Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences.
308 episodes transcribedThis week Vinnie & Karl nominate their candidates for biggest creep of 2005: The boys announce their plan for new bonus episodes, and we...
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest bowler: The boys deal with the fall out of their humiliating loss to Kaya: I...
This week Karl & Vinnie are joined by our pal Kaya to find the creepiest Trans person: Karl lays out Vinnie’s podcast consequence and giv...
This week we welcome Trucker Andy in studio to join Karl & Vinnie in submitting their nominations for creepiest porn actor/actress: In th...
This week Karl in Vinnie head into the wild blue yonder and search for the creepiest airline: Karl still hates Anthony Fauchi: In the Scum Pa...
This week Karl and Vinnie are joined by their pals Cros and Kevin to nominate their candidates for creep of the year! In the Scum Parade we m...
In this holiday special Vinnie & Karl search for the biggest Christmas creep: In the scum parade the boys visit their home town, we meet...
This week in honor of Karl’s safe return we search the Sunshine State for the Creepiest Floridian: Karl gets called out for not fulfilling hi...
This week Vinnie & Karl scour TV news to find their nominees for creepiest news anchor. Karl reveals his Nick Bate opus and we pick out a...
In this week’s wild card edition of the show Karl spins the wheel while Vinnie laughs his tits off: Karl unveils another Nick Bate cover and...
This week Karl & Vinnie search for Thanksgiving themed Creeps: Karl releases a new a Nick Bate cover track & some new consequences ar...
This week Vinnie and Karl search the highways and byways for the creepiest long road trucker: In the Scum Parade we meet the unconcerned fath...
The week Vinnie & Karl are joined by Brandon from @shittysongpod to discover the creepiest song: In this weeks scum parade we meet a man...
In this week’s episode Karl & Vinnie search for the creepiest female cop on the force: Karl unveils another Nick Bate cover song for his...
On this week’s episode Vinnie & Karl search for the creepiest member of a politician’s family. Karl reveals 3 tracks from his Nick Bate c...
This week Karl & Vinnie are joined by the original Co-Host of WATP Kevin for this 2020 Wild Card episode. In the Scum Parade we meet a re...
This week Vinnie & Karl shift through the trash to find out who is the world’s creepiest garbage man. These creeps don’t deserve the titl...
This week someone spins the wheel of consequences! The boys go head to head in another no holds barred potpourri edition to kick of the new r...
So this is one of those episodes where we should start with an apology, this episode gets dark when Karl & Vinnie search the dark web for...
Hooray for Hollywood! This week Vinnie & Karl nominate their choices for creepiest film director! In the scum parade we learn it’s toughe...
