Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences.
291 episodes transcribedThis week we follow Creeps-giving with our very first "Black Friday" themed episode: In WATC Karl discovered a brand-new true crime podcast t...
Karl and Vinnie celebrate another Creepsgiving with the worst creep's Thanksgiving has to offer: In WATC we prove that we are better than "Tr...
In this episode Vinnie spins the wheel of consequences, and we kick off the new round with a no holds barred wildcard match: In WATC we prove...
This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest "Chad" inadvertently creating the most important vote in Creep Off History: Ou...
This week we give last year’s Halloween episode the sequel it deserves: In WATC Karl proves that the “the Vanished” podcast sucks: In the Scu...
This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for biggest creep from the Garden State of New Jersey: Karl read the letter we received from...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the creepiest information technology specialist: in this weeks “Who are these Creeps”...
This week Karl and Vinnie mow down the Motor City by nominating the biggest creeps from Detroit. This one might be hard to listen to, especi...
In this episode your heroes give you a special Scum Stream from an Air B&B in Detroit with their pal Trucker Andy; check out the stories...
This week Karl and Vinnie memorialize Tucker Dixon's epic roast bomb by making their nominations for creepiest male stripper: Karl debuts his...
In this very special live supersized episode not only do Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest “Karl & Vinnie” they are...
This week Karl is traveling back from Los Angelos so Vinnie is joined by Brian Mcbride & Cros to nominate the biggest creeps in the Briti...
In honor of Labor Day this week Karl and Vinnie made their nominations for Creepiest Communist: In the Scum parade we meet a pervy-pedo-photo...
When we last left Karl & Vinnie, they were tied 4-4 in this round, will one of them spin the wheel or will yet another controversy prevai...
This week Karl & Vinnie try to pick the biggest creep from a category we don’t care to share in the descriptions: In the scum parade we m...
In this episode Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creeps that work at Mcdonalds: In the scum parade we check in on ano...
In this episode Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creep in Alabama's Jersey...the Magnolia State Mississippi: This wee...
In the very first Vinnie-less edition of the Creep Off Blind Mike joins Karl to make their nominations for the creepiest mascot of all timeFo...
In this episode Karl & Vinnie celebrate America's favorite pastime by making their nominations for creepiest baseball player: In the Scum...
On today's episode Karl & Vinnie welcome their new pal Pat Dixon from the NYC Crime Report joins us to find out who is the biggest creep...
