Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences.
291 episodes transcribedThe Creep-Off is back! Karl & Vinnie return with a brand-new category: Creepiest Rideshare Driver. Buckle up as they each nominate a true...
Karl & Vinnie are live from the Plaza Hotel for an all-out showdown to name the biggest creep in Sin City. It’s the Hackamania Battle yo...
Karl and Vinnie are back — and this time they’ve brought in their pal, the Voice of Syracuse, Brian McBride! It’s a triple-threat creep showd...
In this episode Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head in another wildcard round of the show! This is an anything-goes episode, there are no categor...
Welcome back, creepos! Karl and Vinnie are no strangers to the Sunshine State. This week, in honor of their trip to "Dabble House," they’ll b...
Grab your shopping carts, creeps—this week on The Creep-Off, Vinnie and Karl stroll down the aisles to nominate the Biggest Creep in the Supe...
Get ready to tip off March Madness the Creep-Off way! Vinnie and Karl dive into the darkest corners of college hoops history to crown the Cre...
Get ready for a twisted St. Patrick’s Day special from The Creep-Off! This week, Vinnie and Karl each nominate their pick for the most distur...
Welcome back, creepos! This week on The Creep Off, Karl and Vinnie saddle up and head to San Antonio, Texas and make their nominations for bi...
Today, Karl is on vacation, and Vinnie has accepted a challenge from Once Over with Cayley's Lucy Tightbox! Today's category: creeps who insp...
This week, we’re nominating the creepiest airline employee of all time (shocker—there are a lot to choose from). Don’t forget to vote for the...
In this episode of "The Creep Off," Karl is joined by Eric Zane for a discussion about some of the latest bizarre news stories in their scum...
This week, we’re diving into the darkest crimes from New Orleans to crown the Biggest Creep in The Big Easy. Don’t forget to vote for who bro...
This week on The Creep Off, Karl and Vinnie take their competition to the stadium, each nominating the biggest creep to ever grace the bleach...
Karl & Vinnie are back after a week off with a brand-new wild card round episode! This time, the guys go head-to-head, nominating the abs...
This week on The Creep Off, Karl and Vinnie dig deep into the dark side of presidential power, nominating the biggest creeps ever to receive...
In this episode Karl & Vinnie present their picks for the biggest creeps of 2024: On Karl’s cop cam we meet a drunk woman dressed like a...
In this week’s contest Karl & Vinnie take on the creeps of Christmas: In Karl’s cop cam we meet the most laid-back reckless driver in his...
Karl's nursing a victory hangover, but we've got the perfect remedy: a heaping dose of Scum and cop cam videos! Join us as we check out some...
Karl is back this week, and the contest continues as our hosts make their nominations for creepiest psychologist: Karl’s Cop Cam features a w...
