Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences.
291 episodes transcribedThis week Karl & Vinnie make their Nominations for biggest creep from the city of Brotherly Love Philadelphia (VOTE HERE): In WATC we rev...
This week Karl & Vinnie nominate the biggest creeps in Easter history, as always the choice is yours VOTE HERE: In WATC we listen to a mu...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for biggest creep from Ohio VOTE HERE: In WATC we meet two self-proclaimed iconic twenty-...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest Airbnb Host (VOTE HERE): In the scum parade we meet the disgraced Rev. Popad...
Karl is off this week so joining Vinnie to make his nomination for "Creepiest Hog Farmer" is our pal Bryan Johnson from Tell'em Steve Dave &a...
This week Karl & Vinnie celebrate St. Patrick’s Day by making their nominations for the biggest creep from the emerald isle: In WATC this...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creep from the year 1955: In WATP we discovered that Yeardley Smith in rea...
This weel Karl & Vinnie kick of a new round with a wildcard matchup: In WATC find out what happens when you mix Martini's & Murder......
This week's episode started with some serious tech issues, but that did not stop us from making our nominations for creepiest clerk: In WATC...
In observance of Valentine's Day Karl & Vinnie have decided to celebrate true love by making their nominations for creepiest couple: This...
This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest meth enthusiast: In WATC Patty C-Cups returns with a new show titled “Of Men &...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest plumber: In WATC Karl reviews a podcast that has no business being in the tr...
Join Karl & Vinnie as they make their nominations for creepiest senior citizen. In this week's WATC Karl introduces us to a true crime po...
This week Karl & Vinnie hit the ice and make their picks for creepiest hockey player of all time: In WATC we meet a host who is legit pis...
This week Karl and Vinnie explore the world of people who think they know how to fix everyone else, Self-Help Gurus. We also make a big annou...
This week Karl spins the wheel, the scoreboard is reset, and we start the new game with a wildcard round.Check out the stories from this week...
in this episode Karl & Vinnie kiss 2022 goodbye with the help of “Tell’em Steve Dave" & “Would You Kindly’s” Bryan Johnson we decide...
In this very special Creepmas edition of the show we celebrate Karl's birthday with the biggest holiday themed creeps we could find, and we f...
This week Karl and Vinnie determine who is the creepiest Mall Santa of all time: In WATC we finally learn "Why We Drink": In the Scum Parade...
In honor of the World Cup, Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest footballer: In WATC we meet the ladies from New Zealand based...
