades, and Viking raids and plenty of other things that don't rhyme. Subscribe to Gone Medieval from History Hit wherever you get your podcasts.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.