Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences.
308 episodes transcribedIn this episode, Karl and Vinnie nominate the creepiest zookeeper of all time. Karl also brings the dorkiest podcast in the history of podcas...
Today, Karl and Vinnie try not to murder each other as they present their nominations for Creepiest Tattoo Artist. In WATC, we check in with...
Today Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for biggest creep that works for the biggest retailer in America Walmart: In WATC we revisit t...
A new round is beginning, and the stakes have never been higher. This week, Karl and Vinnie are joined by Bryan Johnson, the voice of reason,...
This week, the score is tied, and Vinnie & Karl bring in their biggest creeps from Ukraine. In WATC, we learn about one true crime podcas...
This week Karl is on game point and Vinnie’s back is against the wall. Join them as they shine a light on the creeps who hang out by the pool...
In this episode Vinnie & Karl brings you a very special Scum Parade featuring insane stories from around the world, your voicemails, and...
Everyday across the world men and women are trusted to wield sharp metal instruments next to complete strangers' heads, in this episode Karl...
This week Karl & Vinnie celebrate Juneteenth by messing with Texas, we also celebrate Vinnie’s birthday: In WATC we feature a show hosted...
Today Karl & Vinnie finally make their nominations for the creepiest male nurse of all time: In WATC we check back in with our favorite t...
Today Karl comes to us from his new estate in Florida, and due to travel schedules, we decided to bring you a special hangover edition of the...
Today Karl & Vinnie salute the Air Force by outing some of their biggest creeps and the Karl Podcast Network is born: In WATC we listen t...
This week the PGA invaded our hometown of Rochester, Ny so we decided to nominate the creepiest golfer of all time: In WATC we check out a sh...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest Mom of all time! We believe that Mother’s Day is for the good Moms, so we de...
This week someone spins the wheel of consequences and a brand-new round begins: Karl updates us on his “go to church” consequence: In WATC we...
#163 Measure Twice, Cut Once!This week Karl & Vinnie honor the late great Jerry Springer by nominating the creepiest guest from the Jerry...
In this Philadelphia hangover edition of the Creep Off Vinnie gets unexpected news right before the show goes live, Karl spills the beans on...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their Nominations for biggest creep from the city of Brotherly Love Philadelphia (VOTE HERE): In WATC we rev...
This week Karl & Vinnie nominate the biggest creeps in Easter history, as always the choice is yours VOTE HERE: In WATC we listen to a mu...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for biggest creep from Ohio VOTE HERE: In WATC we meet two self-proclaimed iconic twenty-...
