Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences.
312 episodes transcribedEverything’s bigger in Texas…especially the creeps. This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie head to the Lone Star State to answer one q...
Lock up the good silver, this week Karl & Vinnie will be making nominations for the creepiest house cleaner! Plus, We are joined by Lucy...
This week, Karl & Vinnie celebrate Presidents Day by nominating their picks for the biggest creep in our nation’s capital. We also check...
Its episode 300, Karl & Vinnie battle it out in another wildcard round—there’s no category, and all creeps are in play. Plus, we will lis...
Since Karl & Vinnie can’t seem to shut up about football on this episode, they make their nominations for the biggest creep to ever play...
This week on The Creep Off: Karl and Vinnie will finally bring peace to the middle easy by once and for all deciding on who is the biggest cr...
Who is the creepiest artist of all time? We’ll break down the nominees, watch a wild Cop Cam, and go on a Scum Parade!The score is currently...
Nap time is getting creepy this week. Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the creepiest daycare worker of all time. On Karl’s Cop C...
This week on The Creep Off, we’re headed to south America to make our nominations for the biggest creep in Venezuela! Don’t forget to vote fo...
Karl & Vinnie nominate the biggest creep of 2025 and dive into a Holiday Hangover Scum Parade. Most importantly we learn to never mock th...
Join us for our yearly Creepmas celebration! Pour some eggnog, send the kids to grandmas, and settle in for the most uncomfortable holiday tr...
This week, Karl and Vinnie head to the Crossroads of America to make their nominations for the biggest creep in the Hoosier State: Indiana....
This week, Karl and Vinnie kick off a brand-new round with a Wild Card Edition of The Creep Off — no rules, no themes, just the worst humanit...
Karl is traveling today, so Vinnie is joined by Lucy Tightbox from Once Over with Caley for a brand-new Scum Parade and the debut of “Caley’s...
’Tis the start of the holiday season, and Karl & Vinnie are kicking things off the only way they know how — by making their nominations f...
This week on The Creep Off, we’re headed to the Pacific Northwest for a brutal matchup: Who is the Biggest Creep in Portland? Vinnie and Karl...
This week on The Creep Off, Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head with their picks for Creepiest Kid. The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 3 – Gu...
Today in honor of National Homemaker Day, Karl and Vinnie roll up their sleeves and dive into the world of domestic true crime drama to uncov...
It’s the most wonderful time of the year — for creeps! Vinnie and Karl dig through the dark history of All Hallows’ Eve to crown the biggest...
Buckle up for a wild ride on this episode of the creep off! Karl & Vinnie are hitting the open road to crown the Creepiest Trucker of all...
